Can you make a citizens arrest on an illegal alien?

Question

If you know for a FACT they are illegal...can you?

Answer 1

No because the punishment for being illegaly in a country is NOT imprisonment, it is deportation.

Answer 2

1

Answer 3

NO you can't. The only thing you can do is to report the person you allege is an 'illegal alien', given that you have sufficient concrete evidence to back up your claim to authorities. Besides, let the people who deal with arresting illegal immigrants and deporting them do that job. That's what they're paid for. If you don't have concrete evidence to back up your claim, then you could be charged with making a false arrest.

Answer 4

it is comical actual. State regulations with regards to who could make arrests while and for what varies, and that i'm unsure what federal regulation says on it (immigration violations are federal violations, not state). i know in Texas a man or woman must be committing a criminal. it is #a million. because of the fact unlawful presence isn't a criminal, that doesn't be a project the place a citizen could make an arrest i don't think of. And a man or woman can not assume the immigrant entered illegally because of the fact some human beings overstay visas. besides, notwithstanding if we assumed everybody entered illegally, a federal criminal, we gained't circulate arresting human beings for felonies that are actually not in progression. Off-accountability cops very almost on no account mess with that, so why might desire to voters? right here is the different concern. there is not any requirement for any unlawful alien, or somebody for that count number, to discover themselves to a different man or woman in circumstances the place somebody is finding to make a citizen's arrest. if certainty be told, in many situations a police officer won't be able to stroll as much as somebody and demand identity. besides, interior reach and state police won't be able to enforce immigration regulations. So how can a private citizen ensure somebody is against the regulation with a view to arrest them? ultimately, making citizen's arrests might properly be packed with criminal accountability. If somebody fights the arrest, after which you utilize severe tension, your over. YOU circulate to detention center. some might combat because of the fact they don't know who you're. If somebody is composed of me attempting to make a citizen's arrest for no sturdy reason, they might have a severe project. human beings don't understand criminal accountability, and the function it performs, while they circulate and attempt to detain somebody. in case you screw it up, purely slightly, you may properly be charged with a criminal.

Answer 5

You should be able to, but the answer is no, you cannot. Being in this country illegally is a civil infraction, not a criminal infraction. It would be like detaining someone for parking with an expired meter. You can't do it. If it were a criminal infraction, you could. But then again, the feds would probably just let them go anyway, because this country has lost its mind.

Answer 6

It's reached a point now you cannot even question them at the border with such quotes as what makes you think someone is illegal just because at their at the border and fleeing into Mexico. No illegal aliens and their drugs are gonna be the death of this country

Answer 7

A person can make a citizens arrest on _anyone_. The biggest immediate problem would be your ability to enforce the arrest.
Next would be the legality of that arrest. If your 'perp' were not actually in violation of some law which required apprehension, then you could be sued for unlawful arrest.

Answer 8

Yes. But most states do not let you take anyone into custody when effecting the arrest. So touching or in any means detaining that person can lead to civil and criminal penalties be leveled against you.

The best bet is to document the event and swear out a complaint with the police.

Answer 9

I wish! I once had a neighbor who was an illegal in AZ. She had locked her keys in the van.The police show up. I told them she is an illegal, they act like they don't care and they go back to speaking Spanish.

When day that comes that American citizen can around them up, I'll be cheering with the American flag

Answer 10

I wouldn't do it.....because the way things are so political right now....then just may let them out of jail...and they'll come right back and take it out on you. Better to leave that to the Immigration Authorities.