if the police were more brutal and we had less freedoms would the USA be a better place?

Question

personally i would like to see many of our freedoms taken away as munishment. i would like to see public hangings come back in to style. perhaps rounding up gangs and lighting them on fire would get a message accrost.

i look at my country and i see it desolving and becomming worse every day.

you think after 9/11 we would have learn some thing but nope we have not. you would think with all the rape and crap we would do some thing but nope we dont. perhaps one day the military will give up and take the country over because the dumbass civilans are not doing a very good job.

what do you think?

Answer 1

I think you need to do a lot of reading about the history of other countries (including ours) who have tried, or are using, Draconian punishment methods and oppression of the citizens to literally "bend them to the will" of the government.

Now post a list of countries who have thrived under those conditions.

The happiest, most peaceful countries appear to be the ones who have gone the opposite way, with minimal force and oppression.

Answer 2

i'm the police and that i disagree. i'm difficulty to extra restraints and scrutiny than any "many times happening" citizen. i've got faith I could be held to a some distance better popular considering the fact which you have given me the your best option to eliminate your freedoms could the choose get up. in case you commit against the regulation, i will arrest you. in case you attempt to harm me or yet another person, i will harm you. in case you threaten me or somebody else I incredibly have the criminal applicable and authority to kill you. consequently, I could be regulated extra stringently than you. would my activity be extra trouble-free if many civil liberties have been discarded, oh yeah. would the streets be lots safer, you guess. yet, as quickly as you initiate on that direction, it turns right into a slippery-slope. this is an occasion: LAPD Rampart branch - whilst they close those corrupt law enforcement officers down the electorate incredibly raised hell. you realize why? b/c earlier the Rampart branch replaced into working, they could no longer enable their young ones play in the park for worry of having shot, mugged or overwhelmed. They weren't apprehensive approximately that on a similar time as the branch replaced into open. To them, the ends (secure community) justified the skill (corrupt law enforcement officers) b/c they have been after the fairly undesirable men (and became undesirable men themselves in the technique) the toughest difficulty approximately being a good guy: you will no longer be able to do what undesirable men do, no count if the ends would justify the skill. in case you do, you're basically a bad guy, with a 'good' objective. Our civil liberties are that set us apart from the terrorist international locations. they shouldn't in any respect be discarded or surrendered. the priority I see is that slowly shifting wheel of justice. IF shall we detect the thank you to make punishment particular & instant, it would be extra smart than basically severe punishment finally. --Z--

Answer 3

No.