What age should a parent start to use spanking?

Answer 1

No younger than 2 yrs old, but I'd say with most children, it wouldn't be appropriate until 3 or so. I know you're getting a lot of anti-spanking comments but when spanking is used appropriately and for direct disobedience and not anything else, it is very effective and no, it doesn't teach violence like you'll be told.

Go to http://www.family.org (Focus on the Family's website) for more information about spanking.

Answer 2

I do not believe in beating, slapping, but there were times when my son would deliberately disobey me and do things like try to stick a fork in an electric outlet after prying off the child-proof caps, or run across the street after unlocking the child-proof door locks during the 30 seconds I was in the toilet. Sitting in time outs was totally ineffective, and it took a swat on his well-padded bottom to get his attention. You could actually see the change in his face as he went from "I'll do whatever I want" to "Oh, I guess you really meant it." Time outs were totally ineffective with him, as he was and is perfectly content to sit by himself in a chair. He just thinks happy thoughts, and entertains himself, so that didn't work. Once he was 4-5 I switched to things like taking away toys or things like that. Each child is different, and what works for one doesn't always work for another. I cringe when I see parents constantly smacking their kids for every little thing, and it's more the parents that need discipline than the kids, but it's probably what they were taught. I have some seen some real MONSTERS result in children who were from non-spanking homes, who think it's fine to hit people, kick adults in the shins, as their psychologist parents say "Now sweetie, you know that makes mommy unhappy when you do that." I do not believe a well-earned smack on the butt once in awhile is abuse. For some kids who aren't very receptive to verbal instruction because of their developmental style or personality, etc. sometimes a physical prompt gets the point across. But by school age all kids should be able to be reasoned with and no longer spanked at all. I was taught this in a very long parenting curriculum, which was also very careful NOT to advocate beating, etc.

Answer 3

as quickly as they start to stroll through fact they are too youthful for time outs and speaking tos, and additionally you need to discipline toddlers as early as a threat, incredibly with risky issues. as long as you're no longer beating the adverse newborn, it fairly is great. i do no longer understand people who say which you are going to no longer be able to spank any newborn and in case you do you're a foul discern and uneducated. Do they no longer understand that a million year olds who can stroll desire disclipline too? Do they no longer understand that a a million year previous can't comprehend a visit or something like that? i might incredibly in simple terms spank a newborn that youthful for doing some thing risky (such as touching an outlet or warm range) yet you will no longer be able to easily be like "no do no longer try this". they are too youthful yet to comprehend WHY what they do is inaccurate, does that recommend you nevertheless will no longer be able to tell them that this is inaccurate? No! each in specific situations spanking is the only way. Sorry for the long rant. Antispankers malicious program me. and that i replaced into abused as a newborn. Spanking isn't abuse.

Answer 4

OMG! People still spank? Never! If you teach your children right from wrong and that there are consequences to every action then you shouldn't need to spank. It only perpetuates the cycle of physical violence. Ground them, punish them in some other way. My parents never raised a hand to me and I think I turned out okay. My motherinlaw used to spank her kids on a regular basis. My spouse would tell me that she would not let up until he started crying. And he said that he wasn't affected by the pain at all so he had to learn to make himself cry. I have seen how that type of punishment can affect people, like my sisterinlaw, my spouse, and their middle brother. One boy feels nothing but resentment and makes jokes about it, my spouse seems to think it was normal (I do not), and my sisterinlaw, I think she is okay but she retaliated in different, harmful ways. Keep your hands to yourself, pick up a book, take some advice from other people, and think of your child's well-being. They will thank you for it later. Now I gotta call mom and dad and thank them!

Answer 5

Unless you are trying to teach your child that violence is an appropriate outlet to solve conflict, do not use this old fashioned and scary technique to discipline. You will be better off using time ins, a technique that has a child sit quietly to DE stress and then you talk the incident over. Be firm and clear about what was unacceptable and what you do expect. Ask for an apology from the child and then give a hug. This works much better that the smack on the butt technique! Good luck! Being a parent is hard. Keep seeking advice form someone you trust to get through it.

Answer 6

Man you opened the can of worms here. These pansy as$ people will tell you that you should NEVER spank your child. Well guess what??????? I DO. I would bet you money that they do too. Good luck honey and the age thing..
At 1 I started a swat, firm but not HARSH on a diaper. Before that just firm voiced NO! You cannot reason with a child. You cannot reason with a 3 year old. They don't have the reasoning abilities nor the verbal skill necessary.

Answer 7

Discipline can be appropriate at any age. You need to remember your goal. You want to teach your child self-discipline and the whys of life. Why don't we hit someone, because it hurts them. Many parents feel that hitting their child helps them feel what the other person felt. The problem is that then the child feels victimized and is thinking about themselves rather than their original victim. It is better to dispatch your child to administer first aid to their victim and then do something a little extra to make their victim feel better (besides sorry, maybe sing a song). This helps build into your child an image of empathy and compassion for others.
In each instance as your child grows, find the lesson and try to teach it. Don't lose your teaching moment by losing your temper and by making the child feel like a victim. Any discipline technique can be overused, time outs are an example. The time out is great for violent expressions of emotion but it doesn't help a kid remember to share or learn the why of a moral or idea.
I don't believe spanking should be used, I use tme outs as a breaktime so my kids can regain their composure (I use them too) but not as a punishment. My family tries to discipline with respect and love, thinking first of our lesson. We try to teach instead of punish. I feel it a bit hypocritical to try and teach a child to respect others by hitting him.
Teaching starts on the baby's birthday, discipline begins and develops slowly starting around 5 mos when the baby can start to get into stuff, punishment has no place in a home.

Answer 8

I DON'T spank. I was spanked when I was a kid and all it did was humiliate me. I always thought it was so messed up that while my dad was hitting (spanking) me for hitting (slapping) my sister...he'd always yell "You are not allowed to hit!". Doesn't that seem a little f'd up to you?
I respect my daughter, I would never hit her. I feel sorry for children that are still disrespected and humiliated in this unnecessary way.

Answer 9

When a parent observes their grown children spanking their grandchildren. Get it? Never spank a child.

Answer 10

Parents shouldn't use spanking at any age.Parents should discipline, teach,talk to,help,understand, love their children,not spank them(or hurt them in any way).Trust me in the world there are a lot of people who will hurt your children(emotionally but physically maybe too) and you are not the one supposed to be one of them.

Answer 11

Really small babies never should be spanked, when they get older you may tap thier hand when they touch something but still few spanks, children who deliberately disobey thier parents or who continue to do dangerous activity that could hurt them can be spanked starting around 2 or 3. Spanking should only be used very sparingly and by a parent who is in control of herself or himself. Never spank when angry. Always tell the child exactly what they are getting the spank for-sometimes they seem to be uncertain what they are being punished for! And if the spanking doesnt seem necessary then use a time out or ground them from TV or an activity.