Do you agree? How to tell a good Muslim from a bad Muslim method.?

Question

Simply ask him or her:

Do you believe Osama Bin Ladin is a good Muslim, a bad Muslim or a non-Muslim pretending to be Muslim and why do you believe that?


I found that this is the only way that I could begin to tell the difference between Good Muslims and those who secretly side with extremism.

Good Muslims will answer you directly, generally something along the lines that Osama Bin Laden is a bad Muslim or not a Muslim. They will then support their answers.

Bad muslims/extremist sympathizers/weasel out of questions muslims will generally do one of the following.

Avoid the question

Evade by giving vague answers or regurgitating canned answers and scriptures etc.

or they may also potentially lie about their belief but it will be painful for them to in effect be helping the cause of peace by their very words. I doubt most bad muslims will be willing to lie publicly when they know it will be used against their extremist friends.

poki poki you said:

"i believe Osama bin Laden is a misguided Muslim who seeked to please his own ego and forgot what God teaches."

Those are sinnful acts are they not? or at the very least, acts unbecoming of a Good Muslim. So by your very own public words we can infer that you poki poki believe Osama Bin Ladin is a bad muslim.

You didn't answer directly and attempted to be clever but anyone can see where your true alliances fall.

I Know... Do you???

You said:
Wow....

that sounds like a Christian!!

"Circular reasoning, avoiding the question...using the bible as an answer to everything...

Does that mean they are all on Osama's side!?!?!"

I am not religious and I completely agree that people of other religions use similar forms of dialog to squirm their way out of things.

And how can someone like you be able to make such a great distinction and yet be so foolish as to follow it with such an absurd question.

First of all: Most Christians would not be expected to answer whether or not Osama Bin Ladin is a good Muslim, bad Muslim or non Muslim pretending to be a Good Muslim as I am sure that most Muslims would expect that only true Muslims could make that final assessment.

Secondly I am sure that most Christian would agree that Osama Bin Ladin's act of terrorism are sins.

And Christians are not the ones saying they are Good Muslims or Real Muslims or Moderate Muslims.

What are you half blithering idiot?

A.J.

You said:

"dont label ppl b itch. wat if i said "how do u tell a good american from a bad american" or "a good christian from a bad christian" thats 1 person, if ur a b itch it doesnt make me one, even if alot more americans are ungrateful b itches!"

Listen moron, we have Muslims they are peaceful in comes sicko terrorist who kill many innocent people and by the way these sicko terrorist also say they are Muslims.

People get confused they and angry that want answers. Muslims say the terrorist are not real Muslim, or the terrorist are not following the real message of the Koran etc.

Some Muslims consider themselves moderate Muslims or mainstream Muslims etc.

All I am trying to figure out is the best method to figure out who is on whose side.

So stop trying to make it look like I am trying to as you say "label" people.

You have a better idea on how to differentiate the good apples from the bad apples?

Probably NOT in which case shut your freaking pie hole!!!

Dangerous Danny,

You said:

"What if a bad muslim just flat out lies?"

I have already answered your question, however I believe it bears repeating.

If a bad muslim or islamic extremist sympathizer tries to hide their true alliance to extremism by publicly saying they hate Osama Bin Laden and/or that he will probably go to hell for his sin against Islam, then at least their own words can be used against them and against the cause of extremism and to further the cause of Peace which is what most people want.

Answer 1

i believe Osama bin Laden is a misguided Muslim who seeked to please his own ego and forgot what God teaches.

Answer 2

I hate to judge and all, but from a moral and practical viewpoint I would obviously say bad. If he really did ALL those things, then he killed lots of innocent people (which *cough* is punishable by hell). From a strcitly Muslim standpoint, he has crushed all that we've done to make Islam a good religion. If he really wnted to be a good Muslim he would've spread peace not violence. He hasn;t helped guide one non Muslim to Islam (at least to my knowledge lol) and is therefore not a benefit to anyone (IMHO). Stupid, ignorant extremists are ruining all the god damned work we do and now there is double-standards and a heightened pressure on the Muslim community to be super Muslims. We are supposed to be good family members, smart, peaceful, anti-terrorism, openy involved in the community etc. but if we do one thing wrong everyone starts judging us (even in our own Muslim community). I've done so much of correcting thse misconceptions, speaking out against all forms of teeroism and making our city a better place. Why do *we* go unnoticed by the masses? And God knows best. Peace.

Answer 3

it quite is basically certainly disgusting. It made me cry through fact it quite is basically so incorrect. some areas of Pakistan as a state.... isn't the suitable place to seem at as an Islamic occasion through fact some people finally end up mixing way of existence and forget approximately Islamic innovations through fact the're uneducated. The cherished Prophet PBUH typical females's rights! Pre-Islamic Arabia used to bury ladies alive and Islam positioned a end to it! it quite is FORBIDDEN and that i wish via Allah that he destroys those people in Hellfire and interior the grave. those people committed 2 significant sins. They comitted homicide and refused to permit the girl the the suitable option to verify on their spouses it relatively is an undemanding right for Muslim females. It basically breaks my heart once I see such backward issues even it wasn't in a meant Islamic community no person merits this. that may not Islam its way of existence.

Answer 4

muslim are not bad the way they make them to be make them bad but there not but if you sit down and talk to a muslim you might become good friend

Answer 5

Wow....

that sounds like a Christian!!

Circular reasoning, avoiding the question...using the bible as an answer to everything...

Does that mean they are all on Osama's side!?!?!

Answer 6

What if a bad muslim just flat out lies?