Are illegal immigrants really to blame for our job losses or are the comapnies that are hiring them guilty too

Question

The way I see it is if these big wig companies would just grit their teeth are hang in there with the good old american help they got, pay the employees their worth and stop hiring these d*&$
illegals, their wouldn't be such a big problem. They are just as much to blame as these illegal immigrants who are after the jobs!

Answer 1

I think the country is losing more jobs to oversees countries where workers are forced to work overtime and only paid $20 a month. More and more jobs are being sent oversees at a much higher rate than illegals are taking.

Answer 2

But first and foremost the illegal is to blame solely for being here illegally.The company's that hire illegal aliens simply compound the problem.Of course the employers are equally to blame.If the promise of jobs wasn't dangled like a steak before a hungry dog ,less illegals would come here.We have strict laws against this practice but they are either not enforced or totally ignored by our government.

Americano lives in a dream world created by propaganda and propagated by BS.rhetoric.There are many lazy, worthless, drunken,shiftless illegal aliens just as there are in all people.Illegal aliens cant walk on water stop making it seem that they can.

Answer 3

Big companies are to blame. If there are no jobs the flow of illegals would consideable drop! Fines need to be given to anyone who hires an illegal. Big fines 10,000 dollars per company.
However for that to happen govenment must become more involved in the business sector! A Big Republican NO!NO!
Rats you have these big wig companies who are own mostly by republicans, Then you have the republicans who want less government involvement. Why do the Democrats get the blame for illegals?? Seems to me like the republicans but us in a catch 22.

Answer 4

Up until about 3 years ago, U.S Border Patrol Agents were allowed to stop possible illegal immigrants anywhere. Now , restrictions are in place that state agents cannot even enter business parking lots without search warrants. Check your local state reps and you will find out who voted these laws in place currently. You will also find no pending legilation to remove these laws. Basically agents can chase a pickup truck full of illegal immigrants to a business parking lot, than must stop and do nothing.

Answer 5

I blame the employers far more than I blame the illegal immigrants. If NO employers were hiring illegal immigrants anywhere in the USA, most of the illegal immigrants would leave on their own steam before very long. There would still be those who would stay to try to have anchor babies and get free benefits and those who will stay and try to get away with using fake/fraudulent SSNs and other ID, as well as the criminal element in the illicit drug business, prostitution, and gang activity, but they would soon be routed out while the others would mass deport themselves. And, while we are at it, if we got rid of the anchor baby law and strictly and consistently denied social benefits and free medical care for all but emergency needs, a great deal more of the illegals would take themselves back home and many more potential illegal immigrants would decide not to come, in the first place.

Yes, in my books, the employers of illegals are far worse criminals than the illegals, themselves.

Answer 6

The companies are to blame. Hey if you know anyone who hires an illegal immigrant go to www.irs.gov and fill out a 3949A form. I DID IT and I'm waiting to hear word! The business will be charged $100,000 for each illegal immigrant they hire and if they get caught red handed by your tip, you get 10%. $$Cha-CHING$$

Answer 7

ABsolutely correct. IN fact, I believe the are moe at fault. The big bruisers are telling our Sen and Con twits that this country won't have jobs, taxes workers or opportunity unless they can have cheap labor. Cheap labor that won't turn them in for their misdeeds on environment, misdeeds on how they work people and so on. Who knows what malfeasance is done with illegals at the helm doing the labor.
The minute you make them legal ...they want more money. They get lawyers and off we go ..just like it is for Americans anyway.
The illegals are a quick fix at best. They will bring us to our knees financially and circumstancially. We simply cannot allow it.

Answer 8

Both are to blame. There are other players too, like the US gov't which loves a docile non-voting population and Mexico which likes a convenient trash dumpster north of the border.

Answer 9

HUMM, MAYBE, the impoverished jobless would actully have better paying jobs. This work was not always done by Mexicans. How about inmates getting out there supervised, and cheap?

Answer 10

Nobody is to blame. It's not their fault that they are good workers and get there first to get the job.I am American but it makes me so mad when Americans sit there and complain about illegals stealing our jobs.Why don't you all stop complaining and get off the internet and your butt and go get a job.