Is corporal punishment beneficial or detrimental to a child's future?

Answer 1

Corporal Punishment is beneficial for some children, not all. I use to do it for everything till I realized it was losing its effect. Now I reserve it only for extreme incidents.
I do believe it works most times, and should be differentiated from child abuse, which is excessive and can bring no benefit to a child's development.

Answer 2

Depends on how it's used.

I was spanked, and it wasn't the least detrimental to me. Once or twice it was even border-line on a beating, and it still wasn't detrimental. I don't know why people get so worked up when they see a kid get a pop on the butt or their hands slapped....

I can say from experience, that not using corporal punishment is alot more detrimental to the child..and the parent.

Answer 3

i do no longer position self assurance in corporal punishment for any reason. Why do people imagine it is completely fantastic to apply violence on childrens even as they would not assume the same component of their lives. are you able to imagine going to artwork and the boss popping out and saying, "properly, Bob, sales weren't very good very last quarter and it is because you have not been being attentive on your costs," and then getting punched interior the face? Violence is violence, and it would not remedy some thing. All it does is teach the youngster to be frightened of the parent. they don't the way in which to foretell outcomes of their habit more desirable than understanding they are going to get spanked in the experience that they get stuck. a better attitude is to have time outs and then ask the youngster why s/he became punished. in the experience that they get it incorrect, you tell them the perfect reason, then take a seat and clarify WHY the habit is undesirable. only telling a baby "no" would not get by ability of to them because they don't comprehend that you at the on the spot are not only saying no to decline. when they comprehend that you extremely do have their perfect pastimes at heart the habit will replace. little ones extremely, fairly go with to thrill their father and mom. also, remember the praise even as they do some thing precise like,"Jimmy, i spotted you hung up your coat precise once you purchased domicile. I only go with to inform you that you probably did a tremendous job, and that i extremely have a good time with it. you're any such help, and that i'm fortunate to have a baby like you." If a baby is advised that they are good, they are going to be good because it is what's anticipated of them. If all they listen is, "Dont try this, do not do this, why can't you behave, ect.," they're going to continually act up because they attempt to thrill their parent and from what they listen believe that the parent would not go with them to act properly.

Answer 4

I think if done properly it can be beneficial. It can also be very detrimental as well. We all need to get to know our children better. For example--if I spanked my children it wouldn't be beneficial for THEM. However, if Susie down the street does it might be beneficial to her own. If we all sought out better punishment and disciplining measures I feel many people would be pleasantly surprised that they do not need to spank to get their point across. However, many people still would.

It's a different answer for every different child, parent, and situation as to if corporal punishment is beneficial or detrimental to a child's future.

Answer 5

It *can* be beneficial, if used properly and *can* be deterimental if used improperly. However, I personally feel there's a very small window where spanking or physical punishment should be used. Never on a child younger than a year old (too young to cognitively connect physical punishment with an undesirable action) and rarely used on a toddler older than 3-4 years (who has reasoning ability and can be disciplined with revoked privileges or the like). I personally only used physical punishment (usually a pinch) in cases where my son was physically endangering himself (running from me in a parking lot).

Answer 6

When it comes to my personal experience I say it never solved the real issue... meaning that noone had to give deep physcological meaning to the reason I was coloring the walls or playing with the ball inside the house or putting my mom's clothes and jewlery when playing Barbie or why I blinded the cat while giving him a bath with clorox.
My Dad used to spank me because he never wanted to explained himself in pretty cute girly words...he didn't have the time or the energy. He was old fashioned. He would make the rules, he gave the warnings and BOOM God forbitted I forgot to follow or test his patience. I sure thought about it before doing any wrong again. I tell you one thing I never dared talked back to my dad or disrespect him in his eyes. I had big differences with him but I knew my dad loved me and protected me and always provided with no excuse.
One thing I found while growing up as a teenager, I was rebellious ( in a good way) and the stronger my dad was, the stronger I became to prove myself and my ideas. I question my teachers, my proffesor in colleges and today I question so called leaders and their true intentions.
Do I think of my DAD as abusive ...never. I think my character was built differently than in today's modern ways.
Today I tend to be strong with children I guess in a disciplinary way, but never spanked anyone yet. Corporal punishment is beneficial more than ever as long as there are no scars...if you know what I mean.
Sometimes children get carried away with remarks not necessary behaviors which may trigger your patience and lack of respect. Spank them, time out them, yell at them and then take vital signs or give CPR watch and listen what happens. Wait till he or she is ready to talk about it calmly. I guess in today's way it should be followed up with a 10min pos explanation of the incident.;) because children tend to be more informed. Information is always power. Let your children teach you how you should discipline them. Finding the balance is important. Always lead by example only that way children would look up to you.

Answer 7

I think corporal punishment is beneficial. Abuse is detrimental.

Answer 8

a spanking is needed every so often. now when a parent is doing it everyday, the positive effect it can possibly have is now gone. it's pointless. now if it's more than a spanking, yes it is detrimental. a child never forgets things like that.

Answer 9

Corporal punishment does not teach a child to be disciplined, which is the whole purpose of discipline- to teach. while it probably doesn't hurt them it sure doesn't help. I have spanked, but it's not how I discipline on a daily basis

Answer 10

I believe it teaches children that violence solves problems so, yes, it it detrimental.