Non Old Firm 11?

Question

after seeing the old firm 11 question, i think it would be interesting to see what people put for this. Maximum of 4 players from any team, but i won't force you to pick 1 from every club.

Outwardlycombustible :I hadn't thought of whittaker in midfeild, but he has been performing well for hibs there recently. I share the concerns over Jones though. but with gow and naismith up front, i think your strikeforce lacks a bit of physical presence.

Superduperoxide, i rate benjelloun highly front,he's got a bit of pace, power and no small amount of skill, but

i think heartly is best throughthe middle. Dods is a decent player, but i don't think he's the complete article. Conway is a good prospect, but he can be a bit overadventurous with his runs, and needs to develop his defensive skills.

dicko, i think fowler would do well in that anchor role, and i'm a bit surprised you're the only one with killen in his team, but i've yet to be convinced on hay, and foran's only contributions lately have been scoring penalties.

Some good answers, all with good & bad points. I can't decide which i like best, so its going to a vote!

Answer 1

GK- Gordon(Heats)
RB- Whittaker(Hibs)
CB- Anderson(Ab'd)
CB -Dods(I.C.T)
LB-Conway (Dun utd)
RM-Hartley(Hearts)
CM- Brown (Hibs)
CM-Severin(Ab'd)
LM-Gow(Fal)
ST-Benjelloun(Hibs)
ST-Velicka (Hearts)

Answer 2

Good Question. Right, here goes

1) Craig Gordon-Hearts
2) Steven Whittaker-Hibs
3) Garry Hay-Kilmarnock
4) Martyn Corrigan-Motherwell
5) Russell Anderson-Aberdeen
6) Richie Foran-Motherwell
7)James Fowler-Kilmarnock
8) Paul Hartley-Hearts
9) Chris Killen-Hibs
10) Guillaume Beuzelin-Hibs
11) Alan Gow-Falkirk

Playing in a 4-4-2 formation with Fowler as the holding midfielder. It was a toss up between Gow and Scott MacDonald of Motherwell for the final place, but the ability Gow has to operate from wide positions just swayed me to plump for him!!!

PS-This team would horse the Old-Firm select!!

Answer 3

definite, indisputably. it would supply the winners of the leauge champions league qualifiers, which exchange into the place the previous company surprisingly plenty had to start, it would additionally make the leagues greater aggressive for this reason greater crowds might pass to the video games. additionally, youd get the honour hunters who couldnt be stricken vacationing right down to England each 2nd week to observe an away interest, and those that dont relatively helps the previous company, wouldnt pay the stupid costs of season tickets etc by way of fact the fees might shoot up Partick Thistle may be the gang in Scotland that could earnings greater by way of fact the tickets may be greater good to get on matchdays for the previous company so theyd little doubt come to a determination to visit firhill, and little ones might pass to observe the Jags as theyd have no possibility to get into Parkhead or Ibrox, for this reason producing greater gate takings and supporters. all in all i think of it would be a sturdy element, previous company could pass down and plague England with thier squabbles whilst Scottish soccer might have interest in it returned

Answer 4

Gk - Gordon (Hearts)
RB- Neilson (Hearts)
CB- Jones, Anderson (Hibs,Aberdeen)
LB- Murphy (Hibs)
RM- Whittaker (Hibs)
CM- Hartley, Brown (Hearts,Hibs)
LM -Robson (Dundee Utd)
ST- Gow,Naismith (Falkirk, Kilmarnock)

Answer 5

Cant argue with outwardly... cept maybe rob jones, but i cant think of anyone else to replace him. Scott Severin at centre half?

Answer 6

Any players not playing for Rangers are obviously not even worth considering.

Answer 7

sorry dont know any non old firm players names