Stanley Ketchel vs Jake LaMotta. Who wins?

Question

15 rounds at middleweight and in their prime.

Answer 1

KETCHEL - W 54 (KO's 49) TF 64 - W pct 84% - KO pct 77% - wins over B. Papke{3} and O'Brien - KO'ed by J. Johnson and B. Papke - #6 ranked puncher
He was murdered over a woman when he was 24.

LAMOTTA - W 83 (KO's 30) TF 106 - W pct 78% - KO pct 28% - wins over Robinson{2}, Zivic[3], Satterfield and Cerdan - KO 'ed by Robinson and B. Fox (unknown fighter) - #52 ranked fighter
The movie "Raging Bull" was about his life

If Ketchel is really the puncher they say he is and this bout is fought under modern era rules. Then Ketchel pounds the Bull around the ring until the ref stops it. Ketchel becomes the second fighter to stop Jake. He contented all his life that he threw the Billy Fox fight. Ketchel by a 13 rd TKO.

Answer 2

I put this on my watchlist, because it sounds like a great dream fight, I wanted to see what the usuals would say. But I see they aren't weighing in. It's hard for me to comment on having only see one ketchel fight (and that being an unusual one where he fights Jack Johnson rather than another middleweight). Two tough guys who'd love to stand toe-to-toe and see who gives way first. But who would give way, I don't know. Where's Smitty when you need him???

Answer 3

Ketchel by decision

Answer 4

Jake LaMotta....Ya never got me down Ray...Ya never got me down.