Why do Muslim assume that all of the Christian and Jews holy site belong to them. what is their prove it's

Question

belong to them

they want Jurusalem, Bathlehem and etc

the al aqsa mosque was actually a catholic before muslim turn into a mosque

i mean a catholic church

Answer 1

Man where do you get these information from?

Muslims claiming Beitlehm as their?

you can't distinguish between Muslims and Palestinians do you?

God bless

Answer 2

I think you're wrong about al aqsa being catholic, but there are plenty of other examples of such things...one very recent is the sacking of Joseph's Tomb in Shechem/Nablus and the site being turned into a mosque. This happened in 2001.

The muslims, knowing that their faith is a lie and their prophet is a fraud can only justify their existence by 'proving' those faiths that came before them never really existed. Hence, Abraham, Moses and even Jesus are called muslims. Another example is when Yassir Arafat, near the end of the Camp David meetings in 2000, told President Clinton that the Jewish Temples never existed on the Temple Mount. There is no basis for this argument and even the Koran describes the Temples there. Yet, this is now standard educational material throughout the muslim world. The muslims seek to de-legitimize rightful claims by erasing evidence and creating rumor to the contrary.

Answer 3

This is easy.... the holy sites belonged the the christians and jews before Islam ever existed. There is much historical and archeological evidence. Thre were several conquering groups that held the holy land in history. And each one had to relinquish the land to the conquering group, which is how things happen in war. During one of these cycles of ownership, the turks had the land, who were muslim. However, they also lost the land to the British.

Each group that had possessed the property has some physical evidence remaining that they were ONCE there. The muslims
have their mosque. However, since they susequently lost the land during war, they cannot continue to claim this land is theirs.

The last group to own the property was the British. The British legally turned over the land to the Jews in 1948, so that the Jews could return to their homeland. The Jews have much evidence.

Answer 4

We don't believe Jewish or Christian holy sites are ours. You don't know what you are talking about.

When Omar Ibn Al Khatab who was the Calif of Muslims and conquered the roman tyrant invasion out of Jursalem, He made a treaty with Christians and Jews, He even refused to pray in Church of the resurrection so no Muslim would ever come and say it's ours cause he prayed there. He found an old Jewish synagogue, He cleaned it with his clothes and ordered to clean and get it ready for Jews to worship freely.

The holy place in Jerusalem for Muslims, is Al Aqsa mosque that's all.

The situation in Palestine is not about the land is for Muslims, Christians or Jews. It's about the land is for the people who owns it for thousands of years Muslims or not. These lands are granted to Israelis by the Britain during the war. So the land is for the people who lived there for thousands of years not for the people who came from every country in the world protected by armies and took it by force.

Holy places are for anyone following any of the three religions from anywhere in the world anytime.

Turn off your CNN and FOX news and start reading and understanding from accredited reliable sources about Islam not from lying sources and those who enjoy the benefit of the non stopping war and the power and money that comes from that.

Al Aqsa was built at time of Adam as well as Al Kaaba (in Mecca) and were rebuilt by Ibrahim (Abraham) PBUH and his son Ismael PBUH. Ismael is the grandfather of our Prophet Muhammad PBUH and all Arabs are tracked to Ismael and in turn Muslims. Al Aqsa remained as a holy place but none of Christians or Jews used it as a place of worship not a church not a temple not a synagogue. Read history from proper, honest and I would not say Muslim source but at least neutral not anti-Muslims sources.

Answer 5

In Genesis, there was Adam and Eve created to replenish the Earth in Gods image. They had two (2 ) sons, Cain and Abel. Cain grew jealous of Abel because he thought Adam showed favoritism, and he slew Abel. Adam had to make a decision, as He was Gods anointed, He banished Cain out of the outer wilderness. Please read the first chapter of Muslim Bible. Mo hammed came out of the wilderness, performing miracles. Since that time, their has only been hatred toward the Hebrews as they were to be called. Also, check out scripture about who fights at the Battle of Armageddon, or the Valley of Miggido? God Bless !!

Answer 6

It was the Prophet Mohammed himself who attempted to negate the positive image of the Jew that had been prevalent earlier. According to historian Bernard Lewis, the Prophet Mohammed's original plan had been to induce the Jews to adopt Islam; when Mohammed began his rule at Medina in AD 622 he counted few supporters, so he adopted several Jewish practices-including daily prayer facing toward Jerusalem and the fast of Yom Kippur-in the hope of wooing the Jews.

But the Jewish community rejected the Prophet Mohammed's religion, preferring to adhere to its own beliefs, whereupon Mohammed subsequently substituted Mecca for Jerusalem, and dropped many of the Jewish practices.

Aslam 09221 claims "We Muslims never stop jews or christians to go to their places." This is unfortunately a great lie.

A few examples. Following the war in 1948, the Jordanians destroyed all synagogues in East Jerusalem. In 2001 the "Palestinians" destroyed Joseph's tomb in Nablus. The Waqf does not permit Jews to pray on the Temple Mount, the holiest site in the Jewish world.

Jews are not permitted to reside in Saudi Arabia or in Jordan.

The list could be extended, but the conclusion is that Muslims do NOT respect the rights of Jews to pray.

Answer 7

They believe that because the teachings of Christianity, Judaism, and Islam have many of the same famous historical figures such as Moses, Jesus, and most notably Abraham. So many of their holy sites shar that same characteristic.

Answer 8

no we don't think that. Jews holy book & the bible they are god's religions, did you know that we Muslims believe in Jesus, Moses, and Abraham to us there prophets to you they may be fathers or sons of god but we all believe in the same thing I’m not putting the finger on one religion or one person.

Christianity was the first religion it was the greatest religion until the people changed to words of Allah (god), soon people left that religion not because it was boring it’s because they didn’t understand no more.

Jews ,long ago refused to take Allah’s religion but they were poor at the time so they had to believe in god so that god would help them by giving them food to eat ,they said
yes to take the religion so god gave them food to eat as soon as they had finished, they said no to the religion but when other when Islam was strating to spread their religion ,they took the their holy book but it was to late for them to take it they should of took it when god had sent it to them..
so were the same i believe their is chirsitanity& jews but i didn't say they belong to me.

Answer 9

history proves that some holy sites are the centre of islamic religion. however, i do not think muslims claims or assumes so. many places in the world are about christiaity and they exist untouched in the islamic world..like moses well in saint chathrine-Egypt. the beauty of jeruslim is that it was a holy site for muslims and chrisitians and both werre allowed to pray there before the occupation took place and non-muslims came to prevent both from praying there.

Answer 10

Probably the same " Proof " that Abraham was going to sacrifice Ishmael when all historic fact says it was Isaac ! Twisted warped view of history to suit their own story.