pug or boston terrier?

Question

so ive research both breeds because in the beggining i wanted a pug sooo bad and i mean ive been wanting one for so long but through out my research it became clear that alot of people commented about how bad a pug sheds,but i want more input about it is it really that bad? i live at home with my parents (im 20) and im sure they would hate having hair all over the house ,so my next choice is a boston terrier i did research about the breed but yet again i want a second opinion i know like the pug they both have medical problems at some point but im kind of overlooking that because i would take care of it im just a little concern about the shedding how bad is it for a pug ? and howbad is it for a boston ?

ive seen quite a few pics of boston and they look a lot bigger that what the description of the breed lists them

ive had a pitbull pup so the hyperness would not be aproblem ,i just wanted to know for sure how bad the shedding from a pug is i do think they are adorable but i think shedding is ok just not in tons
thanks for your replies and ill keep searching anybody has a black pug?? is the shedding a lil less??

Answer 1

I have two pugs, and I'm sure all pugs are different.. but if you don't want a shedder, DON'T GET A PUG. I've never, ever seen anything like it. I'm amazed at the hair. If you pinch any hair anywhere, you can literally pull out about 30 hairs at a time.. and it keeps coming... and coming... you'd think she'd be bald. They shed more than any of the short haired dogs I've ever owned, and more than long hair dogs I grew up with. I've never seen a dog shed more than a pug, so don't get one if you can't deal with hair all over all your clothing and furniture! Good Luck with your search.

Answer 2

They both shed the same. Bostons usually don't have as much breathing problems as a Pug has, although it's still present.

My Boston Terrier is by far the most intelligent and wonderful dog I've ever owned. To be honest, I absolutely hated dogs until I met her -- she has made me value and become aware of how wonderful a dog's companionship is. She knew commands by 12 weeks old and was completely house trained. I would be lost without her. She is also the funniest and most humourous dog I've ever seen with the greatest personality.

The only drawback is that unless you have experience with high energy breeds like a Boston, do your research. They are very, very hyper little dogs. Look at yourself realistically and ask yourself if you really have the time to walk a dog for atleast 15-30 minutes a day, minimum. Pugs nor Bostons do well in high temperatures. They are NOT outside dogs. Because of this know you will NOT be able to let your dog run off the energy outside all day, they are prone to heat strokes etc. Be prepared for a constant longing to play fetch, and a lifelong companion that will give you puppykisses in the morning. It's the best thing in the world.

To get a feel of Boston Terriers and their owners, I STRONGLY point you to this community. You can really get a feel for their personalities.
http://boston_buddies.livejournal.com

Answer 3

I had this same problem when I wanted a dog...except I do not live with my parents.
I have a pug she is so full of life and energy it is hard to say upset when you have a "clown" around she is crazy...you can just look into her eyes and see she is full of it!!!
Yes, she does shed but it you brush the pug every other day is does help put a bunch! There will still be hair though that does escape onto everything. You also have to clean their nose wrinkle with a q-tip at least once a week.
Having a pug around is worth all the hair though I promise. I crate trained her and she slept in her cage till she was 1 now she sleeps with me. I had to make sure she was completely poddy trained before she received "special" treatment....pugs they are a stubborn breed!
I do not know much Boston Terriers any more this was over a year ago.
I hope this helps you in some way.

Answer 4

I've had experience with both breeds, and they are both great dogs. Pugs DO shed a lot. If you really want the look of a pug but don't want to deal with all the hair, I'm going to say get a mixed breed of a pug and boston terrier. I have one, shes great. She has the pug look, and the boston terriers color. She doesn't shed nearly as bad as the other pugs I've had. Actually, it comes no where near as bad. She's great, very friendly, loyal, smart, and very affectionate.

Pugs normally have breathing problems because of their short stout nose, but the boston terrier has a bit longer nose. When the two breeds combine, this helps bring out the nose a little bit which helps out with so many medical problems (breathing being a very big one.)

The boston is a little bit bigger than the Pug, but it really isn't that big of a difference.

Good luck!

Answer 5

This question makes me giggle.

I have a pug and I would not trade her for the world. The reason a fawn pug sheds a lot if that they have a double coat. Maybe get a black pug, which has a single coat.

When you pet the pug, you will have hair all over your lap when you are finished, but I really don't think that they shed more than a cat does. A boston terrier is going to shed as well, too. My colleague at work has a Boston and we always laugh about the dog hair that we have on our work chairs because of our dogs.

Pugs are really wonderful pets. They aren't as strong and solid as Boston Terriers. They are both great breeds. Boston Terriers always try to hump my pug at the dog park so they do seem to be more aggressive than pugs. And, they are bigger. My pug is more submissive than a lot of dogs, though.

Good luck!

Answer 6

Boston Terriers shed alot too, even with their short hair, they do shed. And they are really, really hyper. It depends on the Boston Terrier, we have a Boston Terrier, thats mother weighs like 25 lbs, but her father was like 15 lbs. Our Boston Terrier weighs 20 lbs at 11 months old. My mom has to sweep everyday in our kitchen, from our Boston Terrier. I dont how old your parents are, but if they are older, maybe a Boston Terrier isnt the best choice because they are so hyper, and jump alot. My friend has a three year old Boston terrier and it is really hyper too. Good Luck, if it was me, I'd see how hyper a Pug is, and then make the choice, because I think they both shed the same amount. They need lost a room to release their energy and need alot of attention, our Boston Terrier wines if we arent giving her attention. So Good luck.

Answer 7

I love pugs and boston terriers but in my "acquaintance" with them, the boston terriers seemed to have a better personality. This is a big generalisation! I agree about the dogs shedding the same amount and short-haired dogs are better IMO than long haired due to the amount of hair. If you're really concerned, check out "mixes" with poodles. They are known for little/ no shedding.

Answer 8

I dated someone who is a dog trainer and had a houseful of AKC pugs - showed them as well. They do shed, but so does any shorthaired dog. Terriers have more of a driven personality - a small difference. I never did like small dogs, but I loved all the pugs. Like any small breed, sizes can differ among BTs as well as pugs but pugs tend to stay smaller more routinely.

Answer 9

Both shed. You should do some research on non-shedding dogs. I have a bichon frise who literally never sheds a hair. He has hair, not fur. Feels kind of like a sheep. There are lots of breeds that do not shed, or that shed very little. Pugs and bostons shed alot.

Answer 10

....the shedding is about the same on each...the biggest difference is temperment...if you like staying home in front of the tv...pug, if you want a little friend that will go everywhere, bostie..also, a properly bred Bostie doesn't have health problems...a puppy mill Bostie will often have an elogated paleete that requires $1300 surgery....with pugs, its usually just snoring and snorting....Bosties are also getting bigger and more boxer like all the time, mine is a more frenchie type at twelve pounds, and shes gorgeous! best of Luck!