how can i get my 4 year old dog to stop going potty in the house?

Question

My dog gets to go out 2xs a day, ran and allowed time to go potty...
She gets fed the same time, the same amount during the day...
Sometimes she goes weeks without going in the house...
If she is put in another room by herself she will go, if she is left in the house, sometimes she is good and then there are random times she goes??
I cant figure out what to do...
i tried holding her face close to the mess and yell no
i have left her in the cage while i wasnt around, then after a couple days i would let her free when i left for only a few hours, then built it up...
she has nothing to be jealous about, she gets the same attention as before, she gets well fed, well loved and played with...
any suggestions, that are serious, would be greatly appreciated.

thanks!!
its been going on for the last couple months...

Answer 1

keep him outside, he'll learn

Answer 2

Are you taking her out at the same times everyday? She may not be able to hold all day long.

Putting her face by the mess and yelling No, has no training value what so ever. You can only punish your dog if you catch her in the act.

I'd crate her while you are gone, or keep her in a room you know she won't eliminate in. Also be sure to clean up the mess with an enzymatic cleaner such as Nature's Miracle. This way there is no trace of previous accidents for her to be attracted back to.

Alot of times when a dog forgets its housetraining it can be because of a medical problem a UTI for instance will cause inappropriate elimination. Once treated the dog can return to its normally housetrained self.

Contrary to what a lot of people seem to think, dogs don't do things out of spite. If she is eliminating in the house there is a valid doggie reason for it.

Answer 3

depending on the size of your dog you have to consider the amount of food you're feeding it and the amount of water . larger dogs take longer to digest food , smaller dogs digest food faster ,so letting the dog out sooner will greatly decrease the Chance of it making a mess in the house ! placing the dogs face in the mess does nothing to teach the dog what it did wrong . training a dog takes lots of patience and time . then some dogs ,like humans have trouble holding their bowl movement and have accidents .for this type of dog you can only take precautions in placing down training paper .you can find it at your local pet store you cad also try installing a dogie door which gives access to the out side for your dog all the time if this is possible . but just remember that love and patience is what a dog needs .NEVER yell or put the dogs face in the mess because a dog has only a short attention span a can never understand why making a mess in the house is wrong

Answer 4

first i would suggest an exam by a vet to rule out any possible medical problems. while there ask about the possibility of sepration anxiety...i am including a link....i had a dog that had this...was a great dog, but every time i left for work and when i came back, my home looked like a tornado had hit. trash everywhere, poop in several places from a house broke dog, i was going thru tough times and ...well there really is no excuse, i had reached my limits with her and didnt know why she would do this...3 day in a row i beat her. did she stop. no. did it break my heart. yes. finally i asked a vet and they told me about SA and suggested i lock her in my room when i left. because it was the room that the smell of me was strongest...it would act like her "den" and provide her a feeling of security. i covered all the windows so it would be dark, and put the kitties with her for companionship (they were friends) and did just that...and it worked, nothing destroyed, no poop. i also found that if i took her to work with me she would stay in the car all night and not destroy anything their either...i do think their may be meds for it now tho....

http://www.judithstock.com/Speaking_of_Animals/Separation_Anxiety_in_Pets/separation_anxiety_in_pets.html

good luck

Answer 5

i don't mean to sound harsh but you do have a dog and not a camel. i suggest letting her go outside a little more than that.
i mean, realistically...do you always go only twice a day?
that's why it doesn't always happen everyday because sometimes 2 times is enough...but just like us humans sometimes 2 times is NOT enough and maybe she needs 3, 4, or maybe even 5.
if it's a smaller dog...especially because the smaller the dog the smaller the bladder.

Answer 6

dogs need to go pee more often than 2xsa day so if he can't get out he will go in the house start taking him out more often or get domeone to do it for u is u can't

Answer 7

how many times a day do you go potty? try taking him out every two hours. something is confuseing her or upsetting her. Fix it!!!!!!

Answer 8

Give it a spanking a it will learn. Not that hard so that it hurts but enough so it knows that you are mad.

Answer 9

Take your dog for long walks....

Answer 10

Providing your puppy or dog with an indoor kennel crate can satisfy many dogs' need for a den-like enclosure. Besides being an effective housebreaking tool (because it takes advantage of the dog's natural reluctance to soil its sleeping place), it can also help to reduce separation anxiety, to prevent destructive behavior (such as chewing furniture), to keep a puppy away from potentially dangerous household items (i.e., poisons, electrical wires, etc.), and to serve as a mobile indoor dog house which can be moved from room to room whenever necessary.


A kennel crate also serves as a travel cabin for you dog when travelling by car or plane. Additionally, most hotels which accept dogs on their premises require them to be crated while in the room to prevent damage to hotel furniture and rugs.


Most dogs which have been introduced to the kennel crate while still young grow up to prefer their crate to rest in or "hang-out" in. Therefore a crate (or any other area of confinement) should NEVER be used for the purpose of punishment.


We recommend that you provide a kennel crate throughout your dog's lifetime. Some crates allow for the removal of the door once it is no longer necessary for the purpose of training. The crate can be placed under a table, or a table top can be put on top of it to make it both unobtrusive and useful.


Preparing the Crate

Vari-Kennel type: Take the crate apart, removing the screws, the top and the door. Allow your pup to go in and out of the bottom half of the crate before attaching the top half. This stage can require anywhere from several hours to a few days. This step can be omitted in the case of a young puppy who accepts crating right away.


Wire Mesh type:Tie the crate door back so that it stays open without moving or shutting closed. If the crate comes with a floor pan, place a piece of cardboard or a towel between the floor (or crate bottom) and the floor pan in order to keep it from rattling.


Furnishing Your Puppy's Crate

Toys and Treats: Place your puppy's favorite toys and dog treats at the far end opposite the door opening. These toys may include the "Tuffy", "Billy", "Kong", "Nylabone" or a ball. Toys and bails should always be inedible and large enough to prevent their being swallowed. Any fragmented toys should be removed to prevent choking and internal obstruction. You may also place a sterilized marrow bone filled with cheese or dog treats in the crate.


Water: A small hamster-type water dispenser with ice water should be attached to the crate if your puppy is to be confined for more than two hours in the crate.


Bedding: Place a towel or blanket inside the crate to create a soft, comfortable bed for the puppy. If the puppy chews the towel, remove it to prevent the pup from swallowing or choking on the pieces. Although most puppies prefer lying on soft bedding, some may prefer to rest on a hard, flat surface, and may push the towel to one end of the crate to avoid it. If the puppy urinates on the towel, remove bedding until the pup no longer eliminates in the crate.


Location of Crate

Whenever possible, place the crate near or next to you when you are home. This will encourage the pup to go inside it without his feeling lonely or isolated when you go out. A central room in the apartment (i.e.: living room or kitchen) or a large hallway near the entrance is a good place to crate your puppy.


Introducing the Crate to Your Puppy

In order that your puppy associate his/her kennel crate with comfort, security and enjoyment, please follow these guidelines:




Occasionally throughout the day, drop small pieces of kibble or dog biscuits in the crate. While investigating his new crate, the pup will discover edible treasures, thereby reinforcing his positive associations with the crate. You may also feed him in the crate to create the same effect. If the dog hesitates, it often works to feed him in front of the crate, then right inside the doorway and then, finally, in the back of the crate.


In the beginning, praise and pet your pup when he enters. Do not try to push, pull or force the puppy into the crate. At this early stage of introduction only inducive methods are suggested. Overnight exception: You may need to place your pup in his crate and shut the door upon retiring. (In most cases, the crate should be placed next to your bed overnight. If this is not possible, the crate can be placed in the kitchen, bathroom or living room.)


You may also play this enjoyable and educational game with your pup or dog: without alerting your puppy, drop a small dog biscuit into the crate. Then call your puppy and say to him, "Where's the biscuit? It's in your room." Using only a friendly, encouraging voice, direct your pup toward his crate. When the puppy discovers the treat, give enthusiastic praise. The biscuit will automatically serve as a primary reward. Your pup should be free to leave its crate at all times during this game. Later on, your puppy's toy or ball can be substituted for the treat.


It is advisable first to crate your pup for short periods of time while you are home with him. In fact, crate training is best accomplished while you are in the room with your dog. Getting him used to your absence from the room in which he is crated is a good first step. This prevents an association being made with the crate and your leaving him/her alone.








A Note About Crating Puppies

Puppies under 4 months of age have little bladder or sphincter control. Puppies under 3 months have even less. Very young puppies under 9 weeks should not be crated, as they need to eliminate very frequently (usually 8-12 times or more daily).


Important Reminders

Collars: Always remove your puppy or dog's collar before confining in the crate. Even flat buckle collars can occasionally get struck on the bars or wire mesh of a crate. If you must leave a collar on the pup when you crate him (e.g.: for his identification tag), use a safety "break away" collar.


Warm Weather: Do not crate a puppy or dog when temperatures reach an uncomfortable level. This is especially true for the short-muzzled (Pugs, Pekes, Bulldogs, etc.) and the Arctic or thick- coated breeds (Malamutes, Huskies, Akitas, Newfoundlands, etc.). Cold water should always be available to puppies, especially during warm weather. [Never leave an unsupervised dog on a terrace, roof or inside a car during warm weather. Also, keep outdoor exercise periods brief until the hot weather subsides.]


Be certain that your puppy has fully eliminated shortly before being crated. Be sure that the crate you are using is not too large to discourage your pup from eliminating in it. Rarely does a pup or dog eliminate in the crate if it is properly sized and the dog is an appropriate age to be crated a given amount of time. If your pup/dog continues to eliminate in the crate, the following may be the causes:



The pup is too young to have much control.


The pup has a poor or rich diet, or very large meals.


The pup did not eliminate prior to being confined.


The pup has worms.


The pup has gaseous or loose stools.


The pup drank large amounts of water prior to being crated.


The pup has been forced to eliminate in small confined areas prior to crate training.


The pup/dog is suffering from a health condition or illness (i.e., bladder infection, prostate problem, etc.)


The puppy or dog is experiencing severe separation anxiety when left alone.



Note: Puppies purchased in pet stores, or puppies which were kept solely in small cages or other similar enclosures at a young age (between approximately 7 and 16 weeks of age), may be considerably harder to housebreak using the crate training method due to their having been forced to eliminate in their sleeping area during this formative stage of development. This is the time when most puppies are learning to eliminate outside their sleeping area. Confining them with their waste products retards the housebreaking process, and this problem can continue throughout a dog's adult life.


Accidents In The Crate

If your puppy messes in his crate while you are out, do not punish him upon your return. Simply wash out the crate using a pet odor neutralizer (such as Nature's Miracle, Nilodor, or Outright). Do not use ammonia-based products, as their odor resembles urine and may draw your dog back to urinate in the same spot again.




Crating Duration Guidelines


9-10 Weeks
Approx. 30-60 minutes

11-14 Weeks
Approx. 1-3 hours

15-16 Weeks
Approx. 3-4 hours

17 + Weeks
Approx. 4+ (6 hours maximum)



*NOTE: Except for overnight, neither puppies nor dogs should be crated for more than 5 hours at a time. (6 hours maximum!)


The Crate As Punishment

NEVER use the crate as a form of punishment or reprimand for your puppy or dog. This simply causes the dog to fear and resent the crate. If correctly introduced to his crate, your puppy should be happy to go into his crate at any time. You may however use the crate as a brief time-out for your puppy as a way of discouraging nipping or excessive rowdiness.

[NOTE: Sufficient daily exercize is important for healthy puppies and dogs. Regular daily walks should be offered as soon as a puppy is fully immunized. Backyard exercize is not enough!]


Children And The Crate

Do not allow children to play in your dog's crate or to handle your dog while he/she is in the crate. The crate is your dog's private sanctuary. His/her rights to privacy should always be respected.


Barking In The Crate

In most cases a pup who cries incessantly in his crate has either been crated too soon (without taking the proper steps as outlined above) or is suffering from separation anxiety and is anxious about being left alone. Some pups may simply under exercised. Others may not have enough attention paid them. Some breeds of dog may be particularly vocal (e.g., Miniature Pinchers, Mini Schnauzers, and other frisky terrier types). These dogs may need the "Alternate Method of Confining Your Dog", along with increasing the amount of exercise and play your dog receives daily.


When Not To Use A Crate

Do not crate your puppy or dog if:



s/he is too young to have sufficient bladder or sphincter control.


s/he has diarrhea. Diarrhea can be caused by: worms, illness, intestinal upsets such as colitis, too much and/or the wrong kinds of food, quick changes in the dogs diet, or stress, fear or anxiety.


s/he is vomiting.


you must leave him/her crated for more than the Crating Duration Guidelines suggest.


s/he has not eliminated shortly before being placed inside the crate.
(See Housetraining Guidelines for exceptions.)


the temperature is excessively high.


s/he has not had sufficient exercise, companionship and socialization.











Buying a Crate

Where to buy a crate: Crates can be purchased through most pet supply outlets, through pet mail order catalogs and through most professional breeders. Some examples are:




Crate Size and Manufacturers:
Dog Size:

Small: (Vari-Kennel #100 or General Cage #201)
Toy Poodles, the Maltese, etc., with average weight of 6-10 lbs.

Medium Small: (Vari-Kennel #200 or General Cage #202/212)
Mini Schnauzers, Jack Russells, etc., with average weight of 11-20 lbs.

Medium: (Vari-Kennel #300 or General Cage #203/213)
Cocker Spaniels, Field Spaniels, small Shelties, etc., with average weight of 21-40 lbs.

Large: (Vari-Kennel #400 or General Cage #204/214)
Huskies, large Samoyeds, small Golden Retrievers, etc., with average weight of 41-65 Ibs.

Very Large: (Vari-Kennel #500 or General Cage #205/215)
German Shepherds, Alaskan Malamutes, Rottweilers, etc., with average weight of 67-100 lbs.

Extra Large: (General Cage #206 or Mid-West #89-Z, 89-E or 99)
Newfoundlands, Great Danes, etc, with average weight of 110 lbs. plus.









The Cost of A Crate

Crates can cost between $35 and $150 depending on the size and the type of crate and the source.




The Cost of Not Buying a Crate


The cost of not using a crate:



your shoes


books


table legs;


chairs and sofas;


throw rugs and carpet, and


electric, telephone and computer wires.


The real cost, however, is your dog's safety and your peace of mind.


Alternative Method Of Confining Your Puppy


There are alternative methods to crating very young puppies and puppies who must be left alone in the house for lengths of time exceeding the recommended maximum duration of confinement (see Crating Duration Guidelines). We suggest the following:


Use a small to medium-sized room space such as a kitchen, large bathroom or hallway with non- porous floor. Set up the crate on one end, the food and water a few feet away, and some newspaper (approx. 2'x3' to 3'x3') using a 3 to 4 layer thickness, several feet away. Confine your puppy to this room or area using a 3 ft. high, safety-approved child's gate rather than shutting off the opening by a solid door. Your pup will feel less isolated if it can see out beyond its immediate place of confinement. Puppy proof the area by removing any dangerous objects or substances.

By Robin Kovary, with Barbara Giella

Please see: "How to Successfully Housetrain Your Puppy"