If God is ALL POWERFUL/ALL KNOWING,did he know Adam&Eve would CHOOSE to eat the fruit, even before they ate it

Question

If God DIDNT know, then how could he be omnipotent and all knowing? Then he wouldn't be a God, right?

If he God DID know that Adam and Eve were going to CHOOSE to eat the fruit, even before they ate it...then why did he allow it to happen, knowing that them eating it would damn all mankind?

Answer 1

Just another christian contradiction. Thats why I choose atheism.

Atheism, you know it makes sense.

Answer 2

Your question contains the answer. God is all knowing, therefore God knew that the serpent would deceive Eve and that Adam would sin. But what was Adam's sin? Was it sin to eat the fruit from the tree of knowledge of good or evil? Or was the sin a sin of disobedience as all sin is (that's a lot of sin in one SINtence!)?

Let's have a little fun. I've got a friend who calls himself God. When I was a kid I'd expect someone to be struck down by lightning for saying something like that. Anyway, my friend said he went to see a psychiatrist and told the doctor that, "My name is God". The doctor looked sideways at my friend and said, "You can't be God, you're just an ordinary man!" My friend told him, "How do you know I'm not God, are you God?" The psychiatrist threw him out of his office.

Is there a point to this story? I don't know. But I do know that all the fish in the sea are not thirsty.

Go back to the story as it is written and you'll find that Eve was deceived. Adam made a choice. Now, put yourself in both their positions. Would you have done any better?

We have the knowledge of good and evil. We know what sin is. Adam and Eve just heard about it. I'm not sure they realized what the consequences were. They found out. Just like we find out. We're taught, at least most of us are taught the difference between right and wrong when we're children. Yet, for some strange reason, without fail, we end up sinning.

I know of only one child who grew up and did not sin. In the end, he became a curse - sin.

God has reserved some knowledge for himself.

Other relevant questions include:

1. What is sin?
2. If God created all things, did God create sin?
3. Is this all a quality control experiment for freewill?
4. What was that tricky serpent doing in that beautiful garden in the first place?
5. Since I did not ask to be born, why does the world not owe me a living?

Some questions is just for the askin'!

Answer 3

Oh melanie it is so good to know someone else has thought this too. Don't get me long I love God I am just trying to understand him and am using my free will he gave me to question all things. Thats the biggest turn off to christianity for me are the close minded people that pretty much say "well if the bible said it I beleive it!" I mean the bible was written by men. It is a historical book and yes I believe can help us know a lot about Christians back then but it's like I think "wait a minute if god knew we were gonna do the wrong thing why let us?" 4000 years of death and sickness and wars and famine just because two people couldn't do the right thing? That irks me a bit in itself. Except I just had an epiphany. Maybe thats why christ paid for our sins. Through Adam and Eve we were all condemned and through Christ we are all set free and recieve the benefit of his sacrafice. I don't know there are so many questions about the bible that you think you figure out one only to open a door to 40 more,

Answer 4

You are absolutely right, and this is the result of Arminianism -- it's bad theology that breeds questions like this that cannot be resolved with any amount of doublespeak.

If God is to be omnipotent, then man must be damaged, and it's fairly easy to see in the Bible what kind of damage is involved. No one seeks Him. All have sinned and fallen short of the glory of God. Adam took all of humanity down with him through the doctrine of original sin.

Therefore, yes, take all the free will you want, it leads to the same destruction. So to answer your questions:

- God made Adam and Eve good. They sinned. God did not cause them to sin, they did this on their own. They chose freely, just like we choose freely today. Same result, but we were born into sin, Adam was not.

- Your premise is correct that if God did not know then he could not by definition be omnipotent and all-knowing. Therefore something must be wrong with man, and the Bible supports the fact that man is guilty and stands condemned before the Lord.

- If God did know in advance, then he allowed this to happen for his own glory.

Answer 5

First , you misquote the Bible vast time. 2nd, springing up Adam & Eve isn't magic. it relatively is a time whilst guy with technologies ought to manage molecules to create a human physique. of direction the physique might haven't any life. could be basically as a sculpture. 2nd, bearing directly to the fruit, on a similar time as we communicate that are ingredients that effect the way we see the international (psychotropic). Why could no longer a fruit be able to confirm them to ask themselves questions approximately what's around them? Hell is basically the absence of God. simply by fact God is the source of each and every thing it incredibly is stable, hell turns right into a bad place, considering which you do no longer hae what you require. And the area with Noah ark isn't a legend. The DNA strings proves that each and every person human beings have a human ancestor around that factor. Plus all historical civilisation remember of their writings the flood and place in a similar era.And bearing directly to the final question: purely Jesus has a human face simply by fact he took human physique. the different individual do no longer unavoidably have a human face, yet can anticipate one. actually there's a verse that proclaims: no guy can see the face of God and stay.

Answer 6

Yes, I believe he did know. If you don't believe in God, then you will never understand so stop reading right here. But if you do believe in God then you should realize how loving he is because even though he knew that he would have to pay for that sin with his own blood, he went ahead and created us anyway.

Answer 7

yes, he did!
And yes, he is the all mighty and all knowing.
Before we resolve what you call a contradiction
we first need to understand why Adam and Eve were
created...
were they created to live there in heaven....or else live on earth?
were they supposed to enjoy blessings they
havn't worked to deserve...or work hard to get them?
I believe they were meant to live on earth...and wouldn't enjoy
the blessings in heaven without working hard to get them.
So, for me, the question should be in diferent form:
Knowing that God knew it, why did he send them there after all?
It's for them to know that heaven is for real, and to indirectly tell them that heaven is their home...actually it was the home of Adam and Eve ...and that they should work hard to find the way back there...if they long to home.
Plus, it is the first story in man's history that proves that we have the choice to either obay or dis-obay...and we will be judged accordingly...and it doesn't have to do with 'God not knowing!!!'

Answer 8

Certainly God knows everything. But he wants to test them. Imagine there is a teacher and student. The student taking exam and he is be hard to do test and the teacher helps the student. It can't be thinked. If there is something like that the test will have no emphasis. Think Like That...

Answer 9

Either he exists, and is actually a mean little kid with an ant farm, or he doesn't. I think the latter option makes the most sense.

Answer 10

Yes, God knew they would fail, but if he would not have allowed them to fail, basically humans would not have had free will, and basically would have been robots!!! By the way, he didnt just leave humans out to dry. Thats why Jesus came, to basically reconcil us back to God....anyway, thats my 30 page answer in a paragraph.

Answer 11

He knew and He created us anyway. He knew that He would have to eventually send His Son to be tortured and killed in taking the penalty for all mankinds sin, but He created us anyway. He had to give us free will if we were to be thinking, emotive beings made in HIS IMAGE. He could have created us without free will, programmed to be good, nice, obedient people. But then we wouldnt be REAL, without free will, He would never know if we really loved Him as it wouldnt be out of our choice but because he forced us to. He wanted us to love and obey him out of choice, not because we had to.