Should parents decide which career their children choose?

Question

tell if u agree or dis agree and give reasons why

Answer 1

No but good luck to them if they try

Answer 2

I do not think parents should pick their children's careers.

Careers are about adult life and adults are independent, not little robots to be manipulated into what other adults want them to do. A career is a huge source of fulfillment and contentment in life--to go into a career simply because your parents have decided that for you can backfire. There are plenty of books out there talking about the very thing--people who mope through life because they became what those around them expected, but were wholly unsatisfied because it wasn't what they really wanted.

I understand that in different cultures, the social structure is different and it is expected that the children will do as the parents wish, even if the children are adults themselves. I did not grow up in such a culture. In my typically Canadian upbringing, childhood is about making your way to independence and leading your own life. You're not leading your own life if you are being told how to lead it.

Answer 3

Absolutely not! Certainly it makes sense for parents to lay a good foundation for children to make wise career choices by emphasizing the value of education, by giving your children educational opportunities, and by giving your children opportunities to observe people in careers that you think might be good choices for them. But you cannot force a career choice on a child. A career is something a person spends the majority of his/her waking hours doing. While choosing one's own career doesn't guarantee one will be happy, having one forced on you against your will almost certainly guarantees you that you will be unhappy.

Also, when children are teenagers and heading off to college to decide what career path they will follow, it's almost always the case that they are at their most rebellious developmental stage. If parents push too hard on the career issue, basically deciding, "you will study pre-med and go to medical school and become a doctor," kids are likely to do the opposite just because they are at that age where they are rejecting authority and figuring out their own likes and dislikes. If the kid is allowed to use college as an opportunity to explore what careers are out their, the child may find that she wants to be a doctor, all on her own. But it you push that route, she may reject that path for ever just because you chose it for her and it wasn't her choice.

Answer 4

No a parent should not choose a career for their child as a parent should not take the responsibility of making sure their child's homework is done or punishing them for bad grades. If you let a child learn early on that their education is to benefit them and has nothing to do with you, not something for you to be proud of all A's they get and embarrassed at anything less the better they will be. They might actually spend time learning something instead of wasting so much time trying to please their parents. If you don't get that at least know you cannot tell your child who to be.

Answer 5

OK, I may be in the minority here, but here's my story.

I was a high school senior and deciding on colleges and careers. I was huge into music (both band & choirs), but also a straight A student who excelled at science, history, and math (I always hated English, though).

I said to Dad, who was footing the college bill that I was torn between history, polisci, and music. He said, if I expected him to help me with college, I would need to major in something that I could support myself on. So I majored in engineering and frankly, to this day, I am very glad. Looking back, I wasn't making that decision with any amount of worldly knowledge at all...I was just picking stuff I liked. So I am very thankful he did what he did.

You may think this was the wrong thing to do, but if it was his money, didn't he have a right to do what he did? I mean, if I had to work my way through college, I could've gone into any major I wanted, right?

Anyway, that's my story...

Answer 6

Absolutely not! The parents have no right to make that decision. Are the parents going to work for the child? What if the child HATES what the parent wants them to be? You want a child to explore and find out things on their own. That's one of the most archaic things I've ever heard. That's like having arranged marriages.

Answer 7

No, of course not, because the career the parents choose may not be one that the kids will be good at or fulfilled by.

Answer 8

i'd desire to weigh in in this question. My mum and dad continuously inspired me to be despite i had to be -- and to be the final at it that i'd desire to. I went to college to alter right into a instructor and am now a preschool director -- and that i admire what I do. My husband's kinfolk, on the different hand, owns a food market and predicted him to artwork there from the time he became little. there became never the different communicate of yet another occupation selection different than taking on the "kinfolk employer." So, he began working there as a young person and now that he's 37, he continues to be there. He took it sluggish to bypass to college, and studied employer. yet, his mum and dad never inspired him to do something - never inspired him to "shop on along with his dream." They completely predicted him to artwork on the shop, and that's what he's achieved. he's now 37 and unquestionably hates working at his mum and dad' shop... yet he has such overbearing mum and dad that he sounds like he would desire to never bypass away and bypass someplace else. He would desire to be so lots extra -- he's SO smart, extremely sturdy with human beings.... yet he's never had yet another interest in his existence. His resume is somewhat short.... SO, all that to assert -- i think that oldsters would desire to help cultivate a toddler's skills and help them to make certain what jobs are accessible that they could be sturdy at and encourage them in despite field they decide on -- yet not come to a determination a toddler's occupation for them. P.S. - we've a 9-3 hundred and sixty 5 days-previous son that isn't experience forced to maintain on with in my husband's footsteps. If that's what he needs to do while he grows up, then we can be high-quality with that -- yet while he chooses to pursue different careers, we can motivate him to take action.

Answer 9

Of course not! If it is there dream than back them up with it. A parent can be a big help with the right job.

Answer 10

No, the children should be happy and are more likely to be happy in a job they choose themselves.

Answer 11

the child should choose what they want to do, what theyre good at. if the parents choose, it wont be a real sucess.