Why do people expect all Muslims to apologize for what terrorists do?

Question

When people say "I'm sorry", that means that they did something wrong. I haven't done anything wrong. If I apologize, that would make me guilty by association like saying that "my people are the terrorists" but those are NOT my people. Those terrorists are ignorant and deserve the pain and suffering they will have in hell...Why then should I apologize for the sins that they have commited just because I am Muslim?

Answer 1

I agree with you completely, and I'm not a Muslim. People expect Muslims to apologize because they see Muslims as being "outsiders" who are somehow less unique and individual than any other person. Because of this, while it would be unthinkable to them to demand the same apology from Christians if one Christian group decided to go nuts (after all, they're one of *us*), they don't seem to understand that it's just as ridiculous to request this of Muslims. It's the same reason why America justified placing Japanese citizens in concentration camps during WWII - they seemed different enough for it to be easy to assume that they all shared the same motives as the people who bombed Pearl Harbor.

You shouldn't apologize. Don't apologize. When people demand an apology from you, look them in the eye and say that one Muslim isn't the same as another Muslim, just like one Christian isn't the same as another, and that you find it dehumanizing that they would assume that about you.

Answer 2

Most of the people who say Muslims should apologize for what terrorists do are not really looking for an apology. What these people want is for Muslims to be so in awe of the Power of the US that they will apologize, like a timid servant will apologize to keep from being beaten by their master.

On 9-11 there was an immense out-pouring of concern and outrage from across the globe. Many Muslim countries condemned what the terrorist did, why do people expect Muslims to keep apologizing? People from diverse religions and nations stood together. Why has that image been so quickly forgotten?

Answer 3

I think it's because it's written in your Koran to kill all infidels. I think that's why many westerners group muslims in with terrorists. I have to admit, when I read that passage I was shocked that Islam teaches that. But then some of my muslim friends on here say that's not for today so I don't think that way anymore. But I honestly think that's why. You don't need to apologize if you aren't one of the terrorists.

Answer 4

If my brother or sister did something that brought shame on my family or my father's name, I'd apologize. If our family's NAME is involved, I'd apologize, even if it was not me who brought the shame.

I think what galls most people is not the lack of an apology from you, who may not be involved - but it's the lack of condemnation of the evil deeds. The tendency, even as you say, "those are NOT my people," but not to make CLEAR that you feel anger and / or shame that they are using your religion's name to do this.

In addition, many Muslims and Muslim leaders don't come out loudly and excommunicate these terrorists from calling themselves by the name and make a loud noise that these terrorists are NOT considered Muslim by you or others in your faith. Many times we see Muslim leaders equivocate by saying, 'yes, but you must understand how oppressed these people feel from the Jews etc.' Or, 'this is their crying out in oppression, and you don't condemn the wrongs of Israel or the US.'

We don't see Islamic countries sending soldiers to fight terrorists, but instead they condemn as "infidels" non-Muslims who put foot on their precious soil. If they took care of the terrorists themself, the "infidels" wouldn't be there.

Wrong + Wrong does not make Right. And doing wrong in reprisal does not erase the wrongs done to you. There should be no equivocation from Muslims in condemning the terrorists. If Israel or the US is wrong, then complain about it like a lot of us do. But don't excuse or minimize the evils of terrorism by saying, 'well, we're no worse than they.'

It is not about you apologizing for them. It is about loudly and vigorously condemning their deeds and publicly denouncing their claims of Islam.

Answer 5

Damn straight. I dont expect muslims to apologize for the actions of a few nuts. Just like I dont expect christians to apologize for the loonies who run the Jesus camp, or expect catholics to apologize for the spanish inquisition.

I totally agree.

Answer 6

While I agree with you 100%, I still wonder why the whole Muslim world isn't up in arms about the people doing this crap in Allah's name. Is the media just not reporting it?

Answer 7

because "people" are retards. If you asked every Christian to apologize for the millions in history that have (and are) committing atrocities in the Churches name, You'd never hear another Christian on YA. Ever. Cause the sun will turn red giant before the Christians are done "apologizing."

Answer 8

you don't have to apologize for them,you (and all muslims) only have to tell them to back to the right path.

Answer 9

Same reason blacks expect all white people to apologize for what a bunch of stupid idiots who have long since died did to black people a long time ago, and almost all of us living white folks agree was wrong. They are making generalizations.

As long as you don't try to blow me up or pay other people to try to blow me up you have nothing to apologize for.

Answer 10

As Salaam to you all, i might desire to characteristic here to this question: ‘Imran ibn Husayn suitable that the Prophet (Salla Allahu ‘alayhi wa salam) as quickly as observed a guy sporting a brass chain. whilst he asked approximately it, the guy replied that he mandatory it to triumph over the weak point of previous age. The Prophet (Salla Allahu ‘alayhi wa salam) commanded him to get rid of it asserting: “it may in basic terms upload on your weak point. could dying overtake you while you're donning it, you may by no potential succeed”? This hadith grow to be recorded by Ahmad [Ibn Hanbal] with a solid chain of Isnad. Ahmad has additionally recorded a marfu hadith reported by ‘Uqbah ibn ‘Amir, asserting: “Whoever wears a talisman or an amulet might by no potential see his wish fulfilled by Allah”. In yet another version of the comparable hadith, the Prophet (Salla Allahu ‘alayhi wa salam) is reported to have further: “Whoever wears a talisman has dedicated shirk”. Ibn Abu Hatim reported from Hudhayfah that the Prophet observed a guy sporting a garment which he claimed secure him against fever; that he tore it to products recalling the verse: “…maximum of them have self assurance no longer in Allah and nevertheless prepare shirk”. wonderful Quran, Surah Yusuf, Ayah 106 “And maximum of them have self assurance no longer in Allah without associating (different as companions [shirk]) with Him! ????? ???????? ???????????? ???????? ?????? ????? ???????????? (12:106) The Muslim who wears any chains and clothing as amulets, charms or talismans are committing a grave offence and since the Prophet (Salla Allahu ‘alayhi wa salam) says: “they prepare Shirk”. This is going for women and adult men persons and may even comprise any merchandise collectively with a key ring containing wonderful Qur’anic text cloth, or like the prepare interior North Africa of a blue hand, blue eye or a blue bead. there are a number of examples too distinctive to comprise here in spite of the undeniable fact that it extremely is suffice to declare that a talisman is something which the wearer believes will supply them further protection. A Muslim could count upon Allah (Subhanahu wa ta’ala) on my own to be their Protector, for has He no longer written your e book for you and is familiar with all it extremely is to ensue to you? The Christian women persons have a habit of donning fortunate charms, bracelets and necklaces and a variety of of alternative Muslim women persons stick to this comparable prepare. Wa Salaam Mahmood