Which is better PitBull Terrier or Rottweiller as pet ?

Question

Which is better PitBull Terrier or Rottweiler as pet ? I wonder which breed should I choose ? PitBull Terrier or Rottweiller ?

Answer 1

Rott! You don't need a show-quality dog for a pet, so check with reputable breeders - they my have a good one for you. I got one many years ago that had some (minor) cosmetic defects that disqualified her for top show and for breeding. I got her with the agreement to have her spayed, which I did. She was the most awesome dog I ever had, and we had many different dogs when I was young. Raised with love, they make incredibly good companions.

Answer 2

Unfortunatley the media has a problem with reporting only attacks by these 2 breeds. It's really ashame. They have the least amount of bite reports of any breeds, but when one bites it is usually severe so the media plays it up. When it isn't one of those 2 breeds they don't even give a breed. Remember the lady with the first face transplant? Her dog bite her face off. It was a Lab.
I have owned several Rotties and until he died of cancer my daughter and gdaughter had the sweetest Pit own them.
If you find some old books on dog breeds you will find BOTH breeds listed under excellent with children. Labs, shepherds and goldens were listed just under good with children.
It is NOT the breeds! These breeds became popular with people who saw dollar signs. They have been bred by back yard breeders, pupy mills and anyone who wants to make a buck. Thats the first problem. You have to go to a reputable breeder and learn the lines and temperments of the dogs in those lines. The second problem? Training. You can not own either breed if you are not going to spend the time or money to train it. This is another reason they have a bad rap. Don't put a breed on a hit list and make it look like a killing machine because you want a big bad dog. Third problem? Socializing. When you own one of these breeds you have to socialize, socialize, socialize. And when you're done with that.......socialize some more. If you can't deal with the responsibility, stay away from the breeds. Some of us have loved them and been loved by them too long to watch them being become endangered.

Answer 3

First make sure the local law allows you to own a PitBull, then wonder why so many places do not allow Pit Bulls within their jurisdictions.

Consider both breeds as dangerous as a loaded 45, but add the fact that Pit Bulls have unpredictable hair triggers. One Pit may be a great pit all his life. The next may break thru your fence and eat the next door neighbor's newborn son. A good Rott from a good breeder should be a much more predictable and controllable animal.

I personally prefer German Shepherds. Smarter and more laid back, they are still all business when you want them to be -- and they will guard the family children unto the death rather than causing death.

Good luck.

Answer 4

I would not have either of those breeds. Many people are afraid of them. That fear from a stranger can make even a gentle dog aggressive. Big, tough dogs like these two breeds are too common now which means breeders aren't being careful, they're out to cash in on the popularity of the breed.

It's like when there is a new 101 Dalmatians movie. The shelters become full everywhere of Dalmatians. The Dalmatian puppies come from puppy mills and have all sorts of inherited problems.

I would always prefer to save the life of some deserving dog at the shelter, a nice mixed breed, and have a dog that appreciates me as much as I love my dogs. Also, a dog that is likely to live a long, healthy life. Dogs don't live long compared to people and it nearly kills me to lose one.

I have nothing against pit bulls or rotties, but I do hate the greedy people who don't think about improving a breed and just want money. I love all dogs.

Answer 5

In trying to decide whether to own a pit bull or rottweiler you have to look at what you want or expect from your pet. Both breeds can be a great companion and family pet, or both can be aggressive, that all depends on the owner. Both breeds are dominate and take a firm but not abusive hand in training. I wouldn't suggest either for someone who has little patience or time to spend with the dog. Having been around both breeds and dobermans all my life I cannot say which breed is the best because it all depends on the owner and environment. The best advice I can give to research both breeds on web sites like the AKC's, talk to vets, and talk to serious breeders, not backyard breeders, you can find breeder contact info on AKC's web site. All these sources should be able to help you make the best decision on your choice of dog breed.

Answer 6

While I am in favor of Rotweillers as pets, I think that considering a pet is a personal choice between you and the dog you choose to adopt. For example you may think that you want breed A or breed B, but in reality, when you go to select your new pet from the County Animal Shelter or The Humane Society, you may find that you are in fact interested in a specific dog that is not either one of those breeds, but in fact is breed C or better yet, it is a mix.

When you consider that while popular, breeds like Rotties and Pitties are really good dogs in their own right, getting a mix has distinct advantages, namely health and attitude.

Pure breeds of any type are going to inherently have more problems than their mix breed counter parts. Issues such as hip dysplasia and any number of other congenital or genetic disorders, as well as the potential for distinct personality traits that you wouldn't otherwise see in mix breeds.

So, to answer your question, between those two breeds, and while I am a fan of both of those breeds and many more, I'm a sucker for the Rotties... but do yourself a favor, don't limit yourself to just a specific breed, find a dog that you like, and go with that dog for it's personality, not for the "brand name".

And if you can at all, get a mix breed, it will save you a lot of frustrations and visits to the vet.

Answer 7

I can only tell you from experience that rotts are pretty good dogs. I have owned 3 and they where all pretty laid back. they would let me know if anyone was around and i didn't have to train them as a guard dog. I don't know too much about pits i would say there are like any other breeds that have good ones and bad ones. I would say do tons of research on both breeds and talk to lots of breeders. If you get one from a good breeder your chances of getting a stable dog are better, not to say that getting one from a rescue is not good. You can get good dogs that are rescues that want to be loved. I would just say make sure which ever breed you decide on that you have all the facts.

Answer 8

What is your purpose Daniel Son? One might ask...study the history of the breed and see if that is what you want to represent. If you only want a big dog with a bad azz image, then get either, heck one of both! Unfortunately it is this attitude that puts Rotties and Pits on The Breed Specific Legislation.
Please educate yourself. Think size, food, vet care, activity level, committment! It all requires time and money!
I was raised with Rotts, love them to death but I fear the health issues. Pits get a bad rap no matter what, and can be very dog aggressive. So know what your committment is before you pick . Who knows maybe you will be happier with a pomeranian! LOL

Answer 9

I would say PitBull Terrier just cuz I got two of my own. They are great with my kids who are 3 years old and 8 months. Great for taking on longs walks and can withstand my 8 months old crawling all over them. And since they are both female dogs they keep a close eye on both my kids like a mother would.

Answer 10

I would pick Rottweiler. My daughters have 2 of them at their dads house and they are really very good dogs. And all I ever hear about is Pit Bulls being involved in attacks. Not too many Rottweilers. Anyways, thats my thought.