If you fall into icy water and become clinically dead but are soon revived by doctors...?

Question

...were you dead, semi-dead, totally dead, temporarily dead or never dead? Which one was Jesus after the crucifixtion?

If they are both the same type of dead, then lots of people have come back to life. How is Jesus special?

Answer 1

Actually meatbot there is a rather well documented account of Jesus being revived and nursed back to health after the Crucifixion and moving to Kashmir and living to be about 80.

He still has many followers there that can attest to this ministry.

Love and blessings Don

Answer 2

That's typical of a non-believer. No depth.
Clinical Deaths are deaths by the standards of the clinic.

There is no such thing as "semi" dead (because you are either dead or not)... Imagry for Semi dead would be that of a coma. Even then, one is not dead.
If the person is temporarily dead, then they were dead momentarily. But temporarily dead implies that the person returns from death.
Totally dead doesn't make since it's the same as just saying "Dead". this ties into what I said about Semi-dead; You are either dead or not. Totally dead and Semi-dead cancel each other out, so they aren't a factor in your question.

Let's now focus on temporarily dead. Do you what how Jesus died. He was pinned (by large iron spikes) to the cross for hours. To confirm his death, he was pierced in his side. Obviously, he did a lot of bleeding. this is nothing like freezing.
Also, he was placed in a tomb for a couple of days.

Think of all of those who were revived... Now what examples do you have of anyone bleeding for hours and enduring those measures of pain that were simply classified as 'clinical deaths' that came back to life?

Answer 3

icy water and dying by crucifixion are completely different. Jesus was completely dead where His soul left His body - He was not in a "coma" and then revived or in "shock" and then revived - He was dead. A sword thrust under the 5th rib right where the heart is was done to prove He was dead and blood and water gushed out. Noone survives a sword thrust into the heart. And when He was Resurrected His physical body was completely changed - if He had just "revived from shock" how could He have just appeared in their midst when all the doors and windows were locked? He was free of natural physical laws of this universe.

Answer 4

You're clinically dead. From a Buddhist perspective, most of the "afterlife" experiences people talk about experiencing at this point before they're brought back sound quite like the "bardo", or in-between state Buddhism discusses. I'd say Jesus was likely clinically dead and achieved some form of enlightenment... the whole experience described in the Bible and various things sound very much like the activities of a "bodhisattva".

_()_

Answer 5

the probabilities of a effectual resuscitation drop rapidly over the years, with below a million% survival after quarter-hour or so. that's a perplexing factor to seem at, by way of fact CPR does proceed perfusion to the organs, nevertheless no longer o.k., so the commencing element for being "ineffective" isn't an exact time. No, that's no longer evidence of an afterlife. i'm a non secular individual and have self assurance strongly that there is an afterlife, besides the incontrovertible fact that it is likewise fairly achievable that the perceptions are basically a symptom, hallucination, or dream, brought about by utilising the decreased ideas perfusion. in need of the 2nd Coming, that is an unprovable proposition.

Answer 6

Good question,

Dannion Brinkley.com went through a life review and wrote the book Saved by the Light after the first nde.
If you read some of the gnostic gospels it talks about Jesus going into hell before his resurrection to give souls a chance to come higher.So, he didn't need a life review, see the difference?

Answer 7

Actually after Jesus died and came back the dead rose from their tombs. That is what the bible says. What is special about Jesus? He was the first and only sinless perfection to die for our sins. Our one and only Savior.

Answer 8

Clinically dead.

Answer 9

Clinical death for cessation of breath and the circulatory system but preservation of the organs.

Biological death when break down of the body occurs.

In the Bible, Jesus would most likely have been considered to be reaching advanced stages of decomposition.

Answer 10

Wow somebody watches Grey's Anatomy. And yes, you were clinically dead. And so is Jesus.