Soldiers v Prisoners?

Question

Why do people always compare soldiers with prisoners when giving out about the poor conditions in the army ?

My brother in the army does this all the time because I've been in jail but jail/prison is a permanent place where this is not the case with the army. People chose to join the army knowing what to expect but people in jail aren't there by choice.

Answer 1

People in jail CHOOSE to break the law.
Let me tell you something:
people in jail get more free phonecalls than soldiers - furthermore - most soldiers don't even have the time to use these minutes.
Also, my hubby is a soldier & I cannot have a reduction to single persons council tax when he is out of the country for 6 months - however if he were in jail, a student or jobless then I could.

WHEN PEOPLE LIKE MY HUSBAND STOP CHOOSING TO JOIN THE ARMY VOLUNTARILY BECAUSE THEY HAVE TO PUT UP WITH SO MUCH SH IT - PEOPLE LIKE YOU WILL BE FORCED TO JOIN WHEN YOU LEAVE SCHOOL LIKE IN MANY OTHER EUROPEAN COUNTRIES.

by the sounds of it 2 years in the army would have done you good

Answer 2

The issue is both categories of people are where they are by choice. The prisoner because of the activities they have pursued and the soldier because of the activities he wants to pursue.

The only difference is that the accommodation and facilities for someone in prison is provided by the state to make them comfortable.

A soldier has to pay for the items he needs to make his accommodation into an acceptable habitat in which to live.

Answer 3

Blimey - It's nutters day out !!! True enough the Armed Forces has floated schemes to take on young offenders and give them a bit of discipline - and a career option.

BUT -other than having to seek permission do do this or that, and have other controls over your daily routine- The Mind set of your average villan/thug/petty criminal/childmolester are light years behind that of the gutsy lads and lasses who put their necks on the block every day to help prevent a bunch of madmen running loose on the streets all over the world. That might be a bit jingoistic for you but whatever the shortfalls of the ability of politicians - without their presence at the coalface it would be easier for some of these madmen bent on destruction to run amock, and to compare these efforts to people banged up for criminal actions is to my mind a little obscene.

Perhaps there's something there you should give some thought to.............

Answer 4

They are both places where you have a commitment to stay, voluntarily or not. Both unusually stressful occasionally violent environments where 'doing your own thing' is highly restricted and both environments where politicians decide to a significant extent, the conditions and resources available. Not your local in other words. You could almost include hospital patients. We imagine we have a hand in their fate as voters so it gets people interested.
I agree that they are different in the way that people don't chose to be in prisons in the same way as they do in the army.

Answer 5

yes people in jail are there by choice they chose to do a crime,which is stupid,now the army is just like that,only your warned by the police not to steal and commit a crime, but the army is on t.v. telling you how cool the job is, but they lie!!!!!! but its not like you can quit or you go to jail so in some form they both are all prisoners

Answer 6

Been in the Marines, son in the Marines, active with VFW, American Legion, Mareine Corps League, VietNam Veterans of America.....Never heard your comparison....Maybe these"people" that use this comparison ie realy just you and your brother.

People DO CHOOSE to go to jail....you did a crime...Ya gotta do the time

Answer 7

that is faith and spirituality how? you should do more effective perfect for info than Youtube. Thats in basic terms anecdotal info, calling on different anecdotal info as backup. convinced Abu Gharib became a detestable abuse of rights which became uncovered and clamped down on. you should finish that a lot more effective perfect than this to convince us more effective is going on edit> on the least, locate a serious information community. no longer whoever those amateurs are. I artwork in television, and interior the previous have worked in stay information. i understand finished properly how media bias works - and those clips reek of it. eg. At one factor the VO talks of undesirable thoughts of rape among woman prisoners, then is going on to interview an ex-prisoner who says no longer something about it, and larger concentrates on her no longer having the flexibility to preserve her childrens. yet we are meant to link her sob tale to the tale of rape. regularly occurring by technique of the e book bias component. 2d Edit> Your cases link is more effective perfect, although that is nonetheless in common words speaking about Abu Gharib. That became 6 years in the past and there became no rape recorded. you should locate something some distance more effective up to this point and far attaining to interrupt open the sh!t hurricane your tale might want to generate if it were real. believe me, if it were real, then it desires to be uncovered... I do in basic terms not imagine that is.

Answer 8

soldiers always ***** "this is the worst unit", "i cant wait to get outta here", "this chain of command hates the soldiers" blah blah blah on and on. and for good reason they do treat soldiers like crap.

we had to pack our connexs before deployment, we ended up packing them and repacking them something like 20 times in a week. beacuse higher higher decided it didnt look right or it wasnt properly done.

though we have never compaired ourselves with inmates, we do get the short end of the stick.

Answer 9

Surely being in jail is by choice somehow??!! You made the choice to do the crime so it is by choice in the end! Actually going to jail is not the choice, but doing the crime is.

Answer 10

I've was involved with the military for several years and never heard this comparison

but the title question "Soldiers v Prisoners"?

The soldiers would win everytime, much fitter, work as a team and they have much better weapons!