Is Muhammad a Prophet ?

Question

1 - Prophets in the old testament could perform great miracles and prophesy.

According to the Q'uran, Q. 17: 90 to 93, muhammad admitted he was unable to perform miracles nor prophesy.

2 - If Muhammad is the greatest of the prophets, then why was Enoch and Jesus brought straight up to heaven with Jesus returning as a witness to the muslims, but Muhammad is still rotting at Mecca today?

3 - Can a pedophile be a prophet? Prophets in the old testament have great and impeccable character, but muhammad had sex with a 9 year old when he was already 52, thereby committing pedophilia.

4 - Allah told muhammad's adopted son to give up his wife (zainab) to muhammad, why? Why didn't allah have the foresight to know this and prohibited the adopted son's marriage in the first place?

5 - In Ishaq 166, Muhammad admitted he spoke up for Satan, then later apologised for the huge mistake (Satanic verses). Why? do prophets speak for demons? Or is this a demon's prophet?

Answer 1

Please, one should not make fun of someone's religion.

Answer 2

If you're looking for a place to blab on this is not the place. If you sincerely want answers then here they are; but plz don't hear only what you want but accept the truth. Peace.

1. Prophet Muhamad was simply a warner and a man, like you and me. Nothing more, nothing less. Just a good man.

2. He is not the greatest. Muhamad (SAW) said "Do not say I am better than Jonah." (i.e. even the "least important" should not be ranked; they are all prophets of God).

3. Back then it was not pedophilia and the actual age is disputed. For the sake of this I'll say 9 though. In Medieval Europe 12 years old (puberty) was normal among girls to become married. COnsidering the average life span is about 40 years they've lived 1/4 of their life! So, there were different customs. Look in the Bible and you'll find much worse stories!

4. Allah did this on purpose to show that no matter what, an adopted child will never have your blood and therefor is not an actual "heir" of the family but simply like a fostered kid being orphaned. Muhamad (SAW) initially didn't want to do this, but Allah insisted that he set a precedent to clarify the actual position of an adopted child; and even then it was his foster child's wife who got divorced...

5. The Prophet had not yet learned to master resistance from the devil. Actually after a while, he had many encounters with jinnies and tried to convert them to the true Islam. Through piety, Satan was dispelled from his vicinity.

Believe what you want; but truth stands clear from lies. Peace.

Answer 3

you see the problems that i think ignorant people like you have is the lack to seek knowledge on things that you have no idea about. I think you should seek knowledge about islam it is not a matter of forcing someone to islam but at least read about the story of all the prophets and stop being a sinner with what you say about the prophet of Allah because if you know, you would not have question what any prophet said regardless, seek knowledge please and get out of the darkness that you find yourself.

Answer 4

i'm going to ignore the 5 points you gave especially 3 and 5 because they are ridiculous....and have mostly been answered by others already

i just have one question for you.

Are you a muslim? no? oh ok then....so you dont believe that Muhammad (pbuh) was a prophet and neither does any other non-muslim. i see......so...what was the point of the question again?

Answer 5

Yes, he is a prophet. You should be ashamed of your prejudices. Is that what your religion teaches you? I think you have a false prophet because that's not very Godly at all.

A comparative religion class will dispel your ignorance and open your eyes to many different realities of those times. The bible is also full of "fallen men." I suggest that before you throw stones do a search on Lot and how he treated his daughters.

Answer 6

how dare you, writing something that you have no knowledge about. Before you utter the words Muhammad, spend the time reading about your own religion..son. may Allah help those who are ignorant. Ameen.
Until you come with REAL proof, you have not said nothing. At least read before you speak and quote something you have not a single understanding of.

Answer 7

NOt a prophet of GOD>
1 John 2:22
" Who is the liar but the one who denies that Jesus is the Christ? This is the antichrist, the one who denies the Father and the Son"

Answer 8

Lets see he goes against all the teachings of the one and only true God the Father. So I seriously doubt God would make him one of His prophets to spread false truth.

Answer 9

Any prophet that gives one wrong prophhecy is a false prophet.

Answer 10

Muhammed was born almost 600 years after Christ.

Then he tried to re-write history and falsify the teachings of Christ:
Muslims (and Islam) say Jesus was a prophet but they reject all His teachings ...

They reject Christ's divinity;
they reject his claim to be the Son of God;
they reject his death on the cross...
they reject His ressurrection..
They reject Jesus is the Christ/ Messiah...
Need I say more...?

Don't be deceived. The Islamic god is totally different than the God of Jesus Christ .

The Bible calls Muhammed a False prophet....

"Who is a liar but he that denies that Jesus is the Christ? He is anti-Christ, that denies the Father and the Son. He that denies the Son, the same has not the Father." (I John 2:22)

Answer 11

Muslims are goingto say you are lieing, even though everything you have said is fact, and has been written in history books. He was nothing more than a vicious warlord who had really good writers, and lots of support from all his in-laws.