Using immigrants to proctect the nation.?

Question

It solves both the immigration problem and would raise the military troop levels.

Do not allow immigrants to be in the military, but allow them to work building weapons, or have access to weapons already in the country?
What's the difference?

I'm not saying immigrants have to die, just serve a certain term. It provides a Job, medical benifits, patriotism, etc. The more time they serve, the more people they can bring into the country. It gives them everything to get started.

Then again, it does make sense. Immigrants are willing to come into the nation to corrupt it, but not protect it. Then they call it slavery.

I have heard stories of immigrants joining the military and dying, then not getting citizenship. That is terrible.

The immigrants would not be at our backs. The would be in the job that we offered. They don't have to take the job. Then again, they don't have to take any job. Just the ones that they want.

I guess that is just the way I feel about it, being that I have served.

Answer 1

great idea

Answer 2

these immigrants are not the brightest lights on the street and to send them to war would be a waste. to have a war is a waste anyway. I've known people that have come to this country, become American citizens and told me that they would never fight for this country!!!. but on the other hand immigrants have fought for this country in hsitory.. the irish in the civil war...on both sides. but these people don't want nothing to do with this country.. they fly mexican flags protesting at the thought of anybody removing them from this country. note:i'm hispanic also..just to let you know.

Answer 3

And put non-Americans, Non-English speaking, Felons, into the Military ...Are you on Crack??
We can raise Tropop levels by having all the Liberal Armchair Generals and Presidents enlist. After all, they know what is best for our country and could, no doubt, solve all the problems in a 24 hour period......without any bloodshed.........
Sorry I dozed off and was dreaming

Answer 4

No,I want people that really care about America protecting it.Not someone who has no loyalty or allegiance to this nation.

Legal immigrants are Americans and many have served very bravely in our military

Worldsgreatest ...if they are so smart why don't they fix whats wrong with their own country's And stay there ??

Answer 5

Just a few percent could be on the wrong side and could destabilize an army. Bad idea unless you could put them on the front lines and aim weapons at them making sure they don't retreat. Cannon fodder

Answer 6

Bad idea. If we make it required that immigrants must join the military, that's no different than slavery.

Answer 7

You have to be a Democrat/liberal that don't know the different between a legal immigration and illegal immigration, there is a different you know. We are having a illegal immigration problem not a immigration problem,,, now you know the different.. good luck!!!

Answer 8

Isn't cleaning your yards and picking up your plates enough? Now, you want to obligate them to fight in a war.

Answer 9

Here is an article about immigrant soldiers. Nothing new.

Even though his coffin was draped with the American flag, U.S. Marine Staff Sergeant Riayan Tejeda, 26, was not a U.S.citizen. Tejeda, who was killed in combat in Iraq, was a native of the Dominican Republic.

Eight years ago he joined the Marines after graduating from George Washington High School.

“I hope the United States will remember that my son died for this country,” his father Julio Tejada told Newsday.

Tejeda’s death has brought attention to stories of immigrants who fought for the U.S. military throughout history and the current controversy over their immigration status.

For immigrants, joining the military could lead to a faster track to citizenship, which allows them and their immediate family to reap the same benefits as native-born U.S. citizens.

In early 1990s, immigrant soldiers became eligible for citizenship after three years of legal residency, two years less than civilians. More than 3,600 immigrant soldiers became U.S. citizens from 1994 to 1999.

Last July, President Bush signed an executive order that temporarily allows immigrant soldiers to apply for citizenship immediately. Nearly 5,500 military personnel applied and some already got their citizenships.

There is no law prohibiting illegal immigrants from joining in the army but the armed forces representative says anyone without proper documents is rejected, according to a report in the New York Times.

Tejeda and at least six other U.S. servicemen killed in the war in Iraq had not yet become citizens. Six of these immigrants were granted citizenship posthumously but their relatives did not receive the benefits that would normally go to the families of the citizens.

“It is an honorary status in commemoration of the valor and the sacrifices of the deceased,” the Bureau of Citizenship and Immigration Services explained in the memo.

More than 36,000 service members are non-citizens, making up about 5 percent of active duty service members. About a third come from Mexico and other Spanish-speaking countries and the rest are from China, Vietnam, Canada, Korea, India and other countries.

In New York City alone, 40 percent of Navy recruits were immigrants, 36 percent in the Marines and 27 percent in the Army.

Many are surprised by the number of non-citizens serving in the U.S. military but others say immigrants have always been a part of the military.

“Basically, both immigrants or non-citizens have served in the military since at least the Revolutionary war,” said University of Michigan Professor Cara Wong, who has been studying immigrants and war.

There were over 500,000 immigrants who fought in the Civil War. They were allowed to form their own units, elect their officers and speak their native tongues. “The Germans are true and patriotic,” said President Abraham Lincoln about the German immigrants volunteering to fight for the union army.

Some immigrant soldiers were even honored by the army for their bravery. During WWII Mexican born soldier Marcario Garcia, whose company was pinned down by the Nazis, fought his way out and, though wounded, was able to return with captured prisoners. Garcia was promoted to staff sergeant and awarded the Medal of Honor.

“The distinction between legal and illegal immigrants was non-existent until well after the Civil War,” said professor Wong.

The situation of non-citizen soldiers has caught the eyes of lawmakers in Washington D.C. Some are introducing bills that would shorten the waiting period to two years for foreign-born soldiers and others even argue for immediate citizenship for all immigrants on active duty in the armed forces.

But that did not happen soon enough for Tejeda. At his funeral, hundreds of people gathered to honor him at St. Elizabeth’s Church in Washington.

“He may never have been made officially a citizen of our nation,” said Mayor Michael Bloomberg. “But we are proud he was a citizen of New York.”

Spokesmen for Senator Charles Schumer and Representative Charles Rangel said that they are seeking citizenship posthumously for Tejada if his family desires.

Answer 10

Wake up and smell the RUM.

Answer 11

bad idea because these people are samrt enough not to fight in a war that even its own people don't want to fight in.