Trying to prove God to an atheist....?

Question

Trying to prove God to an atheist is like trying to prove your shirt is red to a blind man.

Am I right?

Opinion?

What if he was born blind?

Answer 1

You can't prove God to an atheist. He doesn't exist and atheists don't need a god.

Mind your own spiritual business.

Answer 2

no, the probability of a red shirt existing is very high. you explain to the blind person that colour is the reflected wave length of light that sighted people can sense and distinguish between. you can prove light exists by shining a light so he can sense the heat produced by the light and use the analogy of different pitches of sound to get some understanding of how colour can be sensed in different forms, red being a low note blue high. my nephew has no problem understanding this. you cannot tell me what wavelength the supernatural is because there is nothing to measure, you cannot reassure me that it does exist by letting me experience any of the supernaturals other physical manifestations. god/gods are a totally abstract concept with no physical phenomena that can be directly experienced in exactly the same form by everybody. i, even as an atheist, understand the conception of god/gods as well as any believer, so unlike a blind person i can directly experience the abstraction, but reject it as a logical fallacy.

Answer 3

No. The blind man really exists unlike God.

Answer 4

properly, it rather is a distinctive argument. first of all it rather is impossible in maximum situations to instruct a unfavorable. the way maximum theists postulate God it could be impossible to instruct his nonexistence. Secondly, in spite of if what you assert is real, that may not interior the least data of God's life. We combat against the have self assurance in God because of the wear we % out that thought does to society. i've got not got time to render an exhaustive record however the highlights could contain: the Spanish Inquisition, the dark an prolonged time generally, the Crusades, the persecution of the Huguenots, periodic waves of violent antisemitism and these days efforts to dam stem cellular analyze, anti-gay discrimination and efforts to instruct my toddlers rubbish (i.e. clever layout) in technology type. Peace.

Answer 5

Sort of, but the analogy breaks down when examined. It gets a little better if everyone is color blind, the shirt happens to be white, and you're trying to convince everyone that it is red and that this means we should hate certain people. also, no possible scientific instrument can detect color.

Answer 6

Trying to prove god doesnt exist to a believer is like talking to a brick wall

Answer 7

The issue, Adia, is that there can be no proof of something that transcends the system on which proofs are made. Belief in God is just that: belief. If you believe, fine. If you don't believe, fine. Don't try to proove the unproovable.

Answer 8

even a blind man can understand the concept of red
but how does the blind man trust you enough to know that you are telling the truth about the colour of the shirt

Answer 9

Trying to prove the nonexistence of God to a theist etc. etc.

I've long said, let's talk probability. Which God would you like to discuss, the Christian God or Allah or Zoltar or Zeus?

Answer 10

So... there's a special part in your body that lets you detect this god, that atheists lack?

Fortunately, since bodies are machines, we can create machines to replicate its function.

Would you care to explain how this god-sensing organ works, and where it is located?