DO MUSLIM MALES SQUAT TO URlNATE LIKE FEMALES?

Question

When you compare what men have said in different hadiths, you will find a number of contradictions.

For example, Bukhari (4/60.62) wrote that
“the prophet (pbuh) urinated in standing position.”
But Ibn Hambal (6.192) wrote that
“the prophet (pbuh) never urinated in standing position.”

Now these are supposed to be authentic (genuine) hadiths. There is no way you can believe both of those statements. Their statements show how accurate they are. On top of all that, what difference does it make how the prophet urinated!

According to reliable Islamic sources, Muhammad never stood while urinating except in one case when the place which he was at was too dirty to squat. That was probably the only exception. At all other times, Muhammad squatted. We have to assume he squatted because there are no toilet bowls during the time of Muhammad. Unless…perhaps some muslim can prove otherwise.

Answer 1

Hey you yourself have answered the contradiction here
"According to reliable Islamic sources, Muhammad never stood while urinating except in one case when the place which he was at was too dirty to squat. That was probably the only exception."
Ibn Hambali may be a pious man but when it comes to authentic hadith we reject his stance. Possibly he might not have got this hadith at that time


However, we believe that urine is dirty and we should save ourselves from its spills. If we stand than its likely that spill would fall on our body. However, if surface is soft and we have problem sitting in this position than its allowed to stand

Answer 2

It is not because of no facilities or for any other reasons. It is more to educating the people how they should do things right. It teaches the individual to behave like humans and not to do it like the animal are doing it. The subject teaches us about moral values, hygiene, environmental cleanliness, personality and conduct. It is more to learning values than making a comparison of what the Prophet Muhammad S.A.W. ( pbuh ) had done.

Answer 3

you really have too much jealously of Islam. try to calm down a little.. calm down.

you are so picky in picking small details of books, but ignoring the biggest verses in the Quran talking about worshiping one God, believe in all prophets of God, give charity, help the needy, kindness toward parents, orphans , poor.... you are letting all this and talking about urine? God will question you on everything u had know, he knows what's wisper in ur heart.

Answer 4

Firstly, Hadiths have grades of authencity, that Scholars spend years determining. Based on Chains of Narration and other things to classify them.

Mustalah books speak of a number of classes of hadith in accordance with their status. The following broad classifications can be made, each of which is explained in the later sections:

* According to the reference to a particular authority, e.g. the Prophet (may Allah bless him and grant him peace), a Companion, or a Successor; such ahadith are called marfu' (elevated), mauquf (stopped) and maqtu' (severed) respectively .
* According to the links in the isnad, i.e. whether the chain of reporters is interrupted or uninterrupted, e.g. musnad (supported), muttasil (continuous), munqati' (broken), mu'allaq (hanging), mu'dal (perplexing) and mursal (hurried).
* According to the number of reporters involved in each stage of the isnad, e.g. mutawatir (consecutive) and ahad (isolated), the latter being divided into gharib (scarce, strange), 'aziz (rare, strong), and mashhur (famous).
* According to the manner in which the hadith has been reported, such as using the (Arabic) words 'an ("on the authority of"), haddathana ("he narrated to us"), akhbarana (- "he informed us") or sami'tu ("I heard"). In this category falls the discussion about mudallas (concealed) and musalsal (uniformly-linked) ahadith. [Note: In the quotation of isnads in the remainder of this book, the first mode of narration mentioned above will be represented with a single broken line thus: ---. The three remaining modes of narration mentioned above, which all strongly indicate a clear, direct transmission of the hadith, are represented by a double line thus: ===.]
* According to the nature of the matn and isnad, e.g. an addition by a reliable reporter, known as ziyadatu thiqah, or opposition by a lesser authority to a more reliable one, known as shadhdh (irregular). In some cases, a text containing a vulgar expression, unreasonable remark or obviously-erroneous statement is rejected by the traditionists outright without consideration of the isnad: such a hadith is known as munkar (denounced). If an expression or statement is proved to be an addition by a reporter to the text, it is declared as mudraj (interpolated).
* According to a hidden defect found in the isnad or text of a hadith. Although this could be included in some of the previous categories, a hadith mu'allal (defective hadith) is worthy to be explained separately. The defect can be caused in many ways; e.g. two types of hadith mu'allal are known as maqlub (overturned) and mudtarib (shaky).
* According to the reliability and memory of the reporters; the final judgment on a hadith depends crucially on this factor: verdicts such as sahih (sound), hasan (good), da'if (weak) and maudu' (fabricated, forged) rest mainly upon the nature of the reporters in the isnad.

Peace Be With You

Answer 5

WHY do you care?? Does it really matter how anyone urinates? I know some women who do this standing, like men. Will you tear them apart too?

Stop getting your information from inaccurate sources.

Answer 6

No, We Urinate standing.. just like you :-D...

Do you think that someone, not a prophet.. but anyone.. will bring people to watch him while peeing? how old are you?

"According to reliable Islamic sources"? please state your sources.. because the info in ur question are fake...

Are you really concerned with "how a man, 1400 years ago, used to pee? :) :)

Answer 7

you may desire to be careful once you quote somebody. i'm valuable Zakir on no account stated each and each Muslim guy could desire to marry greater women. by skill of asserting this you're making it look like Zakir is inflicting issues by skill of making it crucial for each Muslim guy to have distinctive better halves while you your self are making formidable statements(misquoting) and attributing them to Zakir. The Quran on no account makes it a compulsion to marry distinctive better halves. It says in financial disaster 4 Verse 3 ....Marry women people of your determination in twos, threes and fours yet once you cant do justice between them then marry basically one.... So it rather is obviously obtrusive what the Quran is asserting and in case you recognize English precise then you fairly won't misread it. in case you think Zakir to be an recommend of polygamy then kindly clarify why he himself has basically one spouse? For now enable us to be sparkling that Islam does not make it a compulsion to have distinctive better halves. It basically provides the permission on social gathering yet prefers for adult men to marry basically one spouse. Going by skill of your call I take it which you're a Hindu. What do you may desire to assert approximately lord krishna having mora than 16000 better halves? don't be a hate monger. attempt and comprehend Islam in its real essence and you shall prevail Insh-Allah. As on your question to what's going to happen if the opposite occurs, we are going to anticipate that to happen and then manage it if required. could Allah handbook you.

Answer 8

You need to read about the science of hadith to know the different levels of authenticity of hadiths

http://www.usc.edu/dept/MSA/fundamentals/hadithsunnah/scienceofhadith/atit.html

Answer 9

For knowledge, take reference from Quran instead of these unauthentic books. They will never answer your inquires.

Secondly.. There is a key named 'Caps Lock' on the left side of your keyborad.. instantly press it.

Answer 10

WAY TOO MUCH INFORMATION FOR ME!!!
You know all that but don't know if - MUSLIM MALES SQUAT TO URlNATE LIKE FEMALES?