If Judas had been killed before he tried to betray Jesus, would someone else had done it?

Question

If Judas had said, "No!" to the religious leaders, would they have found someone else to betray Jesus ? After all, they had some people who lied for them when they tried Jesus. The religious leaders knew and reconized Jesus. They didn't need someone to point Him out! In any event, the "plan" would have been carried out!
Wouldn't you agree? Try to think outside the Bible on this!

Answer 1

It was predicicted that Jesus would betrayed by a friend. So yes, they would have found some one else. But let's not forget John tells us that satan entered into Judas, so he had help with his dissision.

Answer 2

The leaders didn't seek Judas out: he went to them with his evil plan. There were a few moments in the Gospels when Jesus could have been seized, but the time was not ripe and so those who would have done so were prevented by God from doing so. I don't think that they required anybody to point Him out: Jesus made the point that there had been many opportunities which they had missed in broad daylight and so it was ironic that they should go to so much trouble to seek Him out by night. This was the week of the Passover: Jesus would have gone to the temple each day and it was a question of keeping a look out, drawing Him aside on some pretext or other and then pouncing on Him with the temple guard.

The big question is: could Judas have withdrawn from his plan? What would have been the consequences for him had he done so?

Answer 3

Alot of Christians seem to have a trouble with the "what ifs" in the bible or life. In fact most of the world does. Jesus doesn't ask you to accept him on whim, in fact he challenges you seek him and find the truth. It's not about "what if" Judas hadn't betrayed Jesus, it's about accepting that what has happened was meant to happen, and since God is the almighty and he created us, he's not surprised by anything we do. God already knew Judas was going to betray Jesus, in fact God probably put Judas in Jesus's life for that SPECIFIC purpose. Seems horrid doesn't it? But God did it for the salvation of man.

Answer 4

Jesus had to die for our sins, but the type of death and the role of the Jewish leaders and Judas in that death did not have to be as it occurred, however, any differences would have been seen by God from the beginning and all of the prophecies in the Bible concerning Christ's death would have been different if Judas did not betray Christ.

Foreknowledge is not the same as predestination. God has foreknowledge, but gives mankind the power of choice hence God does not pre determine any persons ultimate destiny.

Answer 5

Judas was an important part of the plan. Jesus had already said to his disciples that the one to betray him was amongst them even at that time and that he would betray Him with a kiss. Judas at that time could not be stopped from doing his duty even by an assassin. The deed was already in prophesy and could not be altered in any way.

Answer 6

I would rather try to think inside the Scriptures. The Messiah came to live, to testify, and to die a perfect sacrifice at the exact time foretold. Matt. 26:24 "Indeed, the Son of Adam goes as it has been written concerning Him, but woe to that man by whom the Son of Adam is delivered up! It would have been good for that man if he had not been born." Since the Messiah loved Judas, and would not have wished him lost, He would have rather that Judas repented. If that had happened, we can be reasonably certain that one of the Pharisees would have said, hey, we can find this dude, lets go. (because He was scheduled to die as the Passover lamb was being killed)

Answer 7

If was for God's Glory that He told before Judas sold Jesus, it was told in the bible long before he would do that, even that act of the 30 pieces of silver was fortold in Zech 11:12,13. God knowing did not mean Judas had to do it but those events was very well written in scripture and Jesus being fully God knew full well what He was getting into and went anyway JUST FOR YOU, scripture was fullfilled and the God of The Bible did all that JUST FOR YOU, learn more free bible lessons www.itiswritten.com bible questions www.bibleinfo.com talk to me also [e-mail] God bless

Answer 8

Okay people, Jesus's life could not have been completely pre-destined, as God had already given people free will. DUH.

To answer your question, yes, they would have found someone else. I think Judas was misunderstood. The EMO kid of his time, so to speak.

Answer 9

Rabbinical components checklist that 40 years purely before the destruction of the Temple in A.D. 70, the Romans forbade the Jewish government to manage the loss of life penalty. this suggests this precise replaced into taken away around A.D. 30, almost immediately till now the Crucifixion. the reason the Sanhedrin (the Jewish governing physique that sentenced Jesus to loss of life) sought the Romans' sanction, while the mobs that attempted to stone Jesus did no longer, is that the Sanhedrin replaced right into a suitable courtroom, located in Jerusalem; they could have been identifiable and answerable under Roman regulation. The mobs, on the different hand, have been nameless communities attempting to dispense vigilante justice. Lynch mobs do no longer word the criminal standards of administering the loss of life penalty. in the event that they did, they does no longer be lynch mobs.

Answer 10

The point is, criminals rarely escape prosecution throughout history. So the authorities would have captured Jesus in some way or another.