English Deutsch Français Italiano Español Português 繁體中文 Bahasa Indonesia Tiếng Việt ภาษาไทย
All categories

911 - WERE the jewish community involved .........?
I recently watched a documentary on the television, it stated that there are normally roughly 4000 jewish persons in the Twin towers on any given day, BUT on that horrible day, there were only a handfull (roughly 150) so the program stated.
This extremely disturbed me, to think that a so-called friendly people said nothing about this, if this IS the case, can I have only serious answers please, IF it is the case, why why why did this happen and no word was leaked that this sort of atrocity was going to happen ??????????

Additional Details

10 hours ago
I have read only a few answers already, feels like I have started a war in my own living room, gees, but I think a few of you - going by the tv programme, you have your facts WRONG, why would a programme that deals in facts and actually investigates the questions be missled by perhaps SOMEONE saying something that is wrong in the eyes of the Jewish person types, sorrry, but these investigative journo's do thier homework, granted, they are not allways correct, but most, if not all in the world would agree that they do stumble on the bit of truth now and again, maybe not all, but there HAS to be something in order for it to make an actual programme, more so on prime time telly, evening, when all the young and old are watching. I dare you to come back with an answer to that, re-read if you are not sure if you should answer this.

2007-02-24 22:12:55 · 13 answers · asked by Anonymous in News & Events Media & Journalism

13 answers

Please, please check your information before posting blatant lies that are offensive. You can always check snopes. Look under rumors of war and there is an article about the supposed 4,000 Israelis who did not attend work. It states that it is clearly untrue. I am Jewish, and my uncle was on the way into the tower when he saw a plane hit the floor above his office. My friend's father, also Jewish, was not as lucky, and he died in the second tower. Do you really think that the Muslim hijackers, known enemies of Israelis and Jews worldwide, would conspire with American Jews? I'm surprised that you seem perplexed by the angry reaction to your posting. I am a New Yorker and I am Jewish, and I know many people who lost relatives and friends on that awful day. My roommate at the time, once again Jewish, narrowly escaped death by jumping on a ferry to Staten Island, where a lovely Indian family (strangers at the time, friends now) invited her to stay with them until she could get back to Manhattan. They did not suspect my friend of having insider knowlege of the attack because that would be utterly ridiculous. We were attacked that day as New Yorkers and as Americans, not as Jews or non-Jews. I urge you not to espouse such unfounded ideas on this website. I know that you meant well with your question, but it had very anti-semitic (blame the Jews for everything, even when not supported by evidence) undertones, and frankly, it scares me.

2007-02-25 16:59:10 · answer #1 · answered by remote 2 · 6 1

As a Jewish person I am highly insulted and astounded by your sheer stupidity. New York is full of Jews and there is no reason why we would do that. We are not bloodthirsty murderes like the muslims are (neither as stupid as you).

It's true that barely any Jews died that day and there is a simple reason why. G-D WAS LOOKING OUT FOR US!! The attacks happened in the week leading up to our High Holy Days. During that week religious Jews wake up extra early because there is a special prayer that we say that week - and it is very long. I know of many friends, neighbors and family members who arrived late the day of the attacks just because they ran late saying the prayers.

There are some other extraoidinary stories about people I know who were saved that day. Do you know that hundreds of Hatzola members (Hatzola - Jewish volunteer ambulances/EMT's) went to the scene of the attacks to save people. Many had very close calls, but luckily NO-ONE DIED. How can you say we planned it?

My friends uncle died that day - he was JEWISH. Jews are not suicidal - knock that into your head somehow!!!

2007-02-26 12:03:06 · answer #2 · answered by Sunshine 3 · 3 1

Its not actual. the place did you watch this documentary IranTV? Its straight forward sufficient to be sure that this would be a lie, why? because of the fact interior the U. S. we don't save figures on the religion of workers, in short there is no thank you to be sure anyones faith at artwork. it is not even permissible to ask the question. Secondly, not all Jews chat to a minimum of one yet another, they not stay interior the ghetto and that i will not be able to extremely see some super telephone tree passing the word. you extremely could hate the Jews to think of they might have that huge a wisdom of this variety of subject and a technique or the different save it from the government or their non-Jewish friends. I certainly have additionally heard this unhappy tale that's unfold by skill of the wide-unfold bunch of haters and is to not be taken heavily. there have been in basic terms 10000 human beings interior the homes that day its extremely uncertain that 4000 of them would be Jewish as Jews in basic terms incorporate approximately a million-a million.5% of the inhabitants of the U. S.. I certainly have examine your addition and in case you examine my reaction you are able to in basic terms use good judgment to comprehend why the so-called documentary is misguided. the only question isn't any remember if or not it replace into intentionally inflammatory, or replace into poorly researched and with a slanted objective. in case you finally end up believing this falsehood then in all probability, thinking a super sort of different documentaries have debunked that 'Jewish Conspiracy" and you do not % to belive those, then you definately in basic terms prefer to have confidence something against people who're Jewish. And no sort of excellent judgment will splendid that.

2016-10-16 10:58:31 · answer #3 · answered by ? 4 · 0 0

I am always astounded at the outrageous lies anti-semites are willing to make up to justify and spread their hatred.

This story is complete fiction. It was made up by people who hate Jews and want to blame them for all the ills of the world. They are using it to recuit you into their way of thinking, and I can see that it was worked.

2007-02-27 02:46:24 · answer #4 · answered by MaryBridget G 4 · 5 0

You asked this question two days in a row? Why? Didn't get the answers you were expecting? There is no truth to this and you have let yourself be manipulated and used and that makes you very stupid.

2007-02-26 09:31:51 · answer #5 · answered by Anonymous · 4 0

Only as victims - anything else is an anti-Semitic conspiracy theory and an insult to all victims of 9/11.

2007-02-26 00:43:46 · answer #6 · answered by Anonymous · 3 1

So they "do their homework", "deal in facts" you say. The problem here is that there are no facts given by them. This theory was started by Arabs when they learned that the true culprits were of Arab dissent. This is a FACT! This was picked up and expanded upon by other anti-Jewish groups. The anti-Bush groups have their own theories.

Just one of many:

2007-02-24 23:16:58 · answer #7 · answered by Mr.Wise 6 · 3 3

Only morons believe what they see on TV or read in newspapers. There is always a vested interest putting a spin on statistics to prove what ever they want.
So far three people have answered this, therefore one of us is Chinese. QED.

2007-02-24 22:22:33 · answer #8 · answered by Anonymous · 3 2

3,850 Jews called in sick or steered clear of the Towers and let the other 150 die? 3,850 Jews would have no reason to let enemies of Israel and the Jewish community attack the Towers.

2007-02-24 22:42:10 · answer #9 · answered by Debra D 7 · 4 1

I know what you mean, I think there should have been more. Although we do have to take into account the fact that the building's weren't full, I guess because of the time not everyone was at work yet

2007-02-24 22:18:01 · answer #10 · answered by aleta_uk_0 4 · 0 5

fedest.com, questions and answers