the idea that God punishes the entire nation?

Question

the idea that God punishes the entire nation when the collective sins of the people becomes too great. Is this unfair to individuals, or does it help to create a stronger sense of personal resposibilityh

Answer 1

He only did that once and that was Sodom and Gomorrah. They were so corrupt that only Lot and his immediate family were found to be still righteous. They were saved from the destruction. As bad as any counrty is in today's time it is still not as bad as Sodom and Gomorrah was then.

Answer 2

This idea is pretty statistically invalid.

That is, it has no basis in ... uh ... reality. It is simple justification by the
religious elite to eliminate variation and therefore reduce their control.

If you presupose the existance of God, and you accept the excited
ramblings of the religious right, then why did Katrina take out the 9th
ward of New Orleans but leave the French Quarter pretty much intact?
Aint that supposed to be where all the fun is?

If God exists, he must surely operate at a much higher level than
the mere attempt to equalize nation's borders on the basis of sin.

Answer 3

God is indeed Just and Loving. And I'll tell you why.
People are saying that it is unfair to distroy the individuals because of the whole nation. But looking at this in a logical manner, those nations who did commit sins and atrocities had to be destroyed in order to prevent their actions and habits from spreading to future generations, therefore helping the rest of the world. Is this not Just and Loving? And to kill those 'innocent' individuals was also justified for these individuals did nothing to prevent these evils from spreading. And if they had died and done their best, then they were given a generous bounty from their Lord after they died for their struggles. Isn't this Just and Loving?

Answer 4

Think of the reverse.

Lets assume that He (meaning God) holds accountable those who really should take responsibility for the good things they have. If they waste or don't take care of the wealth or the environment they have been given.

And if a whole nation can get chastised like a parent talks to his child. Then a whole nation can get rewarded. It cuts both ways.

With much power comes much responsibility. (Spiderman)

(Jesus) "Great gifts mean great responsibilities; greater gifts, greater responsibilities!" Luke 12:48

Answer 5

Perhaps we could look at it from where God sits, He is the one that must check the course of evil, sin is like a cancer at some point God must decide when to check it, and i am SURE God is able to provide for those who are true to Him, we all must die at some point but if we must do that and Live for Him we will Live WITH Him forever, find out more free bible lessons www.itiswritten.com bible questions www.bibleinfo.com God bless talk to me also [e-mail]

Answer 6

I believe your concept on the top Mover, the uncaused reason, and the thinking of think of. the 1st and 2d rules of Thermodynamics additionally help this..somewhat the regulation of Entropy. with connection with perfection/imperfection i do no longer agree. loose will and all that involves enables a introduction to adapt evil, and go through the ramifications of such. initially the introduction grow to be suitable, the thoughts made by way of reported creations replaced the completed equation. The finite and constrained strategies of guy can neither comprehend nor shop on with finite concerns and bounds to a limiteless supernatural rigidity or being. God created perfection, which by way of the introduction's determination grew to grow to be imperfect. God (7-totality of perfection), guy (6-imperfection). the completed seen the human Jesus is a metaphor for human existence. suffering turns into an quintessential element of human existence, and lends salvation at its middle. Jesus additionally allowed God to journey the pitfalls of human existence, temptation, etc., on a subjective point somewhat than from an purpose omniscient, all-powerful, omnipresent attitude. He has given us the procedures, in spite of the undeniable fact that it is as much as us to divine them. What 'imperfect' God might enable non-end skepticism, insurrection, and the upkeep of loose will; understanding to what end this might culminate in. can we as people choose the author related to concerns of introduction itself? Can a introduction by way of its very nature comprehend the inherent high quality of author? a million) God is acceptable/maximum diploma of excellence. 2) God is imperfect/defective. What constitutes perfection or imperfection..a human standard? Perfection does no longer exist contained in the finite universe, subsequently it can't be judged by way of finite creations with connection with the infinite. i like your thesis in spite of the undeniable fact that..properly concept out. (playstation human beings it is not plagiarism that's a coarse draft and he or she reported initially that plenty has been disregarded by way of volume of area..i'm particular the completed replica will cite the ideal contributors..my goodness loosen up!!).

Answer 7

For the LAST TIME, it wasn't biblically ordained. It was a state-instituted massacre at the hands of a despot from Austria and his elite followers.

Answer 8

yes, thousands of years ago the entire concept of "individualism" was non-existent. back then it was all about society, and people being collectively responsible for one another.

Answer 9

Isn't that what they do in military basic training? I don't believe this is God's practice. I believe each of us are responsible for our own actions, good and bad. No collective punishment or reward for all.

Answer 10

God will take care of Hisown. I rely on His understanding and I trust His promises. If I suffer here, He has the whole eternity to make it up to me. : )