I've been dating a girl for over a year and now she wants a breakup. What should i do?

Question

I've been dating a very beautiful girl for over a year now. Prolly the most beautiful girl i've ever dated and ever will date. Anyway, We just had our one year anniversary on the 5th and two weeks before christmas i bought her a $400.00 diamond ring from kays for christmas. It was a promise ring and i thought it would really show her how much i care for her. But i had to give it to her two weeks before christmas because she had to leave with her family to go to california to visit her whole family and she came back on the 7th of janurary and sent me a e-mail saying she wants to break up because "Theres no connection anymore". So i told her i would have to get the ring back because i'm still paying for it and she said that shes lost it. I'm not that worried about the ring i'm mostly wanting her back because i really do love her. What should i do?

Answer 1

Ask her what made her feel like you two were suddenly not compatible anymore so you can find the real reason for her saying that.

Be prepared, though, the truth is likely to hurt you beyond a doubt.

Answer 2

Well sweetie, there's a good thing and bad thing about love, in my opinion love is always reciprocated, if it's not than it's not love. That's just my opinion. Just like God doesn't make him love us, you can't make someone have feelings for you that aren't there. She says the connection is not there, than it's not. If you truly care for her than you should want her to be happy. She's not happy with you. She knows how you feel, especially if you tell her all the time. She just doesn't care. The only thing you can do now, is get the ring back. Not to be mean or anything, but the thing is, it's a promise ring and if she is no longer promising herself to you than she needs to give the ring back. She hasn't lost it. People just don't lose $400.00 rings, that just doesn't happen. Why continue to pay off something that is wasting away on the wrong woman? No. Be polite but be assertive. She seems pretty selfish and totally undeserving of you to do something like that anyway. To want to keep the ring but rid herself of you. A year in a loveless relationship is a total waste of time.Like any considerate human, you'll develop feelings for this person. Sometimes it's not love. Just friendship, maybe not even that. My boyfriend now(future husband) was with his last girlfriend for three years, but they didn't love each other. They don't even like each other. It's pretty funny.We haven't even been together a quarter of that and we know that we're IT for each other. When it's the One you know. The connection will always be there because your souls will be attactched. She'll accept the good and the bad, and you'll accept hers. She'll be deserving of you. She'll love you. It hurts now, and it's going to take time to get over someone who you have been with for so long. But think of it as her doing you a favor, she's moving aside and making room for you to find the right woman. Once you really think about it, I'm sure she wasn't quite everything you wanted in your mate. You probably made a lot of allowances for her, because you did think she was beautiful or the one. The One for you will be everything you need, they won't be perfect. But they will be what you need. Good luck babe! I hope this helped, if you ever need to talk I'm here.

Answer 3

Dude your not going to believe this man i had the same thing about 3-4 months ago. I dated this gal for about a year and nine months an shes beautiful too i gave her a Whitegold Diamond Necklace for the 1 year anni and guess what, the following month she goes to England and come back and says she wants to break up and she did for a month but my regular caring and loving phonecalls made her get back till it was like the 1 year 9th month then she said that she found someone else man. I dont get it cos its so hard for me to cope up too. What is it with Gold and Diamonds? Man im also very very sad cos i loved her a lottt.. Now im single and tormented. The situation get worse when they give pathetic excuses. My advice is that if they want to breakup once that means they are not happy with you and even if you get them back they wont last long. I felt like the most unfortunate guy in the world and now you,,Welcome to the club. Take my advice. Let her go along with the Ring, i also let go the Necklace and iPod i gave her, at least she will see it and remember us. Dont bother getting them back cos they will only go again and confuse you even more.

Answer 4

First, she didn't lose your ring. She's just greedy and she wants to keep it. Second, for her to say there is no "connection" after you gave her a ring (very romantic gesture) is B.S. She is a b*tch, beautiful or not. That woman chewed you up and spit you out and now she is on to her next victim. Stay away from her! Don't let her further humiliate you or take further advantage of your feelings. You WILL get over your love for her and find a better woman. I PROMISE. Move on. Good Luck!

Answer 5

Well, I understand why she broke up with you because of the connection thing, but the thing about the ring..........that's a flat out lie!! She probably sold it or something. Maybe you'll just have to learn from your mistake this time. An expensive mistake, but maybe that's what it will take. Sorry!!

Answer 6

I don't think she lost the ring. She may have met someone while she was away or maybe she does feel disconnected where you are concerned. It's a shame, but if that is what it is, then it's over. It doesn't necessarily mean that it's your fault. Good luck.

Answer 7

To be elementary, i don't have a difficulty with it individually as long as he's emotionally mature adequate to be in a courting. i individually will possibly in no way date a woman that replaced into sixteen, using fact for me it style of feels icky yet thats probable societal norms. i think of that's greater ideal on the grounds which you're woman. although I think of your acquaintances/ kinfolk does no longer be accepting in any respect, if my close chum began courting/ residing with a minor i may be very indignant. i'm no longer attempting to be an *** in basic terms elementary. Im interior the states, i dont understand the guidelines up in CA yet that courting may be unlawful and you'd be a statutory rapist interior the eyes of our us of a. i think of i'm changing my innovations as i'm scripting this, you're too previous for him, its probable an exceedingly mushy courting using fact he desires you and is probable very affectionate. you're relatively obtainable filling a mom roll in his eyes (i make lunch for him), and this may be risky for the two one in each and every of you. Its complicated on the grounds which you reside with him now yet i think of you're walking down a highway that doesnt lead everywhere. Yeah, for my area undesirable theory i think of you could bail, it relatively is probable the toughest factor to do yet this cant be stable. stable good fortune i wish you nicely sounds like a bad difficulty.

Answer 8

Get over her and learn a lesson from the experience ... don't ever buy a girl you don't really know that well (you obviously didn't know this girl) such an expensive gift.

Remember, girls are like buses, if you miss one, wait 10 minutes and another one will come by.

Answer 9

I'm so sure she lost the ring. It sounds like she doesn't want to be with you anymore, but still wants the ring... thats pretty shitty of her. idk what to tell you, because I know what it feels like to love somebody, and I can't imagine how hard it'd be to let it go. Tell her how you feel, send her flowers & little notes telling her how much you miss her & love her... good luck.

Answer 10

Let her go man and don't be giving diamonds away like you did. Now go pay the bill we all make mistakes.