Someone ran over my dog, I know who it was, Is there anything I can do so that they will replace him?

Question

Should I ask them to replace it, or should I try to take them to civil court? I don't want the money I want a puppy. Nothing will replace my puppy, Scrappy.

Answer 1

You could approach the person first. Take a friend because these kinds of things can get ugly fast. Be polite and don't get in their face about it. That will only get their backs up and yo will be lucky not to get bodily thrown off the property at least.

If you can't get satisfaction from the driver, go to the police. next and make a report. You may even have an admission from the driver from your previous discussion. PLus you'll have a witness to that admission.

If you can't get help from the police, you can try small claims court. Don't expect much though.

The problem is that your dog should not have been running loose on the street to get run over. That was your fault, I'm sorry to say. (Unless he was on the leash at the time he got hit, in which case, you may be able to prove malicious intent to kill your dog.)
If the dog was in the street uncontrolled, the cops or the courts are not going to do much to help you.

As far as replacing your dog, if you can't get the driver to do that for you, you can usually find whole litters of very nice pups at a shelter beginning in late March and April. Fewer are available now, but soon shelters will be overwhelmed with them. Usually the cost is not much, and often it includes the first shots and spay/neuter.PLus you'll be saving a life.

Just please this time control your pup. Leashes and fences are the key.

Answer 2

Your dog is personal property. When someone damages your personal property by intentional or even negligent acts, there are legal remedies available. Most likely you will receive monetary damages equivalent to what a comparable dog would cost. However, my suggestion is that you approach them and request that they buy you a comparable dog to replace the one they killed. If they don't, then you turn to the law. Unfortunately, if you must turn to the law, you will spend more on a lawyer than it would cost you to buy a new dog, unless you take them to small claims court. Usually, the threat of a lawsuit is enough to scare someone into negotiating with you, even a complaint filed in small claims court. Go to your local courthouse to receive info on how you go about filling a claim. Where i'm from the claim must be less than $2000 to be filed in small claims. Good luck.

Answer 3

So sorry for your loss. Scrappy is a cute name. Ask them to get you a new dog and if they say no than you can take them to court and win.

Answer 4

I am so sorry. Call the police and report it first. It is against
the law. Talk to the person and don't lose your temper when
doing so. Ask the person if they intend to replace your dog,
if not than definetly seek a civil suit. One tip, that is helpful,
when you talk to this person , if you have a tape recorder bring
it with you cause you may find it will be very helpful.

Answer 5

Well call the police first what he/she has done is illegal and inhumane. They deserve some legal trouble. Then take the police report and bring it to a lawyer they do free consolations most of the time and see what they think. I would go for money then take the money and find yourself a dog. Do you really want them psychos to pick a dog out for you?

Answer 6

Unfortunately for you, dogs are consider property and you can only get replacement cost in court. You can not get any otter damages for loss of consortium or emotional trauma unless this person did it on purpose and in front of you.

so if you take them to court you would only be entitled to any vet fees paid and replacement costs

Answer 7

Hit and run even if its with an animal is a crime. If you report it to the police you better be sure who it was. Then you can either prosecute or drop the charges for the cost of a new pup. I am very sorry for your loss take care.

Answer 8

Depends what state you live in but probably not most states have leash laws.If the dogs not on a leash its considered your fault.But maybe if you talk to the people they will be nice and get you a puppy they might not know who's dog it was.

Answer 9

I'm sorry to hear of your loss however, if your dog was hit in the road then the responsibility is yours not the person who hit your dog.

Answer 10

you're accurate. Punishing via putting him contained in the crate isn't operating and could not in any respect artwork. via the time the canine comes decrease back he's now no longer operating away. He thinks you're locking him up reason he got here decrease back. The crate isn't education him to go back decrease back, yet quite to save him away longer. What you need to do is -- Get a toddler gate and placed it up. ascertain the canine is behind the gate any time the door is opened. this can save him from operating outdoors. -- practice him to "come" on command. If he will come to you, in spite of if he's desirous to run away, then you definately gained't might want to rigidity about it any extra. -- quite of creating use of rooster cord or in spite of plastic fencing you're utilising you opt for to get something sturdier. placed up a timber fence, typhoon fence, or something that could't be pulled aside or crawled via. -- position a double layer of fencing in case you may merely use rooster cord. Have 2 fences truly. one which likely already has holes and one about 6 inches behind the first one. even as the canine tries to flee from fence #a million he will be stopped via fence #2. If he starts off digging lower than the fence you opt for to position fence on the floor about 3 ft into the backyard and canopy it with dirt. even as he starts off digging he will hit fence and could no longer be in a position to dig out lower than it. -- placed the canine on a lengthy line contained in the backyard between the homestead and a tree yet no longer on the fringe of the fence. he receives to run round yet should not be in a position to get out. particularly, practice and exercising extra.