English Deutsch Français Italiano Español Português 繁體中文 Bahasa Indonesia Tiếng Việt ภาษาไทย
All categories

seeing as islam didnt start up until the 7th centuary where did mohammad get his information on Our Lord Jesus?

7th centuary christianity was pretty developed by that stage,
Why didnt mohammad consult the 4 gospels for his information?

We're christains,we are the experts on Jesus' life,how come he didnt ask us instead of going to some 3rd party hack for his information?

2007-01-22 21:42:29 · 22 answers · asked by ? 3 in Society & Culture Religion & Spirituality

22 answers

Muslims are so stupid, they say that the Bible is corrupted and false,

Muhammad got the information from the bible, and the qu'ran teaches that the bible is false.

Islam is a copycat religion. They should repent for our lord Jesus Christ.

2007-01-22 21:52:16 · answer #1 · answered by Anonymous · 4 7

Lol you have got it all wrong my friend. You must keep into mind that muslims actually CONVERTED from other religions into islam, they didn't just fall from the sky. That is one reason. Second, to be a Muslim, you must acknowledge the former existence of all prophets preceding Mohammad (pbuh) otherwise you are not considered a Muslim. Jesus is your prophet, noone is saying otherwise but Muslims also harbor the same love and respect that you do for him. Why would Muslims ask about Jesus's life? They already knew everything about him. Muslims are obligated to learn about every prophet - their life and death. There was no 3rd party hack lol. Another reason that Mohammad may not have consulted gospels as you say, which clearly slipped your mind, is because muslims and christians have different accounts on the way Jesus died, for one. Muslims believe he wasn't crucified. Muslims call him a prophet, Christians a God. No one is objecting to anyone's beliefs so they should be respected. Secondly, there are some disagreements on the way he lived but in the end, both religions revere him as a religious figure. Muslims knew everything about Jesus from the Quran which was a revelation from Allah and noone knows best about Jesus's life than God, not the Muslims nor the Christians. I hope I thoroughly answered your question. Please do not think I am implying hatred in my answer. On the contrary, I only wish that I have made you understand. Thank you for voicing this concern that I'm sure many wonder about. God bless you. Take care.
I hope that someday we can all live in peace and be one.

2007-01-22 22:01:23 · answer #2 · answered by Anonymous · 3 1

It is interesting to note that there were bishops during the first three hundred years of the Church that were teaching as the Muslim believes that Jesus (pbuh) was a prophet and teacher!! It was only after the conversion of Emperor Constantine that he was the one to call and introduce the doctrine of the Trinity. He a convert to Christianity who knew nothing of this religion introduced a paganistic concept that goes back to Babylonian times. Because the space does not permit me to go into detail about the subject insha'Allah, another time. Only I must point out that the word TRINITY is not found in the Bible in any of its many translation nor is it found in the original Greek or Hebrew languages!

2007-01-23 00:29:34 · answer #3 · answered by BeHappy 5 · 1 0

Firstly all the Prophets that were sent bought the same message, "submission to God" (Islam). Muhammad (pbuh) got his information from God, if you read the Quran that is God "speaking".

Muhammad (pbuh) was a man and a messenger from God. What makes you experts and what so sure that the information you have is correct? Answer a simple question here for me?

Did Jesus bear his own cross?

(a) Yes (John 19:17)

(b) No (Matthew 27:31-32)

2007-01-22 22:05:35 · answer #4 · answered by By Any Means Necessary 5 · 3 1

Muhammad got his information from Gabriel, an angel sent to him by Allah/God. Any information he received about Jesus came from Allah.

Christians may think they are the experts about Jesus, but if that were true, why are there so many denominations in Christianity, all with very different views? Even Christianity cannot agree on God, Jesus and the facts of Christianity.

2007-01-22 21:51:31 · answer #5 · answered by ♥ terry g ♥ 7 · 7 1

Well Mohamed did consult some apocryphal gospel and especially the arabic gospel of Jesus childhood where Jesus kills children who run into him - not the conventional source that Chrsitians were used to. But many of the stories of the arabic gospels make their appearnace in the quran.

He also had a coptic slave that he used to have sex with, he got information on christinaity from her too. In addition he travelled widely for a man of his day for his wife's caravan business and probably had contact with many Arab Christians. At this time, although Chrsitinaity was well establish in the reigion - there were still many divergent views on the nature of Jesus, and how Chrsitians worshipped him.

This diversity of thought is not relfected in the Quran. what does appear is the experience mohamed had for himself when he came across other Chrsitian sects. But the root of Christinaity that we recognise today, and the Christ that we recognise today was a different one, probably, than the one Mohamed experienced - very briefly experinced it must be said

2007-01-22 22:03:33 · answer #6 · answered by Anonymous · 1 3

In Islam, Jesus is seen a Messenger of God who have been sent to lead the human beings of Israel. It states that Jesus grow to be born to Mary because of the fact the effect of virginal thought, a astonishing experience which happened by skill of the decree of God. to assist him in his quest, Jesus grow to be given the skill to accomplish miracles, all by skill of the permission of God. in accordance to Islamic texts, Jesus grow to be neither killed nor crucified, yet fairly he grow to be raised alive as much as heaven.

2016-11-26 20:41:18 · answer #7 · answered by ? 4 · 0 0

The Koran, Bible(Christainity) bhagavath geetha and bhgavatham( hinduism) are similar..
First there was hinduism then came christianity and then islam..
these are philosophies and churches m,osques gurudwaras are repair centres of the world..
Islam that is koran the penguin version looks almost like the story of jesus and krishna mosques masjids are similar..
We should not fight in mbname of GOD GOD is nothing but good ness You can download god song from my website www.maheshnbiomedical.com

2007-01-22 21:50:03 · answer #8 · answered by Mahesh N 2 · 5 0

obviously the Gospel was before the Quran. God's Word can't be changed so the Quran is false. Where is the proof that the message Mohammed got is from God? Has it been prophesied in the Gospel? No. There is no real evidence.

2007-01-22 22:10:48 · answer #9 · answered by Sternchen 5 · 1 2

Gospel of John, Gospel of Luke, Gospel of Mathew, Gospel of .......,
But Qura'n from Allah only.
Prophet Muhammad never claimed holy book belong to him.
Like Jesus(pbuh), Prophet Muhammad(pbuh) said I am just a Prophet and messenger of Almighty God.
Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) and Qura'n said God Almighty revealed Injeel to Prophet Essa (Jesus, pbuh), but later people changed it as per their desire and changed even commands as well.
For example Jesus said do not use swine but later some one so called companion who never met Jesus(pbuh) when Jesus was in this world, said using pork is now allowed.
How come when Moses, and Jesus on the will of Almighty forbid some thing some disrespect God, Moses, and Jesus as well and changed command on his own.
This is Insult of Jesus, Moses, and God Almighty.
Muslims can not do this and Obey Moses, Jesus, and Muhammad because these Holy Prophet brought massage from God Almighty to us, and we should accept as it is without using our limited sick logic.

2007-01-22 22:18:41 · answer #10 · answered by Slave 3 · 2 0

uuuuu the answer of your question lies in the fact that Mohammed (pbuh) was a prophet himself and the information he got I presume your are talking about are the ones that are in the Qur'an?The Qur'an was REVEALED to him and of course God speaks about Jesus (pbuh) because he was a very important prophet, as was Moses (pbuh) and he did incredible things that were worth informing the humandkind as part of religious teaching to the believers. Jesus' (pbuh) miracles are supposed to show how powerful God is to those who want evidence that God exists so of course he was important. But in islam, Jesus (pbuh) was a human, with extra qualities since he was a prophet, but mortal nevertheless and not divine, since by definition only God is the Almighty and not a human.

Hope that helped somehow ; )

2007-01-22 21:51:14 · answer #11 · answered by Coexistence 3 · 6 1

fedest.com, questions and answers