Sunni muslim answer plz…what the criteria you have for true and healthy hadees (hadith)?

Question

As you see the various ahadith dmoralize the personality of prophet so we can say that its sick and also tell that what the true source of prophet saying ashab( companion) or family of prophet especially ALI who is also companion, brother, infallible, khalifa, lion of GOD, husband of prophet’s only one and loving daughter, most trustworthy of ISLAM, I think no be compare with ALI and this man also never worship of idol as other did the whole life of ALI is pure than other so is there any true source accept ALI if you agree so why no more ahadith narrated by this man in your books and you say that these are sahih (correct)

elgamma if your finger cant be equal so how can be companion equal is ab sufyan and abu bakar is equal?

xxangelch i never heared that any shea muslim give priotiy ALI on prophet muhammad here you are wrong and as concern sahih bukhari there is mostly are sahih but majority are suspecious

Answer 1

I'm afraid that your English was rather difficult for me to follow. Besides I'm not a Sunni Muslim, but a Christian who knows a bit about the Qua'ran and Islam.

If I've got you right, what you're asking is what can one do about the hadiths in the Qua'ran that make Mohammad look bad?

Well, frankly, nothing; unless you want to "corrupt" the Qua'ran like you claim was done with the Torah and the Bible, isn't it?

In fact, that editing was already done by the Calph Omar who destroyed all the other versions of the Qua'ran that he could lay his hands on in his attempt to bring about the One "True" [Edited] Version.

I'm not sure if I understood what the question was about Shi'at Ali, though.

He was Mohammads relative who married his only surviving daughter - Fatima, is correct. That Fatima was Mohammads only child is wrong, though. Mohammad had many other children, but they all died in infancy.

If we're talking about Mohammad bin Abd'allah bin Abd'ul al Mutailib, aka Mohammad al rasool; then, he had these children of Khadijah: Sons: * Abd-Allah ibn Muhammad * Qasim ibn Muhammad; Daughters: * Ruqayyah bint Muhammad * Umm Kulthum bint Muhammad * Zainab bint Muhammad and * Fatima Zahra. He also had a son of Maria: * Ibrahim ibn Muhammad

All other children died in their infancy except Fatima who was later given in marriage to Shi'at Ali.

As you know,Shi'at Ali left Mohammad when he married the 9 year old Aisha and nominated her father - Abu Bak'r as the Caliph; and that was the beginning of the Shias!

Now, what is shahih or not, is known only to Allah, isn't it?

Hope this helped.

Cheers!

Simon Templar

Answer 2

The criteria for a True Hadeeth (Sahih) are:-

1) The Hadeeth has full chain of narratives. And NOT even one should be broken.

2) The persons who narrated the Hadeeth must be of Good character and faith.

3) The chain of two persons must indicate that they were of the same time and period, which will ensure the possibility that they must have met.

And a True hadeeth will never contradict with the Quran. The hadeeth is NOT from the Prophet's mind. As ALLAH tells us in the Quran, that indeed it is a revelation that comes to the Prophet by ALLAH's will.

The Problem with Shia muslims is that they have given so much importance on the (Ahl-el-Baith) The people of the House of Prophet (PBUH).

Though we respect each sahabi (companion), in no way we adore them. The real Islam is to carry the flame of pain that the prophet (PBUH) and his companions carried in their heart.

True Islam would be to convey the world the beauty and logic about our religion -The Religion of peace and truth. Why dont we throw silly deiiferences and unite for the sake of ALLAH???

" And the BEST in the sight of ALLAH amongst you is the One who is more pious, more GOD-fearing"

Answer 3

Sahih Bukhari is the best one.
one reason why they might have stopped publishing is how some Sheas's talk about ALI. We had a huge Friday talk about this subject. some Muslims (sheas) are making ALi sound like Mohamed (PBUH) which is not right. in another gathering I even heard someone compare ALI to Jesus, Ali was a man Jesus was a prophet, thats not right. Ali was a dear friend of Mohamed and his daughters husband but you can't compare him to Mohamed PBUH or Jesus or anything. but My mom got us the Sahih Bukhari books. they are very good and mostly easy read.

Answer 4

First of All i don't believe in Shiite Sunni grouping......i know there was no such grouping at muhammad times so no use of following it......But Unfortunatly it is there ....Secondly i m afraid that there is no such criterias to judge a Hadith....i go for Bukhari and Muslim, but i batter take quran and just compare the both whether they are condradicting or not ! about Muhammad life so its our common sense that tell us what is right and what is wrong....but these books are good to get the things

And About Ali , so no doubt he was the most precious person, Sunni do follow him and love him.....Problems is with Shiaa peoples actualy, Do you respect others Caliphs? Well i have heard some shiite peoples abusing Omer, AbuBaker and Usman....IS this fair with them? See Sunnis respect all and Shiaa don't ! thats a reality and actualy a pianful one ! When our prophet Loved Abu baker, Omer and Usman , who are we to disobey him? why Shiaa peoples insult them? thats something i could never get .well if you don't agree with them, its your choice ,but do respect them, thats my beleive !

And Secondly Ali was Muhammad(pbuh) 's relative and good companion but others were as well, so its no problem if we follow Abu Huraira' or Ayesha's source too.

Take care !

Answer 5

1- The authenticity of sources.
2- the continuety of the sources.
3- Lack of abnormality, I.E. Contracdiction to the Holy Quran, or actual deeds of the prophet.
4- Lack of weirdness, or extreme strange context.

By that.. Many of Bukhari Hadiths goes wrong.. and Many of Al Kafi, Goes wrong.. but Sunnis and Shiia, most of them, hate to admit it.

Abu Haneefa, the great Scholar that influenced most of Muslim nations, as they follow his way in studying and teaching for Islam, accepted ONLY 17 (SEVENTEEN) hadiths of about 200000.. we must remember here the saying of Abu Lo'lo'a before his death to Omar Ibn Khattab:

"I've planted in your culture 10000 un real Hadiths, prohibiting the halal, and spreading the haram."

I myself can accept all hadiths, but when we come to that contradicts with Quran or Actual deeds of the prophet, or even the logic thinking, I must be cautious.

Ali is a good man, and the differences between Sunni and Shii are no more the differences between Sunnah and themselves, or Shiia and themselves, we are all brothers.. for some political reasons, Some Sunni political leaders and some Shii political leaders refuse each other.. It's not of religion but of policy and political interests.

Answer 6

As i understand Sunni Muslim don't have any problem with Ali and even love him so there is a wrong branch of sunni who's named "al-Qaida" they are trying to destroy Real Sunni Muslim people's view, I am sure all Sunni and Shia Muslim are brothers and respect each other very much.

Answer 7

I usually refer to Sahih Bukhari.

Answer 8

Ayesha "R.A".. is the Prophet's loved spouse, and he ??? ???? ???? ? ??? died even as his head is between her chest and neck. Allah ?????? ? ????? stated about the different halves of the Prophet: "And stay on your residences. Bedizen no longer yourselves with the bedizenment of the Time of lack of expertise. Be usual in prayer, and pay the undesirable-due, and obey Allah and His messenger. Allah's wish is yet to eliminate uncleanness some distance from you, O individuals of the family members, and cleanse you with an intensive cleansing." "The Prophet is in route of the believers than their selves, and his different halves are (as) their moms. " 33:6

Answer 9

there is no body pure more than the others ----they are all equal in islam


yes

Answer 10

look up my website
www.hadices.com
[e-mail]