Was Mohammad a failure as a prophet?

Question

When we study Mosus the prophet of God we see he had power i mean real power. He commanded the wind, The water of the nile, The flies, the lice, the spirit of death. And even more.
When we study Jesus he has the same power over storms and food and water and healing.
But when we study Mohammad we do not find him with any power, so was he a prophet, a failure as a prophet, a false prophet,
or a murdering man who enjoyed sex?

Answer 1

He wasn't a failure, you are the failure, the failure to educated yourself before you post such a silly question with nonsense incorrect so called facts.!

Answer 2

Perhaps your studies of Islam are bit lacking, or perhaps you are simply reflecting the ridiculous and bigoted attitude that you are being taught each day by the mass media.

There have been many of the same miracles attributed to others throughout history.

A Prophet speaks with his God directly, a claim that can never be disproved. Unless I were a prophet myself, and completely sure due to some divine event, I would be hesitant about rating or passing judgment on religious leaders besides your own.

Based simply on the numbers of followers worldwide, you have little chance of being in the right religion when the time comes.

Or, at best, no one is exactly right, and there turns out to be one God responsible for all of the different religions, and you have to explain your intolerance then.

In answer to your question -

Who will be reading what you say 2 or 3 thousand years from now? Any man that has kept himself alive through his words for that long would have to be considered a success, whether you believe his words or not.

Answer 3

first of all i would really appreciate it if you study well before posting such questions .
the holly prophet Mohammad was great not a failure as you say he had many miracles the Qouran was his greatest miracle with all it has in it it told of past stories and stories to come like how the Romans will win the war in few years (at that time ) it all so has allot of scientific miracles still discovering them till now and many scientists are going in to Islam because of what their discover now has been told about ages ago in the holly qouran another miracle is the night journey of the holly prophet when god took him from Saudi Arabia to Jerusalem then up to the skies then back to his home all of that happened from dawn to sunrise .
if i want to talk i can go on forever . am more than happy to answer any question you have .

Answer 4

Below are accounts of the some of the miracles of Prophet Muhammad(P) . Before reading these, it helps to know something about the Science of Traditions (Arabic: Ahadith), an exacting and comprehensive system developed by early Muslim scholars to verify the chain of transmission of these accounts, as well as investigating the trustworthiness and capability of every narrator at every level of the chain. This thorough authentication process ensures that these accounts are real, validated narrations of the sayings, actions, and tacit approvals of the Prophet Muhammad(P). The Traditions mentioned below are all from Sahih al-Bukhari, the most authentic collection.

Splitting of the Moon

Food Multiplication

Water Multiplication

Supplication for Rain

Lights to guide Companions

Crying of the stem of the date-palm tree

Glorification of Allah by the Prophet's meals

The expulsion of a Christian liar's corpse by the Earth

The Speech of the Wolf

The Prophet's Night Journey to Jerusalem and Ascent to the Heavens

Answer 5

I do love my prophet very much more than i love water to clear my thirst. My advise to you is to buy HOLY QURAN and read it with your open heart. You'll find few power which has been given by ALLAH to him as prophet. The most of it was, his journey to meet ALLAH with JIBRIL(angel) travel from MECCA to BAITULMAQDIS in few seconds and to the 7th sky to meet the Creator and he was awarded the SOLAT which has not been awarded to the prophet before him. In few years time, he has unite the Arabs and has change the people perceptions towards ISLAM. Of course, he was only human as the other prophet before him like Jesus, Abraham, Noah , Adam etc. GOD has declare that no people shall enter heaven before MOHAMMAD and his people entered the heaven first. And during his death his was thinking of his people rather than himself. He is married to Siti Khadijah(the only woman which give him childrens) and most of the woman he married was widow which don't have someone to rely on to.

Answer 6

Really tells you how little muslims know about their OWN religion.

Look at Zifkos, the guy said muhammad could split the moon! Looks like muslims don't know their Q'uran! Tsk tsk.

There are NO miracles in the q'uran, the only 'miracles' by muhammad are by the soothesayers who would lie through their teeth even against what muhammad said to improve muhammad's stature as a 'prophet'.

Well, what did muhammad himself say ??? Muhammad ADMITTED in the Q'uran that he could perform NO miracles. One wonders how the muslims can cook up that pack of lies for muhammad to support his flimsy claim of 'prophethood'.

- Sura 17:90
They say: "We will by no means believe in you until you cause a fountain to gush forth from the earth for us.,"

Muhammad replied

- Sura 17:93
Say: "Am I anything but a man,- a messenger?"

Good enough.

Answer 7

Mohammad Nabi God in the land of God and the miracles that God gave them, but like yourself who come sectarian ideas and hostile to the Muslims do not deserve to respond to them

Answer 8

Hi Thomas,

Believe it or not you had just answer your question. A prophet of God never fails.

Answer 9

no he had powers too .. like once the moon was cut into too 2 halfs ! & islam respect the other prophets so you better do instead of insulting muhammad the prophet ...

Answer 10

Moses never had the power. It was because of him though that God brought out events. There were 12 non-Jewish prophets to the other antion but Mohammed wasn't one of them. I'm not sure who he was and whether he preached anti-Semitism but he wasn't a prophet.