Which duo has killed more Muslims: US and Israel or Iraq and Iran?

Question

Yes this is a loaded question, but I'm curious as to the answers.

Several of you brought up a fair point. I meant civilians killed by any representatives of these countries. You might want to change your answer accordingly.

Answer 1

Iran and Iraq hold this dubious distinction undoubtedly. The site below has one history of their most recent conflict, '82-'88 and estimates a million deaths. Other accounts run up and down from that figure.

http://www.iranchamber.com/history/iran_iraq_war/iran_iraq_war3.php

If you also understand that most deaths in Iraq today and since early 2004 are caused by one or the other of these groups (or their survivors) then there is no question. Muslims kill Muslims when they aren't killing someone entirely outside their religion. That is the sad fact.

Answer 2

I would have to give it to Iraq and Iran right now.
The Real 2006
'Iraq Body Count'
Iraqi civilians killed last year by ISLAMIC Terrorists
16,791

Iraqi civilians killed collaterally in incidents involving Americans
(and Islamic Terrorists)
214*

*Source: IraqBodyCount.net

Answer 3

The amazing thing about Muslims like MAFOKOCHIZHI is the way they lie with a straight face. If their heros are murderers, they just blame the victims, as though the Jews were the criminals. Fortunately, most of us are not that foolish.

Israel kills Islamist murderers; the Muslims kill innocent Israeli citizens, and are PROUD of this fact. As in the case in Eilat, where the terrorist organizations were jumping over each other to take credit for the murder of Israelis.

And a guy like MAFOKOCHIZHI has no shame!

Answer 4

You need to clarify, do you mean INNOCENT Muslims? Or TERRORIST Muslims?

And if by "Iraq", do you mean Saddam Hussein? Or the insurgents in Iraq? Either way its still Iraq and Iran. Saddam killed a huge amount of his own people, then add that in with what the insurgents are doing.

Answer 5

Even the Falastinians kill more Muslims.

Hamas has planted roadside bombs along roads that PA Chairman Abbas was to have passed. Perhaps they consider him to be a nonbeliever, since the Quran commands (Sura 2:191): And slay them [the infidels] wherever ye find them, and drive them out of the places whence they drove you out, for persecution is worse than slaughter. And fight not with them at the Inviolable Mosque until they first attack you there, but if they attack you (there) then slay them. Such is the reward of nonbelievers."

Answer 6

As stated, that's a worthless question. You might as well ask, what kills more US Christians, war or automobile accidents? (automobile accidents would easily win that if you really cared...)

The important question if you're concerned with innocent deaths is which killed more civilian non-combatants, and Iraqi and Iranian terrorists clearly win that contest, hands down. The US has not killed tens of thousands of civilians as one answerer stated. That's patently false. War critics make up grossly exaggerated numbers like hundreds of thousands have died, or millions have died, but there is no basis for these estimates.

Answer 7

Iraq and Iran

Answer 8

Iraq and Iran have been at this war for hundreds of years. They win at killing the most people.

Answer 9

I think a more appropriate question would be how many Americans and Israelis have the Muslims killed...

Answer 10

Uhhh, I believe that would be Iraq and Iran, including the so-called "insurgents" (terrorists is what the are and what they should be called).