What is the best brand of used van on the market in Canada for gas economy and reliability & where to buy it?

Question

One mechanic told me that the 97+ Montana or Ventura is the best van for the money. Somone else said that the Astro or Safari is more rugged like a truck, but I dont know if it is as good on gas.

Is it better to buy from an individual in a private sale generally, or better to go to a used car/ van dealer ? Are used vehicles generally less expensive to purchase in Quebec than in Ontario ? How about the Maratimes ?

I've been driving my Dodge Mini-Caravan for 13 years, and put in a second transmission and second engine. I do store to store sales, and drive thousands of kms during 8 months of the year. I took the seats out and created a second level in the van so that I can sleep and avoid expensive motel costs, while keeping supplies under the plywood board suported by milk crates.A motor home would be most comfortable, but too expensive on gas. Im trying to save for a small home, so my van will be my home for the next few years. Ive liked the feel of the Caravan but dont know others

Answer 1

The Montana/Venture were the best in class for fuel but had big problems with their intake manifolds, there are two in my family and both have gone through this problem. The new Toyota Sienna and Honda Odyssey are big and very reliable, also very nice to drive. When it comes to gas consumption the difference between all the vans is negligible. The KIA is one of the worst and the Safari or Astro your mechanic recommended is truck based and poor on gas. Buying from a dealer is a little safer but good deals can be had through a private sale, do your homework either way and have it inspected before buying, ALWAYS.