Is a (silent) witness also guilty ?

Question

Some one asked this question , assuming a 16 yr old girl being raped & killed & the act being witnessed by God (lets assume there is a God)

http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index;_ylt=AtPl5F38lmHqIEFRlafESHzsy6IX?qid=20070223030724AAhqabJ&show=7#profile-info-fb111f328150ee7e8b36de79f775fffaaa

I was shocked by some of the answers by the religous types , they said maybe the girl would have died in a car accident or diagnosed with cancer the next day ........ that still does not absolve God from being a silent witness to the rape.

Dont you think its better to die in a car accident than be gang-raped ...... gosh what kind of a God allows gang rape , and if he did then the rapist were simply doing Gods work , no human judge has the right to punish those doing Gods deeds

Pls click on the URL & read the earlier question , before answering me - Thanx

Answer 1

Yes if a witness could have prevented the crime , but did not do so.

Then the witness is also a criminal.

I feel sorry for all the religous types , who were just not cuning enough to even be able to attempt to answer your question.

Answer 2

I read the former question ,but didn't bother to read the posts.

This is what I believe.
In the beginning of the bible Satan told Eve that God was holding back from her and that he wasn't telling them the truth.

This put into doubt whether God should rule people or if they should rule themselves. People basically rebelled. God has allowed people to govern themselves without his interference in order to answer the doubt. This will be for the benefit of those who are to live under his kingdom.
What ever that girl has endured she can be fixed and giving more. However, if God interfered that would make it appear as if people could govern themselves without any problem and the question would never be answered.
God has allowed people to try different forms of government and has allowed people to advance technologically. He has only interfered to provide an escape route.
He will stop this when the question has been answered and before people destroy themselves.

If he didn't allow this then people will doubt him and try to rebel which would cause endless problems.
He does know what she's going though and plans to help those who are currently suffering under his kingdom. He will do away with the ones that cause these problems