To those who believe in reincarnation - Suicide useless?

Question

For believers in reincarnation. Do you believe if a person committs suicide they have to come back and live that life all over again?

To the dung beetle remark. I do not believe people come back as insects or other animals. And I didn't mean the exact same life. What I meant was would the person have to face the same level of difficulty in life.

Answer 1

Not just suicide... it can include unresolved issues. Have you noticed that we all seem to meet back the same type of people and fall in love again? and Similar "problems" will arise for us to overcome, and if we bail... later we will again meet simialr people to getthru those tests again.

Same concept with sucides, you will return only to face the same problem again and again in diff guises until you are able to overcome it.

Answer 2

If you commit suicide your soul will be treated no differently than someone who died of "natural" causes. There will be no punishment and only awareness and only if you choose to go through the life review. No one is judging you except yourself because you are the only one who knows your own heart. What mediums/spiritualists and religious folk confuse with punishment or having to "repeat" life challenges is that these are all circumstances which the suicide soul wants to do. Some people commit suicide with fear (leading sometimes to TEMPORARY "hellish" conditions) while others commit suicide with a sincere desire to live or live again (causing them to want to retry their life again). So if things aren't going as you'd like them to go, exhaust all physical and spiritual options on this plane but feel free to "exit" and try again. There's no judgement/torment other than that which you place upon yourself, so make sure you're smiling before you exit :)

Answer 3

According to Karma/Dharma, a life lived well is rewarded with a better position in the next. A life that goes bad would mean a worse starting position in the next.

Answer 4

No. I think if someone commits suicide they were mentally ill and chose to shed their physical bodies on their own. I am a past life suicide myself and I'm not living the exact same life over again, but I did have to confront the repercussions of my past life in this life. And I handled it. I wasn't strong enough in my other life to deal with it. I hope that makes sense. Blessed be.

Answer 5

Yes he/she will be reborn into same environment which torutured him/her PLUS another sin of committing suicide will be with him

Karma can not be nullified if we die.. the negativity(or positive) is carried forward in next birth

That z why all religions treat suicide a big sin

Answer 6

what happens is the person comes back in a lower form. reincarnation is a way of evolving. higher if the life is lived well. lower if not.

Answer 7

Pretty much, yeah. You are meant to learn from life. Until you learn, you will continue to go through the same tests and trials.

Answer 8

Absolutely. Not only is suicide useless, it is self-defeating. It is like destroying your car even though you have a long way to go and cannot readily and quickly access another vehicle.

Answer 9

I believe that regardless of whether we kill ourselves or not we do come back again and again until we perfect our souls or until you decide you are done-then you get to join the Source which some call God

Answer 10

no not useless
no they don't have to live that life over again
the thing is next life could be better or you could be a dung beetle