Why do many Jews think you cannot remain a Jew if you believe Jesus is the Messiah?

Question

The First Christians were all Jews and remained Jews while preaching Jesus Christ was the Messiah, Saviour to the world.

Answer 1

The First Christians did not believe that Jesus was God. The Christians broke away from Judaism because they couldn't find any Romans willing to be circumcized! It was in the 4th century and the Nicene creed when the Roman Catholic Church declared Jesus to be God that Christians made the final break away from Judaism.

Jesus Lives: Jews are NOT a race. A Jewish convert's children are all born Jews.

Any Jew that believes in the Trinity is a Christian -- not a Jew!
.

Answer 2

Jews that believe in Jesus Christ as the Messiah = Messianic Jews. Still Jews (race) but not practicing Judaism.

Answer 3

can you be a Christian and practice Islam?


So why can you call from Judayour self a Jew and practice Christianity?

The first Jews believed that Jesus was the messiah. That was not a problem, but when he died and was latter called the son of god your creating a religion that is separate from Judaism.

Answer 4

often maximum christians do no longer imagine he fulfilled them, thats the irony. maximum chrisitans sense that Jesus ought to ought to come lower back for a 2d attempt.... in Judaism if he has to go back lower back to do something of the pastime, which ability he wasn't it. besides that others have coated it. edit: >"Is it because he replaced into no longer huge-spread that the international did not finally end up accepting him and peace did not come, yet particularly Islam and different factions created which will wrestle on always?"< thats a capture 22, and in no way the way it somewhat works. in essence, you're saying that God did not comprehend the right time to deliver the messiah, and despatched him on the incorrect time? that doesn't make sense. and why might want to the messiah be huge-spread if he doesn't do the initiatives? why would his doing the initiatives rely on being huge-spread? that doesn't make sense both. btw i'm chuffed to communicate in mail if fascinated. edit2: >"both Jews and x-ians believe that human beings have free will. If human beings refuse to believe the Messiah replaced into the following, how ought to he in go back provide international peace, fantastically if therefore of the rejection it no longer in problem-free words pitted communities of persons adversarial to at least one yet another yet on accurate of it created Islam..."< you've it backwards. at the same time as the time is ideal the messiah will come and orchestrate the events. its no longer causing the events to take position at the same time as they in the different case weren't waiting to. for the Messiah that Judaism is gazing for, there is absolute self belief of recognition or non-recognition. the shape is only a remember of occurring. at the same time as it does, by what percentage believe it, it truly is going to likely be as sparkling as day. obtrusive because the rain. no longer a question of denying it or accepting it, yet purely recognizing that it truly is... with accessible somewhat being any discuss it. if the guy who replaced into to be the messiah got here, and did not fulfill the initiatives... then they weren't it. ... because they did not fulfill the initiatives. did you comprehend that many Jewish human beings sense that in each and each and every era, there's a "ability" messiah, that if the time is ideal, they'll blossom into being "the only" and fulfill the initiatives? the "ability" one isn't "it" till they do the pastime. finally at the same time as, is certain, as a lot as humanity, ... type of. yet a "the messiah" that doesn't fulfill the initiatives... isn't it.

Answer 5

cuz Jesus was still alive in flesh but now Jews converted have become Christians and need another church that understands!

Answer 6

I think that is a question for Jews for Jesus.

http://www.handlethetruth.net

Answer 7

Jewish do believe in Jesus.

Answer 8

Because you can't!