English Deutsch Français Italiano Español Português 繁體中文 Bahasa Indonesia Tiếng Việt ภาษาไทย
All categories

I notice when the Bible and the Quran conflict Muslims are quick to point out the Bible has been tampered with down through history. In no place in the Quran do we find the Omniscient (knowing everything) Allah pointing out these altered passages of the Bible, or revealing the correct ones. In fact in several verses Allah contradicts himself in the Quran.

Noah’s son killed - Surah 11:42 & 43 (not found in the bible)
Abraham having different fathers (Surah 6:74)
Tower of babel was in Egypt? (Surah 28:38)
Legalizing murder (Surah 8:65)

The Sinaitic - It was written in the middle of the fourth century, about 270 years before Islam. It contains the whole of the New Testament and a large part of the Old Testament. It is now kept in the British Museum.
The Codex Ephraemi and the Dead Sea Scrolls and the thousands of other copies or part of copies of the early Bibles prove beyond doubt that the Bible could not possibly be altered or corrupted.

2007-01-08 09:19:11 · 5 answers · asked by keiichi 6 in Society & Culture Religion & Spirituality

5 answers

Shortly after Mohammed’s death, his verses remained written on stones, bones, leather, and hidden in the memories of his followers. Years passed and most of those, who claimed to remember all of the Qur'an by heart, were killed in battle. Some of the items on which verses were written were damaged or lost.

Muslims today are committed to the idea that there was one original Qur'an which was compiled without any mistakes, omissions or additions. Yet, Islamic history shows that perhaps four to seven different versions of the Qur'an emerged. One of Mohammed’s successors, Caliph Uthman, was shocked by this fact. He assigned a committee of three people to construct a standardized version of the Qur'an. Then Muslim leaders tried to burn all other versions of the Qur'an (Sahih Bukhari, Vol. 6, p. 479

2007-01-08 09:48:02 · answer #1 · answered by Sternchen 5 · 1 6

It is a new addition to my knowledge about the Bible. As a Muslim, I know that Quran has not been changed, not even a single word. I think the original copy is in Egypt with the Al Azhar university, or a museum there. I could certainly discuss with you more, write to me and lets talk, I will request respect to my religion and Allah and I will guarantee respect towards you and your beliefs, peace, a Muslim

2007-01-08 09:24:12 · answer #2 · answered by HK3738 7 · 3 2

The oldest known Quran is dated 400 yrs AFTER Muhammad.

Considering Muslims insane reverance for this nasty book, it seems impossible for Quran's to have been created during Muhammad's time and NOT SURVIVE.

Therefore its obvious that the Quran wasnt made-up until the first Caliph commisioned the project. Utheman.

2007-01-08 09:22:47 · answer #3 · answered by Anonymous · 0 6

http://uk.blog.360.yahoo.com/blog/slideshow.html?p=38&id=zosu3WE2fqjnHDfxuOkCBak7us10eg--

One of the earliest copies, written by one of the COMPANIONS of the Prophet(pbuh).

And you call those contradictions? Just because they disagree with the Bible?
(thats not the tower of Babel by the way)

And why are there so many versions of the Bible?

2007-01-08 09:31:42 · answer #4 · answered by Anonymous · 3 0

The Precious Qur'an consists of 114 surahs [1]and 6256 ayat, some 77,436 words and about 320,211 letters. [2] These numbers may be reported differ­ently from scholar to scholar depending on the method of counting the Arabic words and letters, and sometimes depending on the division or grouping of certain ayat. The entire Book was revealed in 23 years through 194 revelations with the last revelation in the 11th year after the Hijrah (the migration from Makkah to Madinah). On an average basis, one ayah, of about 12 words was revealed per day (but not, of course, every day in practice).



The longest surah in the Noble Qur'an is surah al‑Baqarah with 286 ayat and in it occurs the longest ayah (II:282). The shortest surah is surah al‑Kawthar (CVIII) with only three short ayat. A total of 92 surahs were revealed in Makkah before Muhammad (SA), migrated to Madinah (begin­ning of the Hijri calendar), and the other 22 surahs were revealed in Madinah.



The first surah of the Glorious Qur'an is al‑Fatihah (The Opening). Each surah is named after some striking incident or purpose, or after a key word in that surah. To emphasise the deserving importance of the entire being, and the environment in which the human being lives, Almighty God has granted many environmental names to the surahs of the Holy Qur'an, such as The Night, The Day, The Spider, The Honeybee, The Dawn, The Time, The Sun, The Moon, etc. All the surahs of the Holy Qur'an begin with Bismillahi 'r‑Rahmani 'r‑Raham (in the name of God, the Merciful, the Compassionate) to keep reminding us of His endless Mercy and His all‑encompassing Compassion, except for surah at‑Tawbah (IX), meaning Repentance. This may indicate the degree of God's anger with those who insist on disobeying Him. In contrast, this key word for the Grace, Blessing and Mercy of God has been effectively used twice in the Opening surah (al‑Fatihah).





For the convenience of those who wish to read all the surahs of this great book over a fixed period, the Glorious Qur'an is divided into 30 equal parts, each called one juz' (plural, ajza' meaning parts), or into seven equal segments, each called a manzil. Each juz' is subdivided into two hizbs (sections) which are further divided in four rubs (quarters). Therefore, if one reads one rub every night, the entire Qur'an will be read in about eight months. Similarly, if one wishes to read the complete Qur'an in one week, one must read one manzil a day. Large surahs of the Glorious Qur'an are also divided into rukuc according to the meaning of the passage.



The Noble Qur'an has been well preserved in its original form through­out fourteen centuries in two ways: 1) in writing, and 2) by memorising and passing the words from the heart of one generation into that of another. Two copies of the original standard Qur'an still exist today, one in Istanbul [3] (Turkey) and one in Tashkent [4] (Uzbekistan).



The Glorious Qur'an is considered to be so Holy that Muslims treat it with enormous respect.



While It is being read:

• You must not speak

• You must not eat or drink

• You must concentrate quietly.



It is not to be touched unnecessarily. Before reading it or touching it:

• You must wash thoroughly

• You must be in the right frame of mind and have good intentions

• You must seek refuge in God from satan's wicked intentions

• Women should be clear from menstruation.



Upon completion of its recitation one should conclude the session with certain phrases, at least stating that the Exalted God speaks the Truth, His Blessings be upon Muhammad (SA) and his kinsfolk. But normally, a longer prayer is recited.



When not being recited, it should be:

• Placed high up, so that nothing is put on top of it

• Kept covered with a light cloth to shield it from dust.



I shall refrain from describing this unique Book of Divine Guidance in my own humble words and examine how the Great Qur'an Itself defines Its own aspects.



Endnotes




Notes:

[1] Please refer to the Glossary.

[2] "The history of the collection of the Glorious Qur'an", Sayyid Muhammad Rida Jalali Na'ini (Farsi), 1365 (1986), p 148.

[3] Istanbul is a corrupted name for the city of Islambul. The old Constantinople (during the Byzantine Empire) was re‑named Islambul by the Ottoman Sultan Mehmed II. Islambul is a Turkish expression meaning "where Muslims are plentiful". Istanbul has no relevant meaning. The closest expression is a Greek one, Eistanpolin, meaning "toward the city!"

[4] This is known as the Tashkent Qur'an. It is related to the time of ‘Uthman ibn ‘Affan, and was kept in Khaji 'Ubeydullah Ahrar mosque in Samarqand. Later, It was moved to Petersburg museum during the Tzars' rule in Russia. Late in 1918 It was brought back to Samarqand ceremonially. This Valuable Qur'an was later moved to Tashkent museum (reference: Tarikh al‑Mushaf al‑‘Uthmani by Shiykh 'Ismai’l Makhdum

2007-01-08 09:29:00 · answer #5 · answered by MUHAMMAD 3 · 3 2

fedest.com, questions and answers