if no one (expect jesus) can live life without sin, where is the free will in the situation?

Question

if we are predestined to commit sin from the start, that what does that say about our free will? god puts us on this earth, CREATING us as people who necessarily sin, by nature, and we are indebt to him because of our uncleanlines, our imperfection?

Answer 1

because in God's eyes everything we do is a vile sin. Picking up a pencil and writing a letter to a friend is a sin. I don't have time on these boards to go into it further, but everything you do is sinful. Your only good deeds are deeds you don't know about. At least, thats what Martin Luther says.

Answer 2

We are not predestined to commit sin from the start -- that would make God the author of evil, which is unscriptural. I believe this is called hyper-Calvinism or double predestination.

However, you're close. Free will is complete freedom in our decisions to literally go to Hell in whatever fashion we want. None of us is worthy of Heaven. What God can do is choose His own, and in so doing, He can do this from before the foundations of the world, and this is reflected in the Bible through Predestination. So you're right, no free will in the sense of being able to look to God for salvation, plenty of free will for the ways of the world though.

Answer 3

Not everyone believes man is predestined to sin. Those are the people who believe all men are inherently bad. Many people believe man is inherently good.

What may be a little bit more correct is that man is inherently selfish. Many times given the opportunity, the choice a human would save them self before another. However there are some that rise above them selves to consider the good of humanity, not just themselves. So any way i can't see where you cam up with the assumption that we are predestined to commit sin.

Tendencies towards good and bad i believe are developed/nurtured based on our upbringing, and further developed by our choices of what we considered to be good and bad, integrity, and honor.

Nothing worth anything really comes free with out a price. It really comes down to the level of laziness each individual posses.

Answer 4

You are not predestned to sin but you do have a sin nature because you know right from wrong. Romans 2: 14 For when the Gentiles, which have not the law, do by nature the things contained in the law, these, having not the law, are a law unto themselves: Romans 5: 12 Wherefore, as by one man sin entered into the world, and death by sin; and so death passed upon all men, for that all have sinned: Because you are a sinner you need somebody to pay for your sins. You have free will to believe or not to believe that the Lord Jesus Christ died for your sins. 1 Corinthians 15: 3 For I delivered unto you first of all that which I also received, how that Christ died for our sins according to the scriptures; 1 Corinthians 15: 4 And that he was buried, and that he rose again the third day according to the scriptures: Romans 10: 13 For whosoever shall call upon the name of the Lord shall be saved.

Answer 5

No you make a choice to sin. That's where the freewill comes in at. We were created to sin, we were created to live in the garden with God, but because He gave us a freewill, well you know what Adam did. He brought on sin after that. Now that's where Jesus comes in at, He came so that you can have life. So when you accept Him, His blood shields you from sin. So even though you may sin, you covered and your sins are atoned for. So God sent you a way out of sin, not trying to keep you in it.

Answer 6

Yes you are right we are all enslaved to sin although none of us and none of the angels were ever created in that way, and we were never predestined to sinn that was never God's plan! we are sinners because using their free will, Adam and Eve sinned before they had any children, and they therefore, passed sin on to all their offspring including all of us alive today!
because of our free will, GOD does permit wickedness, and millions on earth willfully make a practice of it. For instance, they declare wars, drop bombs on children, scorch the earth, and cause famines. Millions smoke and get lung cancer, practice adultery and get sexually transmitted diseases, use alcohol to excess and get cirrhosis of the liver, and so on. Such people do not truly want all wickedness stopped. They only want the penalties for it eliminated. When they reap what they have sown, they cry out, "Why me?" And they blame God, as Proverbs 19:3 says: "A man's own folly wrecks his life, and then he bears a grudge against the LORD." (The New English Bible) And if God stopped their evildoing, they would protest their loss of freedom to do it!

Answer 7

unique sin does not circulate lower back to caveman days. It is going lower back to the priesthood. we are advised by the clergymen that mankind delivered unique sin down upon us, and God replace into purely not all-powerful sufficient to take it away lower back. So this creates an excellent guilt complicated interior the believers. yet wait, say the clergymen, there is wish. because of the fact Jesus replace into killed (can absolutely everyone say human blood sacrifice?) for you in case you think you would be saved. excitement for the believers and much extra guilt for people who question the dogma. (not purely are they a sinner, yet they're rejecting the discomfort and suffering that Jesus went in spite of the undeniable fact that.) And while they swallow this delusion the clergymen have them hooked for existence. Rational human beings will ask your self purely how all-powerful and loving God is that if he's compelled to push sin onto mankind, and then the only way he can shop them is to have his son come down in human sort and be brutally killed. Is that truly the terrific concept that an all-powerful, omnicognizant, all loving deity might desire to arise with? It jogs my memory of the Woody Allen quote: If it appears that evidently there is a God, i don't think of that he's evil. however the worst which you will say approximately him is that unquestionably he's an underachiever. human beings have better to be sympathetic to those who they know. this might properly be a survival trait for societies. Anarchistic societies have died out because of the fact the cooperative societies have better speedier and extra advantageous and supplanted them. Ethics and morality are memes, those evolve in societies interior an analogous way that genes evolve in bodies. This has been happening because of the fact earlier human beings existed. To characteristic such habit to your very own deity is insulting to the humanity of the guy and denying the fact of thousands and thousands of years of the evolution of societies.

Answer 8

The free will is in choosing whether we intentionally sin with indifference to God. Or whether we confess to God our sin and be cleansed from it. We either accept sin as a way of life. Or we accept sin as a fact of life. We all sin and fall short of the glory of God. The difference is, what are we doing about it.
Do we accept Gods free gift of salvation? Or are we too busy to care one way or the other. Indifference to God is sin.
Either accept His gift, or reject His gift. It is a decision we all have to make. Great question...God Bless You....Peace.

Answer 9

Think of just today, did you do anything YOU wanted to do, even if it was just eating something, or shopping..you chose..and it wasn't done for you. that is one way.. As for God, you can choose to believe in him, or not. IF there is a god, he could indeed force you to choose him, but IF he exists, he obviously does not force us. In that, lies free will. In other words, god will not force you to go to heaven, or live the life you were meant to really live with him forever, if you don't want to. The offer is there, but he makes no one take it. Kind of like when you propose to your wife, if you are male and in love, what if she HAD to say yes?? Well, that would not be cool. If your kids HAD to love you, not cool...it is special because both sides choose it.

Answer 10

Yep. Would you prefer to live like a caged animal instead? Be thankful for Free Will. And also be thankful of a God that forgives.