Would you bash your children's head with rocks if God told you to?

Question

http://www.cnn.com/2004/LAW/04/03/children.slain/
This woman did, and is now in a psychiatric hospital...atleast she was a good christian, right?

For those saying no, she was under God's direct orders, how can you say "No" ? Have you no faith?

Answer 1

Psa 137:9 May the Lord bless everyone who beats your children against the rocks!

Answer 2

you have misrepresented each and each of those passages. i don't be attentive to despite if it is your purpose, or you basically have not have been given the analyzing skills to handle the fabric. At any fee, here is what's happening in each and each. Exodus 21:a million-11: Slavery became right into a longtime enterprise interior the classic international. maximum slaves have been obtained via purchase from their families. Exodus 21 isn't lots in contact in allowing slavery as with placing very severe regulations on it. Male slaves could be freed, immediately, after six years. woman slaves are assumed to be offered for intercourse, and as a result the owner is had to handle them as better halves. (Neither of those preparations applies to slaves from different peoples, via the way; they're designed basically to guard Hebrew slaves.) Judges 11:29-40 would not sell baby abuse; it condemns human sacrifice. Jephthah delivers a human sacrifice to God, and God punishes him via making his daughter be chosen because of the fact the sacrifice. Isaiah 13:sixteen would not tell everybody to do something; it only predicts that undesirable issues will take place to Babylon. Hosea 13:sixteen likewise only predicts undesirable issues, subsequently happening to Samaria. Psalm 137:9 is a lament via people conquered, enslaved, and hauled off via tension to a distant places united states. It does certainly convey anger to the quantity of asserting that people who bashed their oppressors' babies against rocks could be satisfied. this is an indignant music, and somebody positioned it in a determination of substantial songs in Hebrew. As there are no Babylonian babies around those days, i do no longer likely see that it tells me to do something. And at any fee, this is no longer God asserting to try this, this is a few Hebrew author from the Babylonian captivity. you may as nicely say the Bible tells us to bloodbath all the youngsters below the age of two, because of the fact Herod orders that performed interior the recent testomony. no longer each thing reported or defined interior the Bible is stated as an training or an occasion, and this is smart to no longer get counsel from people who won't be in a position to tell the version.

Answer 3

I don't think God speak to anybody. In this case, is obvious that this woman has mental disorders. Or she is demoniac.

Answer 4

when some body do something wrong its not nessecary to say that god ordered him or her to do so. and maybe she make a mistake but its not god s mistake. coz god would never order us to hurt ourselfs or our children god loves children very much and we should not consider that our mistakes is god s mistakes...have you ever seen a mother asked you to kill her child of course not so can you say that god who crated this mother and her child will give orders to hurt one of them

Answer 5

If god was real and he told me to, yes. Then I would plot the rest of eternity against him, and rule his dominion.

Answer 6

The answer to your question is, Jesus would not tell us to do that, and the woman who did it was receiving instructions from someone other than Jesus. She is not a good Christian.

grace2u

Answer 7

She is not a Christian - this is not taught in the Bible that Christ wrote.