Has our presence in Afghanistan helped their economy? Profits from heroin trafficking have never been higher.?

Question

It is ironic that before we entered Afghanistan, the Taliban had eradicated much of the poppy fields and had dramatically decreased heroin production. Now, that they are at war with us they have increased production to record levels in order to buy weapons and other material they need to fight our military. Beware of unintentional consequences.

Answer 1

You're right. Its too bad the new government isn't strong enough to take over in this area where the Taliban left off.

Has it helped their economy? Doubt it. They pay the workers, of course, but I imagine the profits line the pockets of the few. Probably the arms bought are imported.

Answer 2

Since heroin is illegal, the gov't cannot impose a tax on it, so it does not help the economy.

Answer 3

We help them in many ways than one. We're the number one purchaser of the item you've mentioned as well, and may be the number one producer of the wepon they purchase as well.

Answer 4

yes