How can there be three persons in God (trinity) ? Is this problematic for monotheism?

Question

How can there be three persons in God (Trinity) ? Is this problematic for monotheism?

Answer 1

I completely agree with Lion Killer, the Holy Trinity is just made up by the Roman Catholic Church and you will not find Church, Holy Trinity and Christian in the Bible, these are all man made

P.S. Unfortunately people of every religion have their Holy books at their homes but don't get the time to read it and rather follow someone elses sayings rather than what is authentic

Answer 2

It certainly bothers Muslims, who emphasize monotheism. I have, several times, likened the notion of a trinity to three blindfolded men examining an elephant: one feels a leg, one a tusk, and one the trunk. Later they discuss the experience. Clearly, in this case, these are simply three aspects of a single underlying reality. But I have never found any evidence to suppose that there is any reality in a god.

Answer 3

I nevertheless do no longer think of we are able to comprehend the Holy Trinity. that does no longer mean we could desire to constantly provide up. It in hassle-free terms skill that the Trinity is an inexhaustable secret to be pondered upon. I hate to be a stickler, yet i do no longer think of you have gotten it fairly maximum appropriate. you assert ''one nature.'' One nature could be one will. that could desire to be to deny that Christ has the two a human and divine nature, which could be an historical heresy noted as Monothelitism. don't get me incorrect nevertheless... i do no longer mean it in a condemning variety of way. I basically think of that perchance you may desire to discover a distinctive time era different than ''nature.'' that is rather common to slide into heresy while describing the Holy Trinity, which that's maximum suitable to no longer clarify those issues in our own words. i might motivate you to proceed thinking this, yet attempt to no longer be too hasty on your motives, and perchance seem over the Athanasian Creed some greater circumstances. nevertheless, i will provide you a megastar and a pat on the decrease back to your efforts. you have accomplished a much greater advantageous job including your clarification than i could desire to have. Peace, Drew playstation : to people who say the interest ''Trinity'' isn't any stumbled on interior the Bible (and there'll be some), it is not correct whether that's or no longer. The Bible became canonized around Trinitarian doctrine, that's why the theory is there, whether we don't care to renowned it. St. Athanasius and St. Nicolas (sure, Santa Claus) defined the Trinity greater needless to say based on Bishop Arius, who taught that Jesus became basically ''a sturdy guy.''

Answer 4

This sure causes a lot of trouble, and it's not that mysterious in my opinion.
God is the Creator, and he created humanity "in his own image," that is, creators too, in a way.
Say you you have an idea, "I'm going to build a treehouse." That's your "father" having that idea.
Then you start planning and getting supplies and building and getting all tired and sweaty and sometimes frustrated. That's your "son." Your "father" is still there, but your "son" is more obvious at the moment. You also get happy and excited as things take shape and you are getting results. That's your "spirit." The idea of the treehouse and the building of it and the enjoying (and suffering) of the process and the results, cannot be divided, and yet you can see them separately.....Okay, that's the best I can do right now.... I guess it is kind of mysterious after all....

Answer 5

The short answers are: there can't, and not really (when has rationalization been a problem for faith?).

Consider this: The trinity, like certain stories of the bible, is a bastardization of a pagan concept; in this case, multiple gods. It was deemed easier to convert the pagans to the christian faith, by claiming that there was one god, but three aspects...thereby leading them to the "one true god", while fulfilling their desire to follow more than one.

Answer 6

Yes, it gets rather tricky.

Luckily for Christians, the Holy Spirit was already the 2nd God in the One God system of Judism, so adding a 3rd diety didn't actually confuse things that much more.

Answer 7

I consider myself "monotheistic" but I also believe in the Trinity. Why do you think there is a problem with the two? God is ONE GOD, just as the egg is one egg. God has 3 parts to Himself, just as the egg has three parts. Each part has a different function from the other parts but it is still just ONE. The Father, Son and Holy Ghost are each members of ONE GOD but with different job functions. Like the egg: the yoke and white and shell each have their separate functions but are but one egg. So it is with God. Each member with different functions but ONE GOD.

Answer 8

The three persons refer to the three main roles played by the one God. Creation, sustenance and destruction. The universe is created, sustained and eventually it will be destroyed by the Creator Himself.

Answer 9

The way that I understand the trinity is that THEY are three separate entities, but, one in purpose. When a couple is married, they unite and become one. NOT one being, but, having a unified purpose in life.

I hope that was not confusing.

GOD bless

Answer 10

Seriously! And what about the "fact" that Jesus and God are really the same thing? What does that say about the whole "God sacrificed his only son" bidness? That is was all a scam? Was Jesus' "virgin birth", miracles, cruxifiction, and ressurection all a massive practical joke by God on all of us?

No makey any sense, boss.