What would you do if you found out your girl friend of 2 years use to be a man?

Question

I mean she had the surgery. you never knew. you guys was intimate and all. finally you asked her to marry you and she says this. Yes! but before we go further you need to know something. and than she pulls out a picture that looks like her brother but its really her. What would you do? more importantly remember that you fell in love with this woman too. Gals you can answer too just think of it in reverse.

Answer 1

My only issue is there should have been disclosure.

Her past usually isn't that important, but certain things are important enough they need to be disclosed. Say if they have been married. If they are involved with someone else, currently. If they transitioned from one gender to the other. These should be disclosed. To me this is an ethical issue.

Just to put this in perspective, I have dated a transgendered person. My ex-bf started out as my gf. He transitioned while we were dating (FtM) . We broke up about a year later for reasons which had nothing to do with his present or previous gender.

I do understand that transexual individuals really are in a bind. They face the dilemma of when to tell. If they tell too soon, they are likely never date anyone. If they tell too late, they risk losing someone they have fallen in love with.

I believe it's incumbent to tell prior to a sexual relationship.

Answer 2

Past history shows that these kinds of mariages happened back then too but just were never talked about. For instance two women would marry but one would remain looking like a male their entire marriage but somehow they would have several children. It all depends on how much you love this person, how committed you are, how committed they are. But remember that if they made a change in their life that they are probably still confused in the mind as you can change the body but you can't always change the mind. Figure out why this person made the change. If their insides are female and they decided just by thought to make a change rather than the real need to make a change, then this might be ok. If they can have children and are determined by a doctor to be a female and have changed their birth certificate and all and you can accept them as a person that they are not misrepresenting themself, then it should be ok if you yourself in your mind could accept this kind of arrangement. Get around her family and see what they think of the situation and what her goals were and why she changed.

You ask about a reverse answer, but that would be totally strange to have a woman change to be a man and still have a vagina. It doesn't work in the reverse.

Answer 3

Wow. What a shitty situation. No offense yet your ex female friend appears like a B****. in the experience that your in severe college, i'd propose assembly effective ladies in college. Or in the experience that your city is so small, you comprehend you arent fascinated interior the girls on your type, you would want to bypass to three of your college pastime's away video games at different neighboring severe college's to fulfill ladies there. yet to be straightforward, you would no longer want to bounce into something. 2 years is a lengthy time period and also you've purely been unmarried for 2 weeks. attempt dipping your ft into some new ponds....in case you capture my pick the flow. bypass on dates, have interesting, yet do not get wrapped up in all of us. Your pal do not have felt on your woman although, kick his asss this weekend :)

Answer 4

WOW! Did this happen to you? Man that's a toughie but here goes...

The bottom line is that she lied to you. Straight up! This is something she should have told you from the get go so that you can make up your mind about it and decide if you want to continue before you fall in love.

Honestly I don't think I could go through with it because the lie is just too great. But if you are in love with her then its your choice. Keep in mind that the two of you will never have babies. If you are OK with that then think of the next thing. Can you spend the rest of your life with someone who hid something so important?

Answer 5

I'd freak out at first, but I suppose after a while I'd figure that what the heck, I love this person, so whats the big deal? You'd have to be pretty open minded though to have that attitude.
I've been married for 25 yrs. and if I found out my husband used to be a woman I'd probably laugh my *** off!

Answer 6

I'd go on Jerry Springer so I could get paid for acting on my impulse of wanting to beat his as s to a pulp, but also, Steve would keep me from actually hurting him, which would be a good thing, since I love his female form. Afterwards, I would puke my guts out. Before and during, too.

That's sick, dude.

Answer 7

I think I would have a melt down to be honest!!! Probably wouldn't come out of my house for a few days and just think. I don't think I could stay. I believe that God doesn't make mistakes, if you were born a man you are supposed to be a man and vice verse.

Answer 8

Well, I would be a little creeped out, I mean you can't keep information like that from the person you love. If you really could care less that she was a man, then thats really cool,and if you really love her no matter what then it shouldnt really matter.

Answer 9

I think it's the nastiest thing ever. I'm sorry dude but it's a man. I don't care if she looks fine, has nice body, etc. Biologically, mentally, and deeply inside that is a MAN. I know it sux but I couldn't go through with it. How will you even have kids?! Then deeply inside of you, you'd be thinking you were gay! It's just sick & wrong. Try your best to end it & find another GIRL. If he lied to you about this & you were about to get married, who knows what he'll lie to you else about?

Answer 10

It probably wouldn't make any difference if I really loved her (him). However if children were on the itinerary, I guess perhaps I would need to look elsewhere. It would take some time to get over the dishonesty.