What's the pernalty for apostate, Christianity and Islam, who is granted the rights to enforce such pernalties

Question

Aren't we living in a free world where you are given the free will to CHOOSE? Bizzare.

Answer 1

Many Christians seem to have a distorted view of judging others, that it should never happen. Scripture presents a different view...

1 Corinthians 5:12 Is it my business to judge those outside the church? Aren’t you supposed to judge those inside the church? 13 God will judge those outside. Scripture says, “Get rid of that evil person!”

Clearly, the church in Corinth was INSTRUCTED to exercise judgment in a particular case, so it is not ALWAYS wrong.

Answer 2

The Qur'an says "There is no compulsion in religion"
There is a hadith which says to kill apostates.


The Qur'an is considered the true word of Allah
The Hadith are a collection of sayings of the the Prophet, may contain mistakes, and one of the basic rules of the Science of Hadith is that no hadith can be in contradiction of the Qur'an.


Since this hadith is contradicting, I would think its not to be followed (some commentators say that was meant for some apostates who went around harassing Muslims, killing their livestock, and damaging their property).

Answer 3

In my opinion I don´t think men should punish other men for disobedience, we know from the Scriptures that God himself has punished people and that is the just thing since only Him can see what's in your heart, wether you repent with sincerity or not.
Only He can give a fair judgment and that will surely come on the Last day, every action will be accounted for and we will have to give reasons for them, may He have mercy on us all..!

Answer 4

What in the hell is a pernalites? Same as for misspelling...forty lashes..with a pigs tail.

Answer 5

GOD gave us right to chooses so my answer is GOD .

Answer 6

You can watch this for apostacy in Islam

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4TYOCR_6pFc