If 99% of all ILLEGAL immigrants today were white europeans?

Question

Would descendants of white europeans living here in America have a problem with that. I'm not trying to offend anyone or be racist. I'm just curious because we talked about this in my ethnic studies class.

Answer 1

It's not possible.
Europe is an ocean and continent away (from the Southwest where the illegal problem is happening) and white people in general are into following the rules. We just don't defy authority in huge numbers like that. All you have to do is check your history and statistics to see I'm telling the truth. It's a cultural thing. That's why it's so newsworthy when someone is counter culture or demonstrates or whatever, because that isn't the norm in white or European culture. You're asking if the ridiculous happened, what would be our response? The response would have to be just as ridiculous as the impossible behavior.
Just as ridiculous...if European settlers had actually killed off all of the previous inhabitants, as we are often accused of doing, and had become the population south of the border, they would have become part of the United States and the states of what is now Mexico would be states within the United States.
But since it was a country with it's own ethnic groups and culture, they opted to remain independant.
See, no matter how I look at it, we don't get to masses of illegal white people climbing the fence, strewing litter, and making false accusations of mass murder and racism.
It's a class of cultures and laws, not races.
Race is just an excuse.

Answer 2

Most Americans have no problem with illegal immigrants, only some were upset over illegal immigration issues because they were fooled by some people who want people to fight each other.


It should be noted that even some Hispanic Americans are upset over illegal Hispanic immigrants.



Would descendants of white Europeans living here in America have a problem if 99% of all ILLEGAL immigrants today were white Europeans?

No, but there will always some who have problem because they were fooled.


In most cases in history, it's always the minority (like a thief) who attacked the majority (like a household), but we are fooled that it's the other way around.

Answer 3

A lot of them are. I really don't understand when Mexicans became considered a different color. If you look at government reports they will say, for example, that the city of Maywood it 80% white, then later say that about 90% is Hispanic. That is where the term 'non-Hispanic white' comes from on all of the forms.

Whatever.

It would depend on if it lessened the impact. European polls for example show that an overwhelmingly large majority there think you need to learn the language of a country you move to, and European immigrants tend to be more educated, and so the impacts would be different, particularly on our schools, which is my particular hot button.

If you mean due to race, though, it would stilll be a huge problem. 12 to 20 million illegals is a huge negative impact. Earlier debates dealt with much smaller numbers. When you add the poverty of those immigrants and the fact that they can't pay enough taxes (being poor) even to cover their family's education, the number translates to ruined schools and closing emergency rooms, none of which has anything to do with racism.

Answer 4

You know, there is truth in this remark but one of the prime reasons that racial orientation has become such a hallmark of mostly illegal Mexicanos immigrants is that many either don't or won't learn to speak English. The other reason is that they have been allowed to come into the USA in huge numbers.
This has been permitted by our government and is being overlooked.
In the past, many different people from all over the world have come here but they more or less did so legally. Those folks, the Irish, the Germans etc. were shown descrimination in extreme ways. One thing that was not done, was to allow them into the land and then start handing all our tax dollars over to them to teach their kids in a foreign language, to deliver their babies and turn them into citizens when the parents were here illegally and to in essence encourage the movement by not enforcing the law.
of immigration.

I personally do not like the idea of illegal people of any sort coming into my country at a time like now. Who are all these foreign people and what harm could they do to America?
I think of this everytime I am darned near strip searched when I want to board an airplane. Why are our SOOOOOOO cautious government agencies not so worried about the illegal criminals that steal into our country with drugs and other forms of mayhem to do to us?
In reality the issue is not racism but the lack of law enforcement has caused it to become that now. This is yet another HUGE destructive blow to the USA and all it's attempts to be racially intergrated and fair with all people. The truth and hope and thousands of lives have all been lost simply because our Federal Government has not made any real and effective enforcement of immigration issues.
It's a crying shame this has come about and it slashs me to my heart.

Answer 5

I just answered another question dealing with this. Let me put it this way...in the "white" dictionary under illegal you'll see Mexican. Just like under terrorist you'll see muslim and under criminal you'll see blacks/african american.
Being a new immigrant to america myself, i too even feel brained washed by the media into thinking only mexicans are illegals.

Fact is if all illegals were white (and about 50% of them CURRENTLY are) they would be welcomed and are being welcomed than why the NEWS never ever shows white illegals....think about it..when was the last time you seen a group of white illegals on TV...NEVER.

Bush would come up with something like
"these europeans were here first (never mind the indians they killed to get here) and we are in fact in their home".

Welcome to the real world.God Bless America

EDIT: ITS FUNNY HOW SOME PEOPLE LIKE TO BEND THE LAWS TO SUITE THEIR OWN PURPOSE COMPARING BREAKING LAWS TO HOTEL?

2 MEN GOT A GUN.
One has a licenced the other not licenced. Each man plans and premeditates to use that gun and goes out and kills an innocent person. Who's breaking the law?

Answer 6

Illegal is NOT (I repeat NOT) a race!!!!

Bluddy_we: you can not compare the term illegal with the N-word. Calling someone illegal is not insulting or hateful or derogatory. You can change your status of being illegal by becoming a citizen. You can NOT change your race!! You are correct in mentioning the illegal Canadiens and Asians living in the US. But you fail to mention the MILLIONS of illegal Mexicans living here. Why is that???? I wonder.......

Yes Americans would have a problem with white illegals, black illegals, Asian illegals, etc being in the US illegally!! Being illegal is being illegal!!

Answer 7

In a feeling they have been very corresponding to unlawful immigrants. The white guy got here here and conquered all that stood of their way. truthfully, the white guy could desire to have tried to stay in peace and team spirit with the community individuals and could desire to have found out their strategies. however the white guy replaced into grasping, and that they needed each and every little thing for themselves somewhat of sharing, so the white guy wiped out complete tribes of harmless people killing adult adult males, women persons, babies, previous and youthful in simple terms so they could enhance their territories. i'm of specially Irish and Scottish good, and the feared British did an analogous to my ancestors homelands, yet the two way it does not make issues perfect.

Answer 8

Absolutely. If 12 million of any race was here illegally [in this day and age] I would have a problem with it.

Answer 9

I just wanted to make a quick comparison for most of the moorons who posted here and other places on this subject... For those of you who compare the visa-overstayers to illegal-mexicans (using mexican cause that is your comparison) look at it like this...........

1) You checked into a hotel room and check out is 11am you look at the clock and it is 11:30 am - visa overstayers

2) You broke into a hotel room and took a siesta - illegal border crossers

Who do you think the hotel will prosecute?

Answer 10

I'm white American, and yes i wouldn't like white illegals being here. in my opinion illegal has not color. if they are illegal then they need to become legal or go home.