Can mental illness remove free will?

Question

We don't have free will, but if we did....

Answer 1

Mental illness is a spawn of Satan. If you remove Satan through Christ, then you regain free will that you were blessed with.

Answer 2

I believe that it can. For example, my next door neighbor (whom I have lived next to for six years) is a very nice lady. She is also agoraphobic schizophrenic. On some days she is completely normal and can carry on a completely sane conversation with me about whatever. The next day I see her backing down her driveway, reaching the street, then zooming back up to the garage. She'll do it over and over again without ever leaving her driveway. But, she has NO idea she's even acting odd. To her it is completely normal.

Mental illness can involve cognitive, emotional, behavioral and interpersonal impairments. Insanity (which in my eyes entails complete removal or brief lack of free will) is also a LEGAL term, which means that it is deemed true and realized in our society.

Ha-ha-ha! Obsolete, so true.. and well put!

Answer 3

I actually like your detail better than the question but let me try.

I, believe it or not, agree with you that as you use the terminology "free will", we do not have it. Free will by definition infers the ability to make choices free from the constraint or resultant to natural law. We do not have this freedom.

I, know that we have what I term "Free Agency" or the ability to make decisions within the bounds of and having the effect of natural law bearing on those decisions. We have the freedom to act or choose but it is always bound to natural law and for every decision there is a result leading one toward or away from "truth". This is agency.

If I understand your question to mean are we free from responsibility of our acts do to mental illness? Then yes, if do to a condition that is beyond our ability to exercise will with agency, we commit acts, we are not accountable for that act.

Answer 4

It really depends on what free will is. I personally believe that we do not have it in the first place. We are likely a result of our environment, genes, and experiences. Mental illness could be caused by a lot of various means. People whom have tourette's syndrome will not have free will. It is not their choice to act as they are acting. People with obsessive compulsive disorder often find themselves repeating a task over and over again realizing they really do not wish to be as they are.

If there is free will, I would say mental illness blocks it.

Answer 5

Well, I guess that's what the insanity defense is about -- the person didn't know the difference between right and wrong. I think it's really impossible for us to judge whether a mentally ill person chooses their actions, but fortunately, God knows the heart..

Answer 6

I m surprised in any respect the solutions right here which stated sure. those individuals are clarly no longer conscious of somewhat some the extra debilitating ailments, which contain paranoid schizophrenia. What if somebody is having paranoid hallucinations? Then if he commits homicide, it relatively is conceivable that for the duration of his innovations, it became into fascinated by self protection. Is it the superb option to deliver this man or woman to detention center and hell? i might say it relatively is a very difficult subject, in spite of the incontrovertible fact that it would not look morally justfied to realize this. playstation . I dont think of absolutely everyone has unfastened will relatively. Attitudes, evaluations, and tastes are remarkably consistent in comparable twins, even whilst they have been reared one after the different. and because we base our movements on attitudes, and evaluations, our movements are no longer in all probability unfastened, yet in basic terms the end results of a genetic reason. depressing, no? it relatively is my handle this in any case. i might desire to be very incorrect.

Answer 7

I think a person is acountable...

God certianly understands depression and other afflictions and is merciful

I think a person still have some will and acountability... the issue of free will is a leaded term... we have free wills but since we have natures that are tinged with evil and fallen... the will is free but it is a sin tinged willl and radically corrupted... tinged and limited by the sinful nature... we need grace bigtime

Answer 8

Legally, yes. In actuality, who knows except the mentally ill?

Answer 9

Yes it can.That is why it is so important to seek the Lord while He may be found. Isa.55:6 ; 2 Chronicles 15:2

Answer 10

No! But prison can remove your freedom for willingly violating another's free will.