What do you think of this idea?

Question

I think the US should make it very easy to obtain a work visa to come to the US with these guidelines:
1. All workers are to pay a set 25% tax rate.
2. They will not be allowed to use our social services.
3. They are not elligible for Social Security benefits.
4. All these regulations can change upon get legal citizenship.
5. Use a database to verify status upon employment and punishing businesses who violate these regulations.
The reason for this is because a large portion of immigrants come here and abuse our system with no intention of becoming citizens and eventually go back to their own country.

Answer 1

OK I would go along with that but ONLY IF all illegals are deported first and are identified as they return here. Employers who cheat the workers OR the government (on the taxes) would get mandatory 10 years in prison with no possibility for early release (for EACH infraction) AND alien workers caught cheating AND THEIR FAMILIES are deported immediately losing all their possessions and holdings, with no possibility for return for them OR their family members.

Answer 2

You're a tad behind the times. As brought to us by Bush while many were distracted with racist bickerings, we are now one "Superstate". N.A.F.T.A., as you know, is an economic alliance between Canada, the U.S. and Mexico. Without Congressional over-site, Bush this winter signed into law a political extension of that agreement in which the three nations are now the new North American "Superstate" called SPP. All borders are to be "streamlined" and eventually eliminated, major new toll highways are already planned to connect all three nations (including the big one eight football fields wide right up through the center of the new Superstate that the King of Spain will hold the lease and profits from), a common currency (eventually, not at first) and common citizenship. Mexico gets a chunk of Kansas to use as a staging area for it's highway management priviledges already leased and contracted. New eminent domain laws that are already in place and are already taking people's homes and property away from them if someone else can show that they could earn enough with that land to pay more property taxes, will pave the way, no pun intended, for all the new tollroads. Even our existing roads and docks and ports are being leased out by Bush's administration to foreign commercial interests and most current roads are going to be turned into tollroads, with profits going to foreign leaseholders. This isn't conjecture. It's in the news. I've seen the agreements and contracts. It's for real. Happy days are here again. U.S. citizens aren't going to get to work much on all the new highway work. Unless they are willing to pay 25% tax rate. Hey! See . . . you had the right idea all along! Here is the new government's official website:
http://spp.gov/

Answer 3

1. I think you should pay the 25% tax rate.
2. I think you should not be allowed Social Services.
3. I think you should not be eligible forr Social Security benefits.
4. I think you should show PROOF of CITIZENSHIP.

The reason fo this is because a large portion of people living here in the USA abuse the system just the same as illegal immigrants and eventually put all the blame on those poor unfortunate souls.

Answer 4

All five suggestions are great. In addition, they should be deported immediately and not allowed to return if they are convicted of any felony.

Just heard one-half of the prision population in California are illegal immigrants.

I will not vote for anyone who does not pledge to tackle the illegal immigrant problem.

Seems the Dems are not going to address this problem. Talk but do nothing. This is a problem both parties could get together about and solve. Alas, the will of the people who voted for them are ignored.

There are some Repub's I would like to vote for but their stand on illegal immigration will lose my vote.

Answer 5

If that means their children can't use our schools, fine. But that isn't what our own courts say, so that would be a big change. Especially if their children are born here.

Our schools are failing, and we are importing poverty, with all of its problems. There are reasons we have limits on immigration.

Answer 6

Nah, won't work. It's hard enough to live of of what immigrants (even the legal ones) are often paid without taking out 25% of taxes. And if you said "no social services" (I assume you mean, like, emergency rooms?) then you create a system in which a legal citizen might, if injured without his or her identification, be rejected on the mere suspicion of being an immigrant, while immigrants would be left out on the curb to bleed to death. I refuse to live in that kind of country. Could you?

Answer 7

There are too many here now, deportations need to be first then protect the border then start enforcing the laws that are on the books.

Answer 8

You would need to police this very closely. Fingerprint ID or eye scans similar to those of the airport requirements. Then I think it might work.

Answer 9

I think its wrong. There are immigration guidelines,that must be followed.
This is not lets make a deal.
Stop breaking the laws of our country.
America is our home,respect it !

Answer 10

Well immigrants do go back to their country of origin the main reason they come to US is to get a good life and share it back home.