What if Israel were never created?

Question

1. No Muslim suicide bomber
2. No Islamic terrorist
3. No Islamic extremist

In the 10th century, during the golden age of Islam, the Muslims, Jews and Christian live side by side as neighbour happily. It all change after the Normans take over Jerusalam, they diminished the Muslim...

Sad world

Answer 1

The question is an obscenity.

Answer 2

What if the psychotic socalled "prophet" muhammed had his mental illness treated? What if he had been sent to prison for raping the 9-year-old Aisha? Muhammed was a serial killer and a pedofile. What if the most extreme version of the koran wasn't chosen (among several verisons) to be "the one and only"?

Well, first of all, the Free World would't have had to liberate The Holy Land from the imperialist muhammedan occupiers. That said, to begin with the land belonged to the Jews, as admitted by Christian as well as muhammedan sources.

Restoring Israel and giving back the land to its rightful Jewish owners was a good new start. Now Jews and Christians will live peacefully together and kick out the muslim terrorists of the Middle East.

First we kicked the muslims out of Jerusalem. Next will be Mekka and Medina. That's the only true way to world peace.

Thanks

Answer 3

Actually, Muslim extremism did not begin in 1948. Even before then, there was lots of tension between the Arabs and the westerners. Think about it: In the 1920's, Britain and France turned Arabia into a bunch of mandates (colonies). I think that that would have led to some extremists.

Terrorism - Many acts of terrorism have had nothing to do with Israel. Take the terrorist attacks of 9/11 for instance. Osama bin Laden, explained his reasons for the attack, but not once did he mention Zionism or Israel. If you want another example, look at that bombing in Madrid a couple of years ago.

10th century - Times were good back then. There was almost full equality in Muslim lands. (Jews paid higher taxes than Muslims, but, for the most part, the society was very tolerant.) However, just because they were tolerant back then and they aren't now does not mean that Israel is responsible. Extremism popped up between 900 and 1948.

Answer 4

Davay should be aware that the splinter Jewish group he cites has been decried by ALL Jewish groups in the world. They are an insane collection of 20 insane people, but they get wide press coverage because they are Jewish anti-Semites.

Regarding the question asked here, one could ask if Columbus had never discovered America, there would never have been an American Revolution nor a Civil War. Nor would World War II have broken out if the white man had never taken over the American continent.

But that is as preposterous as the asker's question.

He might as well have asked what would be the situation today if Muhammad had never been born!

Answer 5

All of this fighting in the Middle East between Arab vs Jew started AFTER Britain sat down at the end of World War I and carved up the Ottoman Empire.

The British (specifically Churchill, Lawrence of Arabia, and a secretary from the foreign office) drew the current map They created Syria, Jordan, Saudi Arabia, Iraq, Iran, etc.

The British then started telling Jews to go to the Middle East and live. As Jews came in larger numbers, trouble started. And as Arab nomads started to settle down - they found Jewish settlements.

The British and French moved into these countries and provided "advisers" to help the rulers. In Iraq they tried revolting, but the British won and imprisoned a lot of people. Including Sadam's Uncle.

When World War II started the Iraqs offered to provide Germany with all the oil they wanted if Germany would help to drive the British - OUT. Germent finally sent troops, but the British defeated them.

One of the organizers of the Iragi, went to Germany - became a member of the SS and sent radio broadcasts (every night) back to the Middle East urging them to fight Jews, British and American. After the war, he was so popular in the Middle East he was allowed to go back without facing war crime trails.

Sadam;s Uncle took Sadam in and the rest is recent history.

There is an excellent program on the History Channel called something like: Sadam and the Third Riecht

What America is doing now in the Middle East is what Britain went thru before World War II.

Answer 6

Yes without Israel India would never have been torn apart by Muslims trying to create their own state.

Without Israel Ian and Iraq would not have attacked each other often times using children and chemical weapons.

Without Israel it may have been conceivable that the Arabs in Darfur would not have killed blackies.

Guess what, without Israel there would be a Palestinian state in that place. Guess which is the only country today that has Palestinians in government? Israel....The arabs would have killed more of each other without Israel to hate and thats the only reason I would support the removal of theJewish state.

Answer 7

We ALL deserve a place to call home. Suicide bomber, Islamic terrorist ,extremist and the disrespect for woman is what diminishes Islam and sullies Muslims.

It's a sad sad world when G-d brings us out of the marry clay and brings us enlightenment. Only to end up in a worse place.

Answer 8

I do believe your forgetting the muslim genocide against the jewish founders of Medina, in what is now Saudi Arabia. They were given the choice, leave or die.

That doesn't sound so peaceful to me.

1. no muslim suicide bombers ?? So you think the suicide bombers in Iraq that are killing other Iraqi's just because they are a different sect are doing so because of Israel ??

2. No islamic terrorist ? you think the islamic terrorist who took over Mecca in 1978 did so because of Israel?
Or the islamic terrorist who have killed over 10,000 in Algeria in the last 5 years, did so because of Israel ?

3. No islamic extremist ? Do you believe the 10,000 islamic extremist that Syria killed in Hama in 1982, were extremist because of Israel ??

Answer 9

Being the center where all three major religons crash into each other, there's no way to avoid conflict in middle east.

However things did get much worse when Israel stepped into the picture with the support of US.

Now US is trying to clean up the mess, but too late.

Answer 10

The problem is not the creation of a Jewish state the problem is the creation of a racist Zionist state with no constitution no human rights to native Palestinian people read president carter new book to know what Israel is all about, or see what this Jewish group say about Zionism.