Holocaust???????

Question

who perpetrated holocaust,the NAZIS, GERMAN, so they should pay the compensation to the Jewish nation and establish state within Germany and not whithin the land which belongs to the Palestinian,at least if the ppl at UN think of this before 1948, there will peace in the Middle East and no existence of what we called a moslem terrorrist nowadays

Answer 1

interesting idea...put them in Germany. And stop making troubles in the MidEast!
(Then again, who funded the Germans? I believe it was Bush's grandfather. Did he ever do time for that?)

Answer 2

Hey Yuppe, you do know that the term Palestinian was actually first used by the British when they held a mandate of the area. And guess what, according to a 1922 census done by the British, the population was about eighty percent Muslim, ten percent jewish, and ten percent Christian. The majority of the Israelis came after that and that is why they feel they deserve the land.

Besides that, should the claim of ancestrial heritage even be considered? I mean if that was the case Native Americans could claim the whole United States and Canada as their own. Why shouldn't they be allowed to have a right to the land? Their claim to the land is much more recent than the Jews. The last time Israel existed until modern times was 720 BC. Since then the area has been ruled by one empire or another. That's what happens in war. That is also the reason why the Palestinians have no right to the land anymore. Israel straight up kicked their asses along with most of the Middle East in the six day war.

The funny thing is that originally Jewish settlers were only going to be allowed limited land in the British mandate of Palestine which would be part of a federalized Arabic state (Morrison-Grady Plan) This was rejected by Jews and Arabs. Wouldn't the world be a different place if they could have accepted this!

Answer 3

Actually the area around the Palestine is Israel -the true Israel,the place were the Hebrew,Muslim and Christian beliefs originated from.For the worlds three largest faiths it is a holly place.
Who wouldn't want to let go of their ancestral home.That is why after WWII since Palestine was under the English at the time,they carved out a separate piece of land for the Jews in Palestine.
Muslim fundamentalism did not originate due to this one matter.
History has had SO many incidents that have contributed to the rise of Muslim fundamentalism and finally terrorism.From the dethroning of the Shah of Iran by the orthodox Muslim Clerics to the rise of dictators like Saddam and core terrorists like Osama Bin Laden.
Terrorism has always been their,Muslim or non Muslim.
Its just that, at this day and age.Terrorism has taken a new face.On a final note,one of the compensations was the creation of a new Jewish state.

Answer 4

First off there was NEVER a country called Palestinian in recorded history going back 5000 years. This information comes for Egypt.
Secondly the Palestians were nomads until the Egypt, Syria, Jordan, Lebanon, Saudi Arabia, and Iran told them to settle in the land that was and is Israel! These countries refused to allow them to settle or give them a place to call their own!
Thirdly it was these countries that told the Palestians to settle in the land in order that the U.N. would be forced to give them a land and a country of their own.
Fourth the big power full Arab countries decide that when Israel was granted the land and to become a country again they attacked! They lost however.
Please get your history correct first then ask a question.
Lastly there will NEVER be peace between any of the Moslem's because of their hate for each other!

Answer 5

The atrocities of the Holocaust made it clear the Jews needed a homeland. The reason certain religious Jews believed it had to be in Palestine centers around the Jewish belief that specific territory was promised to them by God. In believing this, they've fallen into the same fallacy and delusion the Islamic radicals have for years. Essentially, as long as everyone believes God gave them the land there is no room for compromise and the killing will continue indefinatley; that's really sad.

Answer 6

If the Germans were not defeated during World War II, they could have controlled Middle East for its oil nowadays with no Arab countries and Israel to talk about.

Answer 7

There will be peace in the middle east if Muslims stop attacking Israel. I promise you that. Jews would share that land. Jews open the holy sites for all. Muslims are not capable of forgiveness.

Answer 8

Agreed. I think the nation of Isreal should be put in Germany. BTW Isreal does not represent all Jews anyways. The idea of creating a Zion initself is evil anyways.

Answer 9

THERE ARE NO SUCH PEOPLE AS PALESTINIANS!!!!!!
It is a term made up in the 1970's for political purposes.
There has never been an arab state in what is now Israel.
Arabs have been massacring Jews at least since the 1920,s- a quarter of a century BEFORE Israeli independence.
There were only a few nomads in that area before Jews started moving their.
Israel is the ancestral home of the Jews.

Answer 10

Rarely, when the British gave up territory, did it go successfully. They drew country borders without regard to tribes or cultural differences. Blame the British.