Isn't it a long time overdue that all Mastiff dogs should be banned from public spaces?

Question

They should be presumed guilty and executed if they escape. (England)

All the Molosser types. They cannot be trained to be safe in public. They are too bloody stubborn.

The small ones like Staffordshire Bull Terriers are a thorough nuisance and the big ones like Dogos are so dangerous it is ridiculous. You can keep them at home. Just do not want to go out armed for protection in England.

I think you may misunderstand the public. A neutral member of the public on a piece of public land (UK) is not in a position to know if the dog is dangerous or not?

I want to be free to walk in public without being prepared to defend myself. Cars may be more dangerous but I can choose to avoid roads.

Answer 1

Its not the breed of dog its the Owner of the breed.
All owners should be banned from taking any breed out in public that has been proven dangerous unless they can pass a test to prove they know how to handle it.

Answer 2

This question just furthers my will to educate the public about the "true" nature of dogs as a whole, not just these type dogs, but all breeds. As well as educate the public about people's involvement in why the attacks, maulings, bites, etc happen.

The truth is, every school should have a "dog safety awareness" class in which someone comes into the school and educates the children about the correct way to approach a dog, how to ask the owner and parent for permission to pet the dog, as well as what to do if approached by a dog.

This goes for adults to. I can't tell you how many adults think a dog is "attacking" them just because it approaches them. People do not know how to tell the signs of a friendly versus unfriendly dog, and still more people do not know that you should not pet a strange (or even known) dog on the head, or hug the dog, as the dog can perceive this as a threat and react accordingly.

It's actually a long time over due that people aren't taught as children how to act, behave, and treat dogs. If more people were educated, less attacks and bites would occur, which would be beneficial on so many levels.

http://www.libertydogtraining.com

Answer 3

As a Mastiff owner I have to disagree, my dog is the dossiest thing anyone will come across, although saying that, if I was in any danger of being harmed he would certanly rip limb from limb to protect me. Children and animals should never be left alone under any circumstances. It is unfortunate what happened to that girl and I feel that the dog was given the ultimate punishment, the fact is, the dogs owner ( the little girls uncle) should ave been more strict with the dog. O yes and another thing the little girl was mauled by a "Pitt type" dog, so I dont see why you should pick on the Mastiffs, they are loyal guard dogs and I would gladly let my dog rip you limb from limb if you where to threaten me or my life. I wouldnt be without my baby.

Answer 4

NO!!!!!! We as concerned citizens should push for harsher laws on the people who turn these wonderful dogs into dangerous animals!!!!!!! The dogs only learn and act as their human moms and dads teach them just like kids!!!!! If you raise with love and caring then you get love and caring if you raise with hate and cruelty you get anger and meaness back...... Do some research about all the good these dogs have done over the years to be specific look up search and rescue bulldogs!!!!!! On 9/11 there were at least 2 bulldogs and many more buldog types that help to recover all the people dead and alive!!! Look up Pit bulls and mastiffs as service animals and see how when they are put in the right hands how much good they can do!!!!!

Answer 5

No if they are not hurting anyone then they are fine maybe you should read this it's quoted from dogbreedinfo.com

Originally valued for their abilities as a fierce guard and fighting dog, today's Mastiff is a gentle giant. It is a self-confident, watchful, and patient dog who is gentle-natured towards his family. Intelligent and dignified. It rarely barks, but it is in its nature to defend its territory and family. Calm, steady and docile, this dog is normally excellent with children, (not recommend for toddlers though, because of their great size). Good natured, but very large and heavy. Responds well to gentle, patient training. This breed loves to please and needs lots of companionship. The Mastiff's dominance varies widely depending on the lineage. They can be aloof with strangers or fairly friendly. Do not hit a Mastiff or you are asking for it! A born guard dog, brave and loyal. When strangers visit, it is likely to refuse to let them in unless they are accepted by its handler. The Mastiff generally holds intruders at bay rather than attacking. Protection training is unnecessary for this naturally protective breed. It is very possessive of home, family and car. It may be combative with other dogs if not very well socialized as a puppy, so extra effort should be given to socialize a Mastiff puppy. If properly socialized it will get along well with other dogs. The Mastiff tends to drool, wheeze and snore loudly. They can be somewhat difficult to train.

Answer 6

Have you ever even MET a Mastiff? These dogs are so calm, laid-back & easy going it's unbeliveable.

Don't let the media hype of a few bad apples let you make a knee-jerk decision on breed, read & find out what the MAJORITY of the so-called 'dangerous breeds' are like - your ignorance is showing.

Answer 7

No!! Actually All the mastiff's I have met are great. They are big and powerful but most Mastiff breeders are extremely careful to breed for good temperment. Good training and socializtion is the key, I see no point in banning dogs unless you plan on banning the idiot humans who cause the problems!

Answer 8

What a stupid way of thinking! It's this mentality that tightens the grip on people's freedom and breeds more ignorance! How about instead of blaming an entire catagory of dog, blame the idiot people who abuse any priviledge. There are people that make owning hamsters look dangerous, I used to work for a vet and have heard how their Hamsters attacked their children. Maybe we should just ban ALL PETS!! There, then we can all live safely in our bubble from anything bad happening! Oh wait...gonna have to ban cars...and knives....and oh crap our air and water too! They are hazerdous to your health! Okay, I propose a law to ban breathing air and drinking of tap water. We must now all carry around oxygen tanks and masks and drink bottled double purified water!



Oh and don't forget scissors and bathtub and shower stalls... ban them all!!

Answer 9

No i don't think this should be the case i myself own a big dog an American bulldog and she is the sweetest thing you will ever meet she doesn't approach strangers when out walking she doesn't show any kind of aggression and listens to everything i say.

Just because its a big dog doesnt make them stubborn to train my dog is trained rather well and shes a big dog.

Answer 10

Dogs are as good as their owners. If you poke a dog and teach him to fight and be aggressive, that's what it will do. A lot of Mastiff type dog owners are macho-image nitwits, who push their dog to be scary to impress other macho-idiots. Then when a kid pays for their stupidity the dog gets the blame.
The English dog who mauled a kid was left alone with a dog who had received complaints already (the owner obviously irresponsible). Where were the child's parents?