Muslims, can you explain to me how the following verse from the Hadith is peaceful?

Question

According to Ibn Abbas, the Prophet said "Kill him who changes his religion,” “behead him,” and “Any person who has changed his religion, kill him.” (Al-Bukhari, Vol. 9, p. 45).

While you're at it, here's another one:

“Uqba mocked Muhammad in Mecca and wrote derogatory verses about him. He was captured during the Battle of Badr, and Muhammad ordered him to be executed. 'But who will look after my children, O Muhammad?' Uqba cried with anguish. 'Hell,' retorted the prophet coldly. Then the sword of one of his followers cut through Uqba’s neck.” (March 624: Uqba bin Abu Muayt)

Once you're done with the mental gymnastics required to spin these scriptures into something benevolent, perhaps you can tell me how they should be applied to the modern world.

p.s. I'm an atheist (aka, not a Jew, Christian, Buddhist, etc.), so pointing out the Crusades or some other trinket of history won't add much credence to your argument.

Answer 1

Well, first.. let me clarify that Islam is not a "non violent" religion. Violence is permitted in certain cases. And if violence has been permitted in a certain case, then it has been allowed by God and humans cannot question it. Second, I cannot take your word for the accuracy of these hadith, and I don't have the books to look it up right now. The second hadith you quoted is from a book called, "March"? I have never heard of this book. It doesn't even sound like a hadith book.

Answer 2

Assalamu Alikum Wa Rahmatu Allahi Wa Baraku, i love your element of view very a lot and that i extremely recognize the way you’ve finished the study in this and that i pray that Allah save you very prepared to understand the right element to do. There’s defiantly an extremely relied on opinion that asserts it’s okay to attempt this if it’s the in hardship-free words thanks to strive against someone who've actually raped our females and took our properties. i have self assurance that usually the answer to this question can not be promptly cutting-edge in Quran or Sunnah because suicide bombing grow to be not available via the time Quran and Sunna the position written, so identifying no matter if it’s condoned or condemned can in hardship-free words be deduced via measuring this act antagonistic to similar acts that occurred throughout the time of Al Rasol’s existence and actual this must be finished via someone who's extremely specialist in Islamic Fatwa. for my area i imagine that the traditional type of conflict Allah has approved is an prepared conflict it truly is approved both to preserve our selves antagonistic to attach or to spread the note of Allah. the following we should be very careful because what’s happening to Muslims now's not be reason for our enemy’s ruthlessness regardless of the indisputable fact that it’s because we’re extremely very far remote from authentic Islam. So i imagine before questioning about suicide bombing or perhaps conflict we ought to attack our greatest enemy first and that’s being remote from Islam, it really is the authentic reason for the humiliation we’re at present subjected to. I also decide on to say that in some situations it really is been approved to kill an enemy of Islam not in the course of the conflict yet else via any available skill, an get jointly of this grow to be at the same time as a Jew wrote an abusing poetry antagonistic to our mom Aisha, Al Rasoul then gave an permission to all and assorted to kill that guy if he can. and some cases this grow to be finished is very much of hazards that it grow to be not a real suicide it grow to be very on the fringe of suicide. regardless of the reality that my opinion doesn’t signify an authority Islamic opinion regardless of the indisputable fact that the point I’m attempting to make the following is that suicide bombing isn't and is purely not the answer to Muslim issues regardless of the indisputable fact that the authentic answer for Muslims to flow again to authentic Islam and practice it. Paryers, Hani

Answer 3

in most countries at that time changing ur religion was as being a traitor to ur country and the second ans to ur question
he tried killing him first when the prophet was praying and later when at war he was caught and beheaded

Answer 4

Your first quote would be something tantamount to treason. Why don't you ask medieval France and England what they did to traitors? I'm pretty sure the answer would be similar.

As for the second, if somebody mocks you and writes derogatory comments about you, wouldn't you want revenge on them?


Also, it's not intended to be peaceful.

Answer 5

Then why are you asking this question just to mock Islam, you have made the story of Uqba to satisfy yourself and your old faith which i do not know

Answer 6

F**K ALL MUSLIMS IN THE WORLD!!!!!!

I HATE EM ALL.

p.s. I'm also an atheist (aka, not a Jew, Christian, Buddhist, etc.).