the concept of rebirth is true if it is true then why muslim don,t accept it and how can u prove it true?

Answer 1

Though Pd. Dayanand and most of the Hindus believe in rebirth but the Vedic text enlightens us that theory of reincarnation is baseless.

" Beyond the three skies let him go,whence he shall NEVER COME AGAIN in all years to be long as the sun is in heaven."--[Arthava veda,6:75:3]

"All creatures are one fourth of Him, three fourths what DIETH NOT IN HEAVENS." --[Ibid, 19:6:3]

"Through whom the gods [Humen ancestors of the Aryans] discovered the eternal life."--[Ibid,4:23:6]

"Let the dead remain among the Fathers."--[Ibid,18:4:48]

"Fathers rejoice in the heaven with all yours members."--[Ibid,18:4:64]

Rig Veda confirms that the Creator creates all things of this world and the next , at a certain time :

"The father of the eye, the wise in spirit, created both these worlds."--[Rig veda,10:82:2]

" You will not find Him who produced these creatures : another thing hasarisen in your mind.Enwrapt in misty cloud with lips that stammer,hymn-chanters wander and are discontented."--[ibid,10:82:7]


As per rebirth theory based on Manu's teachings, a person who commits adultery with the wife of another, or causes death of virtuous people,he gets the BODY OF A TREE, on his rebirth.

This is just baseless since a tree can contain several souls if propagated by cutting its branches and growing them separately.Each branch will become another tree.


Even Bhagwat Geeta informs of Shri Krishna, the 8th avatar of Vishnu as saying. " Thinking on that, merged in that, solely devoted to that THEY GO WHENCE THERE IS NO RETURN, their signs dispelled by wisdom."--[Bhagwat Geeta,5:17]

" Having come to Me, these mahatmas, COME NOT AGAIN TO BIRTH, the place pf pain, noneternal, they have gone to highest bliss."--[ibid,8:14]

The 9th avatar of Vishnu was Buddha who said, " There is no evidence of an immutable ego-being, which remaineth and migrates from body to body."--[The Gospel of Buddha by Carus,p-23]


"Gautama [Buddha] did not teach the transmigration of souls."--[Hibbert lecture by Rhys Davids, 1880, p-91]

"His [Budhha's] doctrine was not metempsycosis."--[Chiristianity & Buddhism by Sterling Berry,p-75]


In JAINISM also, the rebirth theory is not acceptable;


"We will now adopt the law, after the adoption of which WE WILL NOT BE BORN AGAIN."--[Gyan Sutra, part II s.b.e.XIV,p-65]

"How can it be imagined that he shouild be born again who profess the pure,complete, unparalled law and is a recepticle of the unparalleled law."--[Ibid,pg-331-332]

The Sikh Guru Nanak Sahib also discarded this theory;

" The Lord has become mercyful, COMING AND GOING HAS STOPPED."--[Adi Granth translated by Ernest Trumpp,p-72]

"Praise thou the name of Ram[God], THERE WILL NOT BE AGAIN COMIN AND GOING."--[Ibid,p-52]

" Having become in the way of religion, HE PUTS A STOP OF GYRATION OF DEATH AND LIFE."--[Ibid,p-195]


Scientifically also there is no explanation whatsoever, which can
substentiate reincarnation or rebirth.

That's why there is no mention of reincarnation in Quran also. Therefore no Muslim believes in such baseless belief.

Answer 2

In islamic teaching there is no reincarnation so the concept of rebirth is not true.Muslims will not accept this concept because it is against with the holy book and hadith.Islam is a religion which is given by Allah to all of humans in this world while the concept of rebirth is in the hindu religion which is not given by Allah the only one God..I have not a prove that this concept is true.In Islam if someone died his/her soul will come back to Allah the creator and the owner.The soul will not come back to this earth.All died bodies will be lived again in the resurrection. day. and they will be judged in the God's final court.

Answer 3

Many concepts are like the pain that you experience. You can display effects of a pain with expressions, sounds and gestures, but can anyone feel you pain for you. You cant prove pain to anyone else. Rebirth is one such concept. Allah is such a Truth. If someone asks to prove, we can't. But His efffects are visible and accepted as proof enough. We need to accept this Truth.

We dont try to prove or disprove Allah - He exists period. :-)

Rebirth is a concept which needs no proof. It exist period :-)

Answer 4

"Truth" is different from "fact" when you're speaking of truth in this sense. The concept of rebirth is true for some people because it resonnates with them in a very deep way. It's not true for other people because it doesn't resonnate with them. If it doesn't resonnate with them, there's no way to prove it. It's not "provable", and this is where truth and fact diverge.

Answer 5

Rebirth is not blind hope, it is realization through practice.
There is no physical rebirth.
Spiritual rebirth depending on water and fire. Water is the teachings in the Holy Books and fire is the love of God.
All religious knowledge as well as scientific knowledge can only be acquired through systematic learning and true faith. Systematic learning is done through thoughtful planning and constant practice; faith is improved through conscious knowledge, firm resolution and devoted action.

Answer 6

You can prove that it's true by experiencing it for yourself. Just go straight to God and ask to be reborn.

If it doesn't work, nothing is lost.

Answer 7

If they do not believe in something,no body can force them.Same way no body can force a Christian to have four wives or marry a nine year old baby.It is all matter of faith.You have faith in something,you should keep your faith to yourself.

Answer 8

muslims don't believe it.there is no such teaching in islam.quran never said it,prophet muhammad never said it.

there is another fake Proud Muslimah Beautiful Islam.

Answer 9

EVERY RELIGION HAS ITS OWN PHILOSOPHY.THERE ARE INNUMERABLE RECORDED INSTANCES OF CHILDREN REMEMBERING THEIR PREVIOUS BIRTHS. THE LAMAS OF BUDHISM PREDICT THEIR REBIRTHS FROM WHERE THEY ARE LOCATED AND ANOINTED.

Answer 10

Islam says you live only once, so make the most of it and do good deeds..