You all know the one about the tree falling, my question is a bit different...?

Question

If God speaks and no one hears him, is there a God?

The problem of God is that he couldn't seem to talk without people talking for him. Look around you. Is there a burning bush anywhere? Any evidence that isn't hearsay?

To the last ent wife: May I just say that I LOVE tolkien too. :-)

The "look at nature" arguments pretty week. People might not even think of God unless they have heard of that notion before. If I have that feeling and I've never heard of Christianity, I might just become a druid.

Same thing with the babies. I've had 2. And the principle is the same. Its not something that would lead to a God conclusion.

Answer 1

Oh ye of little faith!

Answer 2

just think of god as the power thats controlin us n the universe. u'll have 2 believe there is a power out there. or else none of this wud ever exist. my definition of god is the things that none of us can control or do. like the growin of a tree, the changin tide, the blowin wind etc. all of these r examples of god. how does the universe work in such harmony? by the controlin power wich we call god.
u have Qs? u think gods not answerin? get up early tomo n take a walk in the park or go up 2 ur terrace, lie down n look up at the stars or the lightenin sky. clear ur mind, dont think of anythin, just enjoy the beauty of nature. u'll get ur ans for ur pressin Qs.
just try it a few times. i bet u it will work.

Answer 3

Just look at the way your body works. Take something like ...oh, lets say....your brain. How do you think all the thousands of things that go on in your brain make the rest of your body work? When you get finished with all of that, think of how you have the ability to think. How do you attract things to you in your life? Do you think it is by accident? When you get finished with that, think about the earth. How can all of the things that grow here and are provided for us on this planet, can for the most part be a natural plant remedy to heal us...or at least be processed to heal us for so many ailments. Think of how powerful prayer is. And by the way have you ever gone outside after a rain and smelled the air? Look at the clouds and the black sky at night with all the planets and stars. Then one day....when you have your first child, you look into that babies eyes and look at how tiny he is and how very much you love that baby and then you tell me if you don't believe in God.....God bless and you will find your way.

Answer 4

Doesn't the tree make a sound even though there might not be anyone to hear it? Belief in God demands an act of FAITH. To
paraphrase scripture; faith is the ability to believe in something when there is no proof. Credo quia impossible.

Answer 5

Which god are you asking about? There are tens of thousands of gods. Some of them do talk. The god of the Moonies, is a living breathing god ... If he speaks and no one hears him, he is still a god.

Answer 6

the only "evidence" is preached from a book that has more lies and contradictions than a highschool algebra student who never does his homework lol

in all seriousnous, no, there isnt any evidence

you might get an answer like.......the wind blows, can you see it?
because somehow this relates to god........yes the wind blows, and we KNOW it exists because of 1000's of years of erosion, you can see the effects of wind, i have never seen the effects of god........sorry

Answer 7

He is a / the God to all who hear Him.
I guess that goes to mean some hear His voice and some may not.
There are many ways to hear His voice. I would think it is all about choice.

Answer 8

As much evidence there is that you have a mind of your own!

Answer 9

yes, u can speak to your father who is in the middle of the sea and couldn't hear u,does it mean that he doesn't exist?

Answer 10

that there is a god, that's for sure. That he is too shy to talk directly to us? that's debatable

Answer 11

There is only one reality.